Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The fake interview led to the largest robbery in the history of cryptocurrencies. Who pays

The price of saving Binance: how the largest crypto exchange will pay for hacking
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The main thing in the material:

  • Hackers stole $6.3 billion worth of cryptocurrency from Binance. The attack began with a fictitious interview, during which the computer of an employee of the exchange was infected.
  • The attackers continued to withdraw cryptocurrency even after the hack was discovered. It was possible to stop operations only after revoking special permissions in the blockchain.
  • Binance has already replenished 98% of the stolen assets and restored the full security of 10 major cryptocurrencies.
  • The company did not have a cyber insurance policy. To compensate for the damage, the exchange used its own funds and protective funds. SAFU's bitcoin reserves have halved, and the monitored futures insurance funds have lost about 25% of their volume in a day.
  • After the attack, the exchange temporarily suspended the withdrawal of cryptocurrencies. Operations began to resume on November 1. In the first 46 hours, the net outflow of client funds reached $5.3 billion. However, asset withdrawal is not a direct loss to the exchange.
  • Binance does not disclose consolidated financial statements. With an annual trading turnover of $34 trillion, the real income, profits and volume of the exchange's own reserves remain unknown.

Binance, the largest cryptocurrency exchange, has revealed new circumstances of a record $6.3 billion hack. The attack took place in several stages: the attackers organized a fictitious interview with an employee of the company, infected his computer with malicious code and gained access to the internal infrastructure of the exchange. Hackers were withdrawing crypto assets even after the breach was detected — within a few hours. By early November, the company announced that 98% of the stolen funds had been replenished, but for this it had to use the corporate treasury and protective funds. The traditional insurance system does not protect the site from such losses — the incident raised the question of the financial model of the entire industry, in which the largest players independently assume catastrophic risks. Izvestia investigated how much Binance's financial strength has decreased and whether the company will be able to withstand another crisis.

Billions to rebuild

According to Binance's preliminary investigation, in September, attackers disguised as employers contacted an employee of the exchange. He passed two fictitious interviews, including with the alleged CEO, after which he received a test assignment with malicious code. After its launch, hackers (according to the FBI, from North Korea) gained access to Binance's corporate infrastructure, and then used an AI tool to infiltrate internal systems. They carried out the attack on October 29. The attackers continued to withdraw assets for almost four hours, including after the hack was discovered. As explained in Binance, hackers received special permissions in advance to conduct operations directly on the blockchain. This allowed them to transfer cryptocurrency without having to access the exchange's internal systems again. Therefore, blocking the withdrawal of funds on the site itself did not stop operations: the company had to revoke the permissions in the blockchain separately, which took several hours. As a result, the hackers managed to withdraw $6.3 billion worth of crypto assets from the exchange.

Izvestia reference

The attackers stole cryptocurrency from wallets managed by Binance, rather than directly from individual user accounts. The Binance 14 wallet was at the center of the attack. An analysis of the blockchain showed that 167.5 thousand ETH was withdrawn from it during the hack, and about 28 thousand ETH was withdrawn from another Binance 16 wallet. These are the so-called hot wallets, in which the exchange stores cryptocurrency for operations. The funds serve as collateral for obligations to customers.

For example, if there were 10 ETH in the user's account before the hack, the theft of cryptocurrency from the Binance wallet does not mean that these 10 ETH will be automatically debited from his balance. The exchange's obligation to return the appropriate amount of cryptocurrency to the client remains. However, after the theft of real assets, there are fewer such obligations to fulfill. Thus, according to the exchange on October 1, its ETH reserves fully corresponded to its obligations to customers — the security ratio was 100%. The theft of approximately 205,000 ETH, according to CoinDesk, could have reduced this figure to about 94% if Binance had not replenished the stolen tokens.

