Dead souls: the late politician leads in the US elections
In the USA, the deceased candidate is leading in the local elections in California. Moreover, he surpasses his live opponent in the number of votes by as much as 14%. However, he will not have to take office, because the governor himself will appoint a temporary representative of the district until there are successors to the post of the dead man. Why Americans voted for the deceased, and how this is even possible, is in the Izvestia article.
The dead in politics
In the American district of Calaveras, California, candidate Bruce Giudici, who died two months ago, is leading the elections to the board of governors of the district. According to the election commission, the deceased politician won the support of 56.99% of voters, while his main rival— Clyde Clapp— scored only 43.01%. However, the final voting results have not been announced: about 660 ballots are still being processed.
Giudici, 68, died on August 31 when he fell down the steep driveway while walking around the voters. The candidate's name remained on the ballots because he died after the deadline set by law, during which it was possible to amend the electoral forms and exclude the deceased. This is also why the votes cast for the politician are taken into account when calculating the results.
The headquarters of the deceased candidate continued to urge voters to vote for him even after his death. The team explained this as a desire to prevent Clapp from returning to the board of governors. It is noteworthy that Giudici was also ahead of his current opponent in the June primaries: he received 36.9% of the vote, while Clapp received 35.6%. The current member of the council, Benjamin Stopper, took third place and did not qualify for the November round of elections.
If Giudici gets the majority of votes after the end of the counting and approval of the results, he will be recognized as elected. However, even in this case, the place of the deceased politician will not remain vacant for a long time. In such cases, a person is appointed to this position by the governor of the state. In particular, Gavin Newsom will approve the one who will temporarily serve on the board until a successor is found.
American political scientist Malek Dudakov told Izvestia that for American politics, such a story, although it looks unusual, is actually quite familiar: in the United States, there have been cases before when deceased candidates received votes and even won elections. Similar precedents have occurred in both Republican and Democratic states.
— Therefore, after the possible victory of Giudici, there will be two ways out of the situation. The first is the appointment of a temporary representative, who could theoretically be the widow of a deceased candidate. The second option is to hold special elections, where voters will be able to choose a new representative. In any case, the final decision will be made in accordance with California law, which regulates the procedure for filling vacant positions in local governments," the expert explained.
The impossible is possible
Giudici's case turned out to be very revealing and quite vividly characterizes the US electoral system. It turns out that bureaucratic procedures and laws that are not always understandable to the layman deftly border on democratic principles that are revered by American politicians and citizens.
Speaking of earlier cases like the one in California, it's worth remembering the 2000 U.S. Senate elections. In Missouri, at that time, the incumbent Republican Senator John Ashcroft was fighting for his re-election, and his main opponent was Democrat Mel Carnahan, who held the post of governor of the state at that time.
However, three weeks before the vote, Carnahan died in a plane crash. His son and one of his closest assistants were on board with him. By that time, the preparations for the elections were almost completed: the ballots were printed, and the deadline stipulated by law for the nomination of a new candidate had expired. The name of the deceased remained on the forms.
However, shortly before the start of the election, a way out of the situation was found: the widow of Governor Jean Carnahan declared her readiness to take a seat in the Senate if voters cast their votes to her deceased husband. The deceased eventually gained about 50% of the vote, leaving behind the Republican senator. Then Carnahan became the first woman to represent the state of Missouri in the U.S. Senate.
It is noteworthy that in the United States, it is also common practice for the deceased themselves to "vote." Such scandals often arise on the eve of elections in the country. For example, in January 2024, the Florida authorities reviewed the electoral rolls and found many dead people in them. Immediately after the removal procedure, the share of Democrats among the state's voters fell by 10% — about 500 thousand votes — and the number of Republicans decreased by only 3% or 150 thousand people.
Before that, in 2020, "dead souls" took part in the voting in New York. The Board of Elections received a ballot previously sent to an elector born in 1915, who lived in the Staten Island area and died back in 2012. Moreover, the form was initially recognized as valid. A similar situation occurred in another area of New York - Brooklyn. An unknown person, on behalf of an elector born in 1919, requested a ballot by mail in September, and then participated in the elections in November.
— Such situations occur because different states have different electoral laws, and the process of voting and counting votes is not always properly controlled. As for voting in California, I would suggest that this is some kind of "tribute" to the deceased, whom the voters probably considered a worthy person. The electoral procedure is such that, in any case, after some time, "re-elections" will take place, where the person who will join the board of governors of the district will be determined," concluded international commentator Andrei Kuzmak.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»