Hand over the crab: why arsenic turned out to be in a popular delicacy
The Primorsky branch of APK Natsryba found excess arsenic levels in four batches of live opilio strigun crab (aka snow crab) with a total weight of almost 174 tons. At the same time, the specialists of the institution noted that this crustacean is a bottom—dwelling animal, and it is in its habitats that the highest concentration of heavy metals and toxic elements is found. Izvestia investigated where the arsenic came from in the crab and, accordingly, at the bottom of the sea, and whether the ecological state of the fishing areas is generally known.
Which crab was found to contain arsenic
Inspectors of the Primorsky Interregional Rosselkhoznadzor Administration took samples of live opilio strigun crab, extracted by the enterprise from Vladivostok in the port of Primorye. The products were sent for inspection for the content of toxic elements. On November 12, the Primorsky branch of the Federal State Budgetary Institution "National Center for the Safety of Fish and Agricultural Products of the Agro-industrial Complex" (APK Natsryba, a structure subordinate to the Rosselkhoznadzor) confirmed the excess of arsenic levels (from 2.7 to four times) in four batches of crab with a total weight of almost 174 tons.
The information was entered into the federal information system "VetIS" and brought to the Primorsky Interregional Rosselkhoznadzor Administration.
"According to the specialists of the Primorsky branch, the crab is a bottom—dwelling animal, namely, heavy metals and toxic elements are contained in the highest concentration in the bottom sediments," the APK Natsryba added.
Since the beginning of the year, the Primorsky branch of Natsryba has found arsenic in live crab shipments 34 times.
How dangerous is arsenic in crab
Alexander Fomin, Executive Director of the Association of Industrial and Commercial Enterprises of the Fish Market, noted that arsenic is often found in crabs.
— The fact is that in Russia there are old regulations on this issue: in the world they do not look at arsenic in crab. The fact is that there is organic, and there is inorganic arsenic. Only inorganic is harmful to human health. Fishermen have been raising this topic for many years — 20-30 years for sure, but so far this issue has not been resolved: scientists say they need to conduct special research for which there is no funding. The supervisory authorities say that they cannot simply cancel the control," the source told Izvestia.
He added that expensive species of fish, crab, shrimp and other valuable benthic invertebrates that are not tested on the domestic market are mainly exported, where they are "gladly bought." The batches in which arsenic is detected are not destroyed — they can be exported to foreign markets.
Valentina Slobodskova, a leading researcher at the Laboratory of Marine Ecotoxicology of the TOI Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, explained that common arsenic includes all chemical forms of this element, but its organic varieties predominate in seafood, primarily arsenobetaine. It has significantly lower toxicity than inorganic arsenic, which is dangerous to health. And the excess of the total arsenic content in the strigoi crab may be due precisely to the natural accumulation of the element by bottom organisms and the characteristics of a particular fishing area.
— The strigun crab belongs to the bottom species, and arsenic is naturally present in the marine environment and can concentrate in bottom sediments, — she specified.
According to the expert, in various water areas, the arsenic content in crab muscles varies from 3.5 to 78.6 mg/kg of crude weight. And most often it is an organic, less toxic form of the compound. For example, in a 1986 paper on the strigoi crab from the Sea of Japan, the proportion of organic arsenic was 90%; Norwegian monitoring showed 93%. The World Health Organization (WHO) also points out that arsenic in fish and shellfish is predominantly in a less toxic organic form, and consumption of fish and shellfish is usually not the main source of exposure to inorganic arsenic.
The editorial's interlocutor stressed that it is incorrect to directly compare the values obtained: when the total arsenic content is exceeded, the volume of its inorganic and organic variants does not increase proportionally. Products exceeding the standard may meet the European requirements for inorganic arsenic and vice versa.
— At the same time, this does not exclude the need for control — when confirming that a particular batch does not meet the established requirements, it is subject to restrictions in circulation, — added Valentina Slobodskova.
The scientist recommended that consumers not draw conclusions about all products based on the results of studies of a single batch.
Vadim Petrov, Deputy Director of the United Scientific Center of the Ministry of Natural Resources of the All-Russian Research Institute "Ecology", Chairman of the Public Council at the Russian Hydrometeorological Institute, noted that both the joint expert committee of the FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) and WHO, in the reassessment of arsenic published in 2026, consider its chemical forms separately.
"At the same time, it is wrong to consider any organic arsenic compounds harmless: there are still insufficient toxicological and exposure data for a number of them," he said. — By the amount of total arsenic, it is impossible to determine what proportion is accounted for by the most dangerous forms, therefore, such an analysis does not replace the establishment of chemical forms and the assessment of human exposure.
What does this say about the state of the seas
Vadim Petrov noted that the products were taken at the port of Primorye, but it was not specified where the crab was extracted. Without the coordinates of the catch, the results of the analysis of water and sediments, as well as information on the chemical forms of arsenic, it is incorrect to talk about the contamination of a specific water area of Primorye.
— In my opinion, repeated finds from the same fishing area should become the basis for a coordinated interdepartmental risk assessment. Rosselkhoznadzor has the results of product control, Rosrybolovstvo and VNIRO have information on fishing and bioresources, and Roshydromet has environmental monitoring," he said.
