With a stone in his bosom: Paris suspects Berlin of preparing for nuclear escalation
France fears Europe will be drawn into a nuclear war with Russia over German missiles. Paris insists on a public doctrine for the use of the secret Deep Precision Strike (DPS) program in order to rule out a scenario in which Moscow "misinterprets the signal" and responds with a nuclear strike. Germany acknowledges the concerns, but points to internal discussions in France. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
France is alarmed
France demands that Germany determine how it will use its long-range missiles in the event of a conflict with the Russian Federation. This is reported by The Financial Times, citing six sources.
The concern of the French authorities is caused by the desire of Germany to obtain long-range weapons, as well as a possible response from Russia. The lack of clarity, according to Paris, creates the risk of unintentionally dragging Europe into a nuclear war.
In particular, France fears that an attack on a target in Russia could be carried out using conventional weapons, and Moscow would launch a nuclear strike in response. "If Russia misinterprets the signal, it may be on the verge of nuclear war without even realizing it," the newspaper quoted one of the sources as saying.
As part of the "advanced deterrence" doctrine announced by French President Emmanuel Macron, responsibility for the actions of partners can also be assigned to the Fifth Republic as a nuclear power. One source put it this way: "If you invite someone into your house, you respond if they set it on fire."
Russian President Vladimir Putin has repeatedly stated that the use of long-range weapons would mean that the West is at war with Russia. "We are talking about making a decision on whether NATO countries are directly involved in a military conflict or not," the head of state explained. At the same time, he has repeatedly said that the Russian Federation does not threaten anyone, like all other nuclear powers, developing "its strategic potential."
"We are not threatening anyone, we are not going to attack anyone — neither in the 29th, nor in the 30th, nor in the 50th year," the president assured. He also pointed out that from a military-technical point of view, Russia is ready for a nuclear war, but is not going to unleash it.
The secret missile program
Britain and Germany have initiated a secret Deep Precision Strike missile program worth about €35 billion, under which Germany, Germany, Poland, the Baltic States and the Nordic countries are purchasing a number of non-nuclear land-based missiles that can hit targets deep within the territory of the Russian Federation.
According to the program, it is planned to develop a missile with a range of up to 2,000 km by 2034. At the same time, two types of missiles are considered: hypersonic, developing a speed five times faster than the speed of sound, and low-flying cruise missiles.
France is committed to bringing the DPS in line with its nuclear strategy. Back in May, the media reported on Paris' desire to join this program to create long-range missiles.
Emmanuel Macron wants his country to provide Europe with a "nuclear umbrella" and has proposed the concept of "advanced nuclear deterrence." Together with their German counterparts, the French authorities have set up a nuclear management group to hold consultations on conventional weapons, missile defense and the French nuclear potential.
In addition, the parties agreed that Berlin will begin to participate in French nuclear exercises, as well as visit French strategic facilities.
Germany has already allocated €780 billion for defense spending in the five-year period up to 2030, and as part of this budget, it is acquiring and developing land-based missiles with a range of 500 to more than 2,000 km. This is a qualitatively new tool for a country that, after 1945, built its identity around restraint and abandonment of an independent nuclear program.
One of the sources of The Financial Times added that France was able to develop a kind of nuclear grammar and vocabulary. "We have habits that have developed over time. The Germans don't have them," he said, adding that it would be better "to have a clear public doctrine so that the Russian Federation would never misinterpret or misunderstand the signal."
A common approach is possible
A senior German official, commenting on the situation, confirmed that Berlin shares Paris' concerns. "This is not at all what the French are demanding, but we are resisting," he pointed out. — The acquisition of DPS capabilities inevitably had to be accompanied by a common understanding of how to apply them. It was clear from the very beginning."
According to him, the negotiations were delayed not because of German resistance, but because of internal discussions on the French side regarding the future of its own nuclear strategy. One possible outcome could be a joint statement by Germany, France and the United Kingdom, which would formulate their common approach.
The issue of developing long—range missiles is not a quick matter, said Pavel Timofeev, head of the Regional Problems and Conflicts Sector at the IMEMO RAS.
— Germany has indeed maintained a rather cautious position until recently, especially against the background of the Franco-British plans for a "coalition of the willing." Therefore, it is still difficult for me to imagine that the Germans will radically change their policy now. Especially when these long—range missiles are not yet available," the political scientist said in an interview with Izvestia.
According to the expert, France is most likely afraid not so much of the consequences of a rather speculative escalation, as of the fact that the presence of such weapons could reduce the demand for the French nuclear shield.
— As for the precedent that NATO and EU countries act contrary to the interests of the other, this is not news. France and Germany regularly have disputes on foreign policy issues," the expert explained.
At the same time, the analyst stressed that Paris and Berlin usually find compromises on them.
— And if they don't, they don't really highlight these differences in public. Therefore, I do not see any split," Timofeev summed up.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»