Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Doctors explained the benefits of bitter chocolate for blood vessels

Doctor Kuzmichev: dark chocolate moderately reduces blood pressure
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Bitter chocolate has long been surrounded by the reputation of a healthy delicacy: they explain the benefits for the heart, blood vessels and even mood. But to what extent these promises correspond to the data and how much chocolate can really be eaten without harm, Tatyana Nechitailo, a gastroenterologist at the Scandinavian Health Center, and Mikhail Kuzmichev, a cardiovascular surgeon and phlebologist, told Izvestia on November 16.

What is known about the benefits of cocoa for blood vessels

It is logical to start talking about the benefits of chocolate with cocoa, because it is from its share in the tile that the content of flavanols depends — plant polyphenols, which are associated with the effect on blood vessels. The higher the percentage of cocoa, the more of these compounds there are: milk chocolate contains little cocoa mass, a lot of sugar and milk, and white chocolate does not contain it at all, so it is not a functional product. Dark chocolate from 55% cocoa can already be considered as a product with a potential effect, but only if it replaces other sweets, and is not added to the diet.

"Flavanols are natural polyphenols from cocoa beans. In simple words, they improve the functioning of the inner layer of blood vessels, stimulate the production of nitric oxide, due to which the vessels relax and blood flow improves," Kuzmichev noted.

According to him, there is evidence that flavanols moderately reduce blood pressure, improve vascular elasticity, reduce inflammation and platelet aggregation, and slightly improve the lipid profile. However, the scale of these effects should not be exaggerated. Chocolate does not replace the treatment of hypertension, and although there is a link with heart attacks, strokes and type II diabetes, it is modest and mainly based on observational studies.

In meta-analyses, dark chocolate was associated with a reduction in the risk of coronary heart disease by about 10%, stroke by about 16%, and type 2 diabetes by 18-21%, but this is a lifestyle factor with moderate influence, not a medicine. In addition, the composition of cocoa products varies greatly, and a store-bought tile cannot be equated with an extract with a precisely known amount of flavanols.

Does chocolate affect the intestines and mood

Some of the cocoa polyphenols reach the large intestine, where they are processed by bacteria, and this is why people are talking about the effect of chocolate on mood. After cocoa products, a short-term improvement in mood is possible, but there is not enough data yet to promise a lasting anti-stress effect or recommend chocolate for the treatment of anxiety disorder. Changes in the composition of intestinal bacteria and emotional state may occur simultaneously, but this does not prove that one caused the other.

"Cocoa ingredients can act as prebiotics. Some of the cocoa polyphenols reach the large intestine, where they are processed by bacteria. However, this does not prove that any chocolate bar improves digestion," explained Nechitailo.

The gut—brain axis means a two-way connection between the digestive and nervous systems, which is supported by nerve signals, hormones, and substances produced by intestinal bacteria. Nutrition can influence these processes, but it's too early to say that chocolate reduces anxiety in this way. A variety of plant—based foods—vegetables, fruits, legumes, and whole grains- provide food for bacteria, and chocolate can complement this diet, but it does not replace it.

Does chocolate relieve stress due to magnesium and theobromine

While the prebiotic effect of cocoa remains more of a hypothesis, magnesium and theobromine are often referred to as an almost ready-made recipe for stress relief. However, theobromine is similar in chemical structure to caffeine, but their effects differ, and its calming effect has not been convincingly confirmed. Chocolate also contains caffeine: large portions, especially in the evening, can make it difficult to fall asleep or increase anxiety in people who are sensitive to it.

"Magnesium is needed for the normal functioning of the nervous system and muscles. However, its presence in the product does not prove that this product treats anxiety. Trying to make up for the alleged magnesium deficiency with large portions of chocolate is also not worth it," said Nechitailo.

The possible effect of cocoa on mood is also associated with flavanols, but the effect of a particular substance is difficult to separate from the effect of the product as a whole and the pleasure of its taste. The formula "magnesium plus theobromine equals stress protection" oversimplifies what is happening, so chocolate should not be considered a universal remedy for relaxation.

Who can chocolate hurt?

Moderation is important in consumption — chocolate has limitations. A confirmed allergy to its components requires that such a product be excluded: the packaging should check the composition, including milk and nuts, and warnings about their possible traces. Milk can get into dark chocolate during production, even if it was not added according to the recipe, so the name "dark" in itself does not guarantee safety for a person with such an allergy.

"With reflux, chocolate increases heartburn in some people. Discomfort occurs more often after a heavy, greasy meal and when you get into the habit of going to bed soon after it," Nechitailo warned.

It is wrong to prohibit chocolate for all people with stomach diseases without taking into account tolerance. The connection with migraines is less clear: some people think that the attack begins after chocolate, but cravings for sweets sometimes occur at the beginning of the attack itself, before the headache, and by coincidence alone it is impossible to determine the cause with certainty.

A separate category is "sugar—free" chocolate: it sometimes contains sugar alcohols, such as sorbitol or maltitol, which cause bloating and loose stools in some people, especially in large quantities, and people with irritable bowel syndrome may tolerate such products worse. Kuzmichev added that it is better for people with diabetes, obesity or impaired carbohydrate metabolism to coordinate the amount of chocolate with their doctor.

How to choose chocolate and how much you can eat

The practical guideline for bitter chocolate is from 70% cocoa: it usually contains less sugar than in sweeter versions, but its amount must be checked on the package. The percentage of cocoa does not show the exact content of flavanols — their amount is influenced by raw materials and processing.

The composition should be studied in its entirety, especially the filling: it is more convenient to compare the amount of sugar and calorie content based on the same weight of the product, for example, per 100 grams. The label "sugar-free" does not mean that the product is low in calories or well tolerated by the intestines.

"Without harm to the figure, they usually focus on 20-30 grams of dark chocolate per day, preferably from 70% cocoa. This is about 2-4 small pieces. It is important to take into account the caloric content and sugar in the overall diet," Kuzmichev concluded.

The opinion that "palm oil kills all the benefits" is incorrect: it contains a lot of saturated fats, the amount of which in the diet should be limited, but cocoa butter also serves as a source of these fats. A tile without palm oil still remains a high-calorie sweet, for which the serving size matters. The best choice is chocolate with a high cocoa content, less sugar among similar options and without additives that a person cannot tolerate.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast