Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The possible deprivation of Armenia's voting rights may be discussed at a meeting of the CSTO Collective Security Council on November 11. Yerevan has not paid contributions to the organization for more than two years and declares that its interest in it has dried up. Meanwhile, the Parliament of the republic told Izvestia that the issue of the country's withdrawal from the bloc is not currently being considered at the legislative level. At the same time, experts emphasize that sanctions against Yerevan do not mean the country's automatic exclusion from the CSTO.

The issue of Armenia's membership in the CSTO

Over the past few years, relations between the CSTO and Armenia have deteriorated dramatically. The republic has minimized its activities in the bloc, and Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has publicly announced that the country's interest in the structure has dried up and Yerevan aims to apply to the EU in 2027-2028.

вид на Ереван
Photo: Global Look Press/Russian Look

But despite the rhetoric of the republic's leadership, the official process of denouncing the Collective Security Treaty is not being launched through parliament. This document and the CSTO Charter are interstate agreements that have been ratified by the Armenian Parliament. Therefore, according to national legislation, if a country decides to officially withdraw from the organization, such a decision is impossible without the approval of the legislature.

Gegham Manukyan, a member of the Standing Committee on Defense and Security, told Izvestia that the republic's deputies are not currently discussing the issue of withdrawal from the CSTO.

"There are no steps in parliament, no initiatives about the CSTO, only statements by representatives of the ruling party and Nikol Pashinyan,— he said.

The Strong Armenia faction told Izvestia that they expect other members of the association to assess the current situation and further prospects for cooperation.

— Statements about the termination of cooperation with the organization are being made by the current authorities, and we are closely monitoring their further steps. At the same time, the assessments and positions of the CSTO member states regarding the current situation and future prospects of relations are also important for us," the faction noted.

The party stressed that since 2018, the current authorities have been responsible for building and developing cooperation with the CSTO on the part of Armenia.

Парламент Армении
Photo: Global Look Press/Gevorg Ghazaryan/xinhua

The government will not be able to bypass the Parliament of the republic if it decides to sever relations with the organization. Any statements by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan express only political will, but do not put an end to this issue. The National Assembly of Armenia has ratified the international treaty on the Collective Security Treaty Organization, therefore, according to the law, only deputies can denounce it through a vote. The procedure also requires the Constitutional Court of the Republic to check whether the withdrawal from the bloc does not contradict the basic law of the country. Only after this conclusion will the draft denunciation be submitted to the parliamentarians for consideration.

Meanwhile, the issue of depriving Armenia of the right to vote in the organization is on the agenda. Earlier, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Alexander Pankin said that the CSTO Collective Security Council, which will be held on November 11, may decide to temporarily restrict this right due to non-payment of membership fees for more than two years. At the same time, CSTO Secretary General Taalatbek Masadykov clarified that Russia has already prepared a draft document on the application of the corresponding 25th article of the charter to the republic. The official representative of the Russian Foreign Ministry, Maria Zakharova, also admitted that at the meeting the parties would discuss Yerevan's membership in the CSTO as a whole.

Technically, voice deprivation does not automatically mean leaving the block, explained Dmitry Sidorov, Head of the Department of Foreign Regional Studies at MGLU. However, according to him, the prime Minister is only looking for a convenient reason to completely curtail work with the allies, so such sanctions may put an end to Armenia's participation in the organization.

Although membership in the CSTO meets Armenia's national interests, the current authorities of the country, who have embarked on a course of geopolitical reorientation, believe otherwise. According to Hayk Khalatyan, head of the Analytical Center for Strategic Studies and Initiatives, the republic's leadership is doing everything to exclude her. At the same time, the prime minister is afraid to take such an initiative on his own because of the high political risks, Sidorov added.

Заседание Совета министров иностранных дел ОДКБ 10.06.2026

Meeting of the CSTO Council of Foreign Ministers on 10.06.2026

Photo: RIA Novosti/Maxim Bogodvid

Currently, Armenia participates in the CSTO de jure, but not de facto, although its representative continues to attend meetings of the permanent Council. If she withdraws from the organization herself, then all responsibility for any future escalation at the border will fall entirely on the current government. Europe will not provide Yerevan with security guarantees, while Turkey and Azerbaijan may perceive the period of geopolitical transit as a window of opportunity. This will allow them to increase diplomatic and military pressure to force the republic to give in to the dispute over the Zangezur Corridor, a strategic road through the Armenian south that Baku and Ankara need for direct communication bypassing Yerevan's control.

