The lawyer spoke about the dangers of using AI in the divorce process
Using ChatGPT and other neural networks in a divorce can result in legal errors and delay the litigation. Artificial intelligence is able to invent non-existent legal norms, misinterpret the rights of spouses and give incorrect recommendations on the division of property. Lawyer and human rights activist Ekaterina Kutuzova, a member of the Adyghe Republican Bar Association, told Izvestia on November 16.
"The responses from ChatGPT and other neural networks are not a legal argument in disputes between spouses and cannot be considered by a court as independent evidence or a source of law. The printout of the correspondence with the chatbot represents the opinion of the program, which does not have special legal knowledge and is not responsible for the accuracy of the information provided," the expert explained.
Kutuzova called the so-called hallucinations of artificial intelligence one of the main dangers of using neural networks when preparing documents for divorce. We are talking about cases when the program generates non-existent articles of legislation, fictitious court decisions and incorrect legal references.
In addition, neural networks may not take into account procedural deadlines, rules of jurisdiction, and requirements for filing a claim. As a result, the court may leave the document without movement or return it to remedy the deficiencies. This can delay the divorce process and lead to a loss of time.
The lawyer noted that chatbots can also incorrectly explain their rights to citizens. Artificial intelligence does not have the materials of a specific case, cannot independently examine the evidence and assess all the circumstances of a family conflict. Therefore, the universal recommendations of the neural network are not always applicable to a particular situation.
Certain risks arise when dividing jointly acquired property. As Kutuzova explained, the determination of the spouses' shares depends on the ownership regime, the existence of a prenuptial agreement, the interests of minor children and other legally significant circumstances.
The neural network cannot fully evaluate the evidence, establish the legal status of each property object, and take into account the specifics of judicial practice. Therefore, the chatbot's calculations can only be used as preliminary information, but not as a basis for building a position in court.
The specialist stressed that artificial intelligence can be an auxiliary tool for finding general information, but it is better to trust a qualified lawyer to prepare legally relevant documents and assess the prospects for a family dispute.
Olga Dovgilova, Managing Partner of Dovgilova & Partners Law Firm, said on April 19 that a prenuptial agreement allows you to resolve property issues in advance and reduce the risk of conflicts during divorce, especially in families with assets, businesses or children from previous marriages. The specialist stressed that the key stage is not the signing of the document, but the discussion of its terms. An open dialogue between partners helps to reduce tension and form a common understanding of the objectives of the agreement.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»