"Loyalty has become smarter"
The era of "mindless cashback" is over, but loyalty itself has not gone away — it has just become smarter. Roman Sinenko, head of the VTB Loyalty Program department, told Izvestia in an interview about how competition for customers is changing and why banks are increasingly considering benefits in rubles.
— What is happening with bank loyalty programs now? Were the predictions that the "era of generous cashback" is becoming a thing of the past correct?
— Everything is not as obvious as it seemed. A loyalty program is a basic tool for motivating a customer: it helps to attract people, retain them, and develop relationships not only with the bank, but with any business in general.

If we look at the financial indicators, we understand that the volume of cashback payments will be higher this year — by about 25 billion rubles. This is not a very large amount in the market horizon. According to our forecasts, the total amount of payments for banks this year will be 470-480 billion rubles.
Banks have been looking closely at the loyalty economy for many years. Now every offer goes through an economic model: how much it costs to attract a client, how much it will bring to the bank, and how quickly the investment will pay off. The bank may deliberately spend more on a new client than it receives in the first month, but this should be a calculated decision. And the next stages are the consistent work of the bank with the client.
— What is the current user of loyalty programs? How much do customers understand the conditions now, how picky have they become?
— I will use the statistics of our loyalty program, but it is very similar to the statistics of other banks from the top 5. The customer has become more aware: he compares conditions, selects categories with the maximum benefit, and distributes purchases between banks.
According to our statistics, approximately 85% of participants choose the categories with the highest returns — and do so with an understanding of future benefits. For the bank, this means that it is not the card itself in the wallet that is important, but the proportion of daily transactions. A customer can have five cards, but spend most of the money on one card. It is for this activity that the competition is going on.
And there is a big difficulty here — to find a balance between what you need to earn as a business and what you need to keep and motivate the client to be with you more than yesterday and more than with competitors.
— Which categories of purchases are most valuable to customers now?
— Supermarkets confidently occupy the first place. The share of expenses in this category has been actively growing since September last year. In the second half of this year, we actively developed it at VTB, and competitors quickly followed suit.
The top also includes pharmacies, cafes and restaurants, as well as cashback "for all purchases" — its popularity depends on the season. Pharmacies, for example, re-entered the top three most sought-after categories in both the mass and premium segments in September.
In addition, we are constantly increasing the number of partners who are ready to provide additional discounts or cashback for our customers. This allows the client to receive more benefits, and the bank to distribute the economics of the program with partners.
— What are the prospects for banks' partnership programs with marketplaces?
— This is one of the most promising areas. Almost 90% of the country's residents make purchases on marketplaces at least once a month, or even more often.
Despite the fact that each of the Big Three marketplaces has its own bank, we are actively developing cooperation.
The benefits are mutual: the bank gets additional transactional activity and strengthens relationships with the client, and the marketplace increases turnover. In addition, such partnerships go beyond the classic cashback for purchases: together with a partner, the bank can offer various services in different areas of life with additional benefits: travel, logistics, pharmacy retail and other areas. For example, fast track at the airport, free baggage packing, etc.
— Can the loyalty program and, in particular, cashback become decisive in changing the bank's connection?
— On the one hand, yes. Research directly shows that three quarters of customers, if they discover a card from a second bank with higher cashback returns, are ready to switch to this other bank at the moment. But each of us has savings, obligations in the form of loans and interacts with one bank as the main one.
Earlier it was said about the "bank of the first choice". There is equality now. There is a main bank where the client holds financial obligations and covers key needs. At the same time, there is transactional behavior — this is where the race continues, but with a very smart position.
Loyalty remains the only tool for customer motivation. There are different ways and forms, but in a key way, loyalty has become "smart." The client has also become smarter: the current economy and the abundance of offers make him more practical in his choice. And the bank is ready to show and tell what the client's benefits from interaction are based on, and it can amount to tens, and for some, hundreds of thousands of rubles. This amount includes income from deposits and savings accounts, the amount of cashback, and benefits from partners that the bank attracts.
As in our example, this is cashback not only for transaction activity and monthly category selection, but also cashback for storing current account balances. We appeal to the numbers and the benefits of the client, which are calculated and presented clearly.
— Market conditions are constantly changing. How does the bank adapt the loyalty program?
— This year we see that the world and the economy are accelerating. The rule "you can't change the terms more than once a year because the customer base doesn't get used to it" no longer works.
The client votes in rubles. If he sees a better offer, he quickly adjusts his behavior. That's why we're moving to more frequent updates: major versions of the program can now appear every six months.
We need to look around, at the client first of all, at the company's economy, cooperate with several partners and understand that we need to move faster. The world decides for us.
— Do you use loyalty programs yourself?
— Of course, you can say that I am the same shoemaker with boots. The main one for me is the VTB loyalty program, but I am also testing the offers of other banks. This is a professional interest: it is important to follow the path of the client and understand where he faces difficulties.
My main principle is that everything should be simple for the client, and all the complexity should remain inside the bank. Not everything works out right away, but that's what we're aiming for.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»