Withdrawal from the bloc, however, will not lead to the automatic curtailment of Russia's entire military presence. The base of the Russian Federation in Gyumri is not subordinate to the structures of the CSTO, since Moscow and Yerevan deployed it on the basis of a bilateral interstate agreement. Even if Armenia officially and completely severs relations with the organization, the base in Gyumri will legally continue to operate. In order to close the facility and withdraw troops, the republic's authorities will in any case need to prepare a separate bill and denounce this bilateral agreement.

Why is it unprofitable for Armenia to leave the CSTO

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan announced in early 2024 that the republic had "frozen" its participation in the CSTO. Yerevan has consistently boycotted all recent summits of the organization, refused to hold exercises of the bloc on its territory, recalled its permanent representative and completely stopped financing the structure without paying membership fees. Pashinyan bluntly stated that the CSTO "poses threats to the security and sovereignty of Armenia."

учения ОДКБ 2026

CSTO exercises 2026

Photo: TASS

Meanwhile, leaving the bloc would deprive the republic of serious material support, since cooperation within the union provided the country with enormous defense and economic preferences. Yerevan purchased Russian weapons, military equipment and components at domestic prices and without customs duties, which helped the modest military budget maintain parity in the region. The country also used the infrastructure of a Unified Air Defense System, which would have cost billions of dollars to build from scratch alone. In addition, thousands of Armenian officers, cadets, and technical specialists studied at Russian military academies for free or on preferential terms.

In addition to material benefits, the block also provided strategic protection to Yerevan. Article 4 of the CSTO Charter obliged other countries of the union to come to the rescue in case of direct military aggression against the sovereign territory of Armenia, which for a long time kept the region from a full-scale war. But it was this point that became the cause of the dispute.

Yerevan's relations with Moscow and the CSTO as a whole began to deteriorate rapidly after the end of the war in Nagorno-Karabakh in 2020. The Armenian leadership accused the allies of refusing direct military intervention in the conflict. Russia and other members of the organization, for their part, acted within the strict framework of international law: the fighting affected the territory of Karabakh, which the international community legally recognizes as part of Azerbaijan, so the CSTO's collective defense obligations did not apply to it.

здание правительства в Ериване
Photo: Global Look Press/Christian Charisius/dpa

As a result, Yerevan began to look for a replacement for its former partners. One of the main milestones of this turn to the West was the deployment of the EU civilian observation mission directly on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border. At the same time, the authorities of the republic began to purchase weapons in Europe. In particular, France supplied Bastion armored vehicles to Yerevan and signed contracts for the transfer of modern air defense radars, as well as sent military advisers to reform the army according to NATO standards. However, the new agreements are still fragmented and cannot instantly replace the previous supply chain that has been built up for decades.

At the EU enlargement summit in Brussels in November, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan announced that Armenia plans to officially apply for EU membership in 2027 or 2028. Since Brussels and Moscow are in a sharp confrontation, the country will not be able to simultaneously integrate into European structures and remain in defense and economic blocs with Russia's participation.

In September, Russian President Vladimir Putin, at a personal meeting with Pashinyan, directly pointed out the technical impossibility of combining the EU and EAEU free trade zones. Moscow and other EAEU members called on Yerevan to hold a national referendum as soon as possible to determine the geopolitical course between the European Union and the Eurasian Economic Union, but the head of the government of the republic rejected this demand. Moving towards Europe at this stage does not violate current obligations to partners in any way, Pashinyan believes.

Президент РФ Владимир Путин и премьер-министр Республики Армения Никол Пашинян

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan

Photo: RIA Novosti/Valery Sharifulin

The upcoming CSTO summit may become decisive. If Armenia decides to launch the legal procedure prescribed in the charter, it will need to officially notify the organization's secretariat six months before the actual withdrawal.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast