Phantom Oxen: how "paper animal husbandry" works in Russia
Rosselkhoznadzor specialists discovered a farm in the Kamchatka Territory, which, according to documents, had 296 farm animals, but during a real check there were none. The site was recognized as "phantom". There are not so few such peasant (farm) farms (KFHS) that exist only on paper — several thousand such organizations are discovered every year. With their help, they illegally receive subsidies and legalize products of unknown origin. Izvestia investigated why the market for "paper animal husbandry" persists despite existing product traceability systems.
How often are phantom enterprises discovered
Rosselkhoznadzor employees conducted monitoring of compliance with mandatory requirements for an unnamed farm located in the city of Yelizovo. According to information about the farm included in the components of the FGIS "VetIS", it has 146 heads of cattle and 150 small ones. On October 8, the staff went to the specified address, but they did not find any animals. The territory was examined, including from a drone, to no avail.
The company was described as having signs of a "phantom" (such companies produce and store products only according to documents). On October 30, the information was sent to the local Ministry of Agriculture to update information about the business entity.
Izvestia sent a request to the government of the Kamchatka Territory. No response has been received at the time of publication.
Phantom enterprises are identified regularly. The supervisory authority reported that 2,266 non-existent manufacturing enterprises and trade organizations were discovered in 2023, 2,091 in 2022, and 3,041 in 2021. At the same time, in July 2025, it was said that in six months, 2,091 "phantoms" were identified using the Mercury electronic veterinary certification system. It is important to note that these are not only livestock farms, but also agricultural enterprises.
Why are phantom farms created?
Rosselkhoznadzor regularly detects anomalies in statistics. In July 2026, in a review of the situation with the registration of dairy animals and the registration of the movement of raw milk, it was reported that deviations from the normal procedure for issuing veterinary certificates were found at 12.6% (9014) sites. Not a single head of cattle was registered for 1,377 of them, but their health certificates were issued. At 132, products were put into circulation, but there were no livestock registrations, no certificates were drawn up, and no raw milk was received from outside.
At the same time, the discrepancy between the real state of affairs and statistics is not always the result of malicious intent. The same review provides an example of the "enchanting creativity" of the Stavropol Territory State Lighting Service together with one of the companies. Veterinarians indicated in the system that this organization is the owner of 6.6 thousand heads of cattle, which were actually kept in 1748 private subsidiary farms of citizens in several villages of the region. Moreover, the site for keeping these animals was indicated without a specific address. Legally, this was the entry of deliberately false data into the federal information system, whereas in fact someone, as suggested in the review, simply wanted to simplify their work.
But, obviously, there are cases when this is not just a mistake. One of the reasons why phantom production can occur is an attempt to obtain subsidies for the development of farms from the state. In June 2026, the prosecutor's office of Buryatia reported on the convicted head of the farm, who indicated in the documents the presence of 100 heads of cattle instead of the actual 45. Thanks to this forgery, the man received a subsidy for the development of beef cattle breeding in the amount of more than 350 thousand rubles.
Anatoly Tikhonov, head of the Center for International Agribusiness and Food Security at the Presidential Academy, noted that even more often "phantoms" work as a channel for the legalization of raw materials of unknown origin. For example, last month in Rostov-on-Don, two non-existent production facilities were discovered through which electronic veterinary documentation for animal products was processed. From September to October, more than 300 documents for goods with a total weight of over 8.5 tons were registered through them. Phantom farms declared the import, export, storage and sale of livestock products, as well as issued documents for goods that were intended for social institutions.
"These facts indicate the introduction of low—quality and unsafe products of unknown origin," the local Rosselkhoznadzor administration reported at the time.
The very distortion of statistics can greatly harm the market, Anatoly Tikhonov emphasized. For example, when two phantom sites in the Astrakhan region "produced" 11.4 thousand tons of milk from nowhere (and this is a volume comparable to the production of a small area), the figures were included in official reports and were taken into account when assessing food safety.
— FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. In his reviews of food systems, he emphasizes that the reliability of supply chains and trust in data are one of the important components of planning," the expert said. — When statistics are littered with "phantoms" or incorrect data, the logic of allocating subsidies, forecasts of self-sufficiency, which are based on the Ministry of Agriculture and the Russian Academy of Sciences, collapses, etc.
Most often, the motives of abuse are combined, added Svetlana Shchepetkina, head of the Animal Health Group of Companies, veterinary epidemiologist, Candidate of Veterinary Sciences. At the same time, a scheme involving the legalization of products is more dangerous and more difficult to identify.
— If the documents are executed correctly, and the site is registered, the system sees the "legal" chain. It can be identified by analyzing discrepancies — production volumes do not correspond to livestock, seasonality is disrupted, the geography of supplies is suspicious — and by actual reconciliation of the availability of animals and capacities. Such analytics requires resources and interdepartmental data exchange — and this is not provided for in FGIS VetIS, the system finds errors only at the level of the entered data, which is easy enough to bypass, knowing the algorithms, the expert explained.
She clarified that the distortion can happen in both directions: "phantoms" overestimate the number of livestock, but there is also an underestimation — hiding livestock from accounting. Both options are dangerous for statistics.
— The consequences here are even more severe, because they are not hitting the budget, but epizootic well-being. Unaccounted-for animals do not undergo vaccinations, treatments and diagnostics and become a hidden reservoir of infection. In case of an outbreak, it is unclear where the cattle really are, which means that it is impossible either to localize the outbreak or to prove the well-being of the region. This is a direct threat to the country's food security," Svetlana Shchepetkina emphasized.
The specialist said that she had come across cases when the state veterinary service carried out vaccination only on paper or falsified research results in order to get rid of livestock and additional burden on service.
Why is the problem still persisting?
It is impossible to talk about the massive scale of fictitious productions "without relevant statistics," but the situation requires constant attention, said Lyudmila Manitskaya, director of the Dairy Union of Russia.
— It is necessary to note the great work that the Rosselkhoznadzor is doing to ensure the traceability of products of animal origin and to identify violations in the field of veterinary accounting. Modern information systems make it possible to detect inconsistencies that were previously much more difficult to identify," the Izvestia interlocutor noted.
The Mercury and Horriot systems turned into the main detector of "phantoms", but they did not kill such farms, Anatoly Tikhonov drew attention. These systems are being improved, conditions are changing: for example, starting from September 1, 2026, their integration has made it technically impossible to issue veterinary documents for milk without animals registered in the system. Automatic verification has become more difficult to circumvent, but if the initial information in the registry is false, the inclusion itself does not make them reliable, the expert explained.
The classic "phantoms" in their pure form, as in Kamchatka, when there are no cattle at all, are, according to Svetlana Shchepetkina, rather a residual phenomenon. Traceability systems have dramatically reduced the space for such abuses.
— But the problem has not disappeared, it has simply shifted to a zone of overestimation or underestimation of livestock, movement of animals and products between farms, etc., — said the specialist. — The system only records the entered data, but does not check the actual presence of animals or products.
A separate barrier is the access of small farmers to VetIS, the expert added. They themselves do not bring cattle into the system: this burden is assigned to the civil service, but no one is rationing.
— That is, there is a duty to label animals, but the vet service does not have the time and resources for it — it does this to the detriment of other duties that are so rigidly ignored. As a result, either accounting or epizootic work suffers. This is an institutional defect, not the negligence of specific services," Svetlana Shchepetkina is convinced.
It is possible to fix the system, she stressed, by suggesting entering a unique identifier of the animal, linked to the site and the owner, with reconciliation during movement. It is also important to establish time and resource standards for labeling, processing veterinary accompanying documents and taking them into account in evaluating the activities of the veterinary service on a par with vaccinations. At the same time, small farms can be given simplified access.
— In addition, proportionate sanctions for concealment are important. Responsibility is not only for "phantom" (inappropriate subsidies), but also for unaccounted—for livestock, which is directly related to the epizootic risk," explained the veterinary epidemiologist. — Incentives are also important, not just punishments. For small farms, this is support for legalization (labeling, access to the system), so that it is more profitable to be in the system than outside it.
Lyudmila Manitskaya is convinced that all its bona fide participants are interested in the purity of the market. Phantom farms create conditions for the appearance of products with unconfirmed origin and place honest producers in a deliberately unequal position.
— Some invest in animal husbandry, production and compliance with veterinary requirements, while others try to circumvent the established rules. Therefore, it is fundamentally important to continue improving the traceability system, develop digital control tools and increase the responsibility of turnover participants," the editorial interlocutor urged.
Izvestia sent inquiries to the Ministry of Agriculture of the Russian Federation and the Rosselkhoznadzor. No responses had been received at the time of publication.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»