After the hack, Binance undertook to compensate for the losses on its own. According to the latest data, the exchange has recovered 98% of the lost assets. At the same time, the company has fully restored the provision of 10 major affected cryptocurrencies, including bitcoin, Ethereum, USDT and BNB. The remaining part was accounted for by less liquid tokens, which are more difficult to purchase quickly.

To compensate for the damage, Binance used not only its own corporate funds, but also two types of special reserves. The first is the SAFU fund, created by the exchange to protect users' assets. According to CoinDesk, after four transactions on October 31, the number of bitcoins in the fund halved from 15,000 to about 7.5 thousand. On November 3, the remaining assets were estimated at about $580 million. Binance promised to restore the fund's volume to $1 billion.

The second source is the insurance funds of the futures platform, designed to cover losses during the forced closure of unprofitable trades by traders. Binance claims that after the funds were redistributed, the funds retained reserves above the level necessary to cover trading risks. At the same time, independent data show that the volume of these reserves has changed significantly. According to Swolecharts, on November 1, the total volume of Binance's monitored funds was about $1.85 billion, having decreased by almost 25% per day. It follows from this that previously the volume of reserves was approximately $2.46 billion, and the reduction reached about $600 million.

Despite the name, we are not talking about traditional insurance, but about Binance's internal protective reserves. The company independently forms these funds and covers losses at their expense, without the participation of a third-party insurer. At the same time, Binance did not disclose exactly how much money it sent to compensate for the damage from each source. Changing the balance sheets of funds does not allow us to determine these amounts, since they are affected, among other things, by ordinary trading operations.

Izvestia reference

To confirm the security of client funds, Binance uses the Proof of Reserves (PoR) mechanism, or proof of reserves. It allows you to check whether the exchange has enough cryptocurrencies to fulfill its obligations to users.

For verification, Binance takes a so—called snapshot of reserves, a fixed set of data that calculates the availability of user funds. Such a report reflects the situation on a specific date, and does not guarantee that the volume of reserves will remain unchanged in the future. Proof of Reserves is not a full-fledged audit of a company's financial condition.

Binance founder Changpeng Zhao compared the consequences of the hack with the crises of the Mt. Gox and FTX crypto exchanges, noting that almost all users suffered then. The Japanese platform, which was at one time the largest bitcoin exchange, declared bankruptcy in 2014 after the attackers withdrew about 650 thousand. BTC is equivalent to $370 million in the prices of that time or $50 billion in the current ones. For comparison, Binance lost 18 thousand bitcoins. In 2022, the American FTX went bankrupt, but its collapse was not due to an external attack, but to financial violations and illegal use of client assets. In both cases, users faced lengthy refund procedures that have not yet been completed. At the same time, the creditors of Mt. Gox could receive payments in cryptocurrency, and FTX clients were compensated based on the dollar value of their assets at the time of bankruptcy, rather than at current market prices.

At the same time, the assets of $6.34 billion that hackers have withdrawn from Binance should not yet be considered a final loss. It is known that the exchange and its partners managed to freeze about $2.8 billion of the total amount stolen. The freeze prevents further movement of funds, but the timing of their return remains uncertain. If the exchange manages to get them back, the direct damage will amount to about $3.5 billion, excluding changes in the value of cryptocurrencies and additional costs for rebuilding the cybersecurity system.

Izvestia reference

The Binance hack raised the issue of insuring multibillion-dollar losses of cryptocurrency platforms. According to sources, the exchange did not have a cyber insurance policy that could cover the damage from the attack. Experts note that the possibilities of digital asset insurance are limited: existing programs are not designed for losses of this scale. In addition, insurance contracts may provide exceptions for cyber attacks related to foreign countries.

Therefore, even large cryptocurrency platforms are forced to take on the risks themselves, which in the traditional financial system can be partially transferred to insurers. This model allows you to quickly mobilize resources without waiting for the decision of the insurance company. However, catastrophic losses in this case directly affect the financial capabilities of the business.