According to the expert, in order to establish the environmental cause of pollution, it is necessary to find out the origin of the catch before the area and time of extraction, compare the results for other batches from the same place, check the chemical forms of arsenic and determine whether there are grounds for an environmental survey.
— Marine organisms really serve as bioindicators — they accumulate substances over a certain period of time. But the result depends on the species, age, nutrition, organ under study, season and natural geochemical background," the expert added.
Alexander Fomin drew attention to the fact that there are currently no regions closed to fishing due to the environmental situation, with the exception of restrictions in the Azov and Black Seas after the tanker accident. In general, the fishing areas are quite prosperous, and the levels of product control make it possible to consider it safe: there are studies by Rosrybolovstvo and its institutes; supervision by Rosprirodnadzor and Rosselkhoznadzor; as well as the Rospotrebnadzor control system, which already concerns goods coming to retail.
Vadim Petrov noted that there is a problem with the ecological state of the water areas, but it is heterogeneous, differing in territories, substances and types of organisms.
— It would be a methodological mistake to put the industrial bay, the open area of the Sea of Okhotsk and the remote fishing area under one assessment. There is a review of research on commercial organisms in the Russian part of the Northwestern Pacific Ocean for 2010-2018. He showed that the samples examined generally met the standards with individual exceedances, including arsenic in crustaceans. But this result also characterizes the studied materials of that period, without guaranteeing the safety of today's parties," the expert emphasized.
Similarly, one bay cannot be used to judge all the Far Eastern seas and especially their fishing regions, Vadim Petrov said.
This was also pointed out by Evgeniya Petrova, Senior researcher at the Laboratory of Hydrological Processes and Climate at the TOI Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. According to her, a number of research teams at the Pacific Institute of the Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences conducted monitoring on the content of heavy metals in seawater, bottom sediments and aquatic organisms of the coastal waters of the Sea of Japan. Heavy metal pollution was detected in the Uglovoy Bay (Amur Bay, Peter the Great Bay, Sea of Japan) as a result of economic activity on its coast. Studies of bottom sediments in Novik Bay (Peter the Great Bay, Sea of Japan) showed an increased content of nickel, cobalt, cadmium, zinc, copper and mercury. In the Zolotoy Rog Bay in the same bay, the analysis also revealed a high degree of contamination of bottom sediments — there it was affected by three sunken objects and three sites containing petroleum products and heavy metals.
But these waters are not commercial, and the research was of a local or fragmentary nature, the Izvestia interlocutor emphasized.
Vadim Petrov noted that Russia has a scientific and organizational basis for monitoring the condition of both water areas and aquatic biological resources. Roshydromet and its scientific institutions, fisheries science, and institutes of the Russian Academy of Sciences are engaged in state observations.
— However, the effectiveness of the entire system is also determined by how quickly the laboratory signal helps to identify the causes and prevent a recurrence of the problem. The coverage of observations should be compared with the geography of the fishery. Marine observations should be assessed by how well they cover specific fishing areas, what substances are being investigated, how regularly samples are taken, and whether water, sediments, and organisms can be analyzed together, he said.
The expert added that the official yearbook of the N.N. Zubov State Oceanographic Institute for 2024 summarizes data on 62 local sites of 12 seas obtained by 16 chemical laboratories of the Russian Hydrometeorological Service. This document notes that most of the controlled water areas are clean or moderately polluted, and the most problematic areas are port and estuary areas with high anthropogenic load (petroleum products, metals, biogens, organic substances). In general, studies by Roshydromet, VNIRO and other scientific institutes indicate that the open areas of the Okhotsk, Bering Seas and the northwestern Pacific Ocean are generally favorable for the main fishing facilities. The problem areas remain mainly coastal and port water areas: Avacha Bay in Kamchatka, certain areas of Peter the Great Bay and local areas near settlements and enterprises.
However, there is a problem of insufficient research all over the world, Vadim Petrov believes. The third UN World Ocean Assessment, published in 2026, indicates that operational observations still cover more physical parameters than biological ones. The World Meteorological Organization, in its review dated November 5, 2026, also speaks about the continuing gaps in observations and the need for sustainable financing.
— I consider it extremely necessary to develop in Russia a unified interdepartmental program for environmental monitoring of commercial marine areas, relying on existing institutions and their competencies. A single program should link the catch, ecosystem, and solution. Its task is to link the origin of the catch, the state of the ecosystem and the decision on response measures," said Vadim Petrov.
He also proposed five measures: to identify priority fishing areas and control areas; to link the results of analyses to the place and date of catch, the type of fish and the tissue studied; to establish an interagency response to pollution detection; to unify laboratory techniques; to ensure multi-year monitoring funding and annual publication of results for fishing areas. If an increased arsenic content is detected, in his opinion, it is necessary to determine its chemical forms separately.
Izvestia sent a request to Roshydromet, Rosselkhoznadzor, Rosrybolovstvo, APK Natsryba and the Ministry of Agriculture. No responses had been received at the time of publication.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»