Stability check

Another consequence for Binance was the large-scale outflow of client funds after the incident. After the attack, the exchange temporarily suspended the withdrawal of cryptocurrencies. Operations began to resume on November 1, in stages, for individual digital assets and blockchain networks. First of all, access was opened to the most sought-after cryptocurrencies, including bitcoin and Ethereum.

In the first nine and a half hours after the resumption of operations, users withdrew $4.65 billion from the site and deposited $1.01 billion. In the first 46 hours, the withdrawal volume reached almost $11 billion, while receipts totaled $5.7 billion. The net outflow amounted to $5.3 billion, or 3.1% of assets on the Binance platform, the value of which was estimated at $171 billion before the hack. On November 3, the situation began to stabilize: hourly receipts exceeded the volume of withdrawals.

At the same time, the monitored balances of bitcoin, Ethereum and stablecoins on the exchange's wallets remained below the level recorded before the attack. According to CryptoQuant on November 8, the number of bitcoins in the wallets of the exchange decreased from about 730 thousand to 674 thousand. The difference was about 56,000 BTC, or $4.2 billion at the market price. The reserves of stablecoins on the Ethereum network decreased by 22%, from $41 billion to $32 billion. However, the change in balances may reflect not only the withdrawal of funds by customers, but also the consequences of theft of assets, as well as internal movements of cryptocurrencies.

At the same time, the outflow of client assets should not be considered Binance's loss. These funds belong to users, and their withdrawal reduces both the volume of assets stored on the exchange and its obligations to customers. However, mass withdrawal requests become a test of the platform's ability to return funds in a timely manner, especially after multibillion-dollar losses. The first data shows that Binance was able to resume operations and process a significant volume of applications.

Will Binance have enough money for a second strike

Binance co-CEO Richard Teng stated that the exchange is in a stable financial position. It has more than 335 million users worldwide, and the average daily trading volume is $95 billion.

Binance has generally shown that it can find the resources to cover the damage from one major incident. However, this does not allow us to conclude that she still has a comparable reserve of available funds. The Company does not publish consolidated financial statements with data on revenue, net profit, equity and cash.

Only information about the amount of client transactions is publicly available — in 2025, the total trading volume on the site reached $34 trillion. For a conditional estimate of Binance's possible earnings, a calculation based on trading commissions can be used. According to the exchange's tariffs, the base commission for the purchase and sale of cryptocurrencies on the spot market is 0.1% of the transaction amount, and for individual futures transactions — 0.02%. If these rates are applied to the entire annual turnover, estimated commission income ranges from $6.8 billion to $34 billion. However, this is not an estimate of the exchange's actual revenue: commissions vary depending on the type of transactions, type of application, and customer service conditions.

Izvestia reference

Binance conducts business through several companies registered in different countries. Since January of this year, the global platform Binance.com It operates under the supervision of the financial regulator of the Abu Dhabi International Financial Center (ADGM). Three companies are responsible for different areas of its work: Nest Exchange provides exchange trading in cryptocurrencies and derivative financial instruments, Nest Clearing and Custody handles transaction settlements and storage of client assets, and Nest Trading provides over—the-counter operations.

Binance also has divisions in Europe — in France, Sweden, Spain, Italy and Poland. In particular, Binance France SAS is registered in Paris. According to the published reports, in 2025 its revenue amounted to 53.1 million euros, net profit — 11.8 million euros, and equity — 37.5 million euros.

At the same time, Binance faced difficulties in the European market. After the EU's transition to uniform rules for regulating cryptocurrencies, the company was supposed to get a new license, but so far it has not done so. In this regard, the exchange has required some European clients to withdraw assets and plans to close their accounts by the end of December. However, Binance still intends to obtain the necessary permission and continue operating in Europe.

The volume of remaining liquid funds, the restoration of protective funds and the actual return of frozen assets are of key importance for Binance's financial stability. At the same time, without data on real financial results and the amount of its own funds, it is impossible to reliably determine whether the exchange will be able to withstand another hack of this scale.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast