Uma Chamber: US Democrats threaten to bring down the AI industry
The results of the midterm elections in the United States, which returned control of both houses of Congress to the Democrats, triggered a major downturn in the stock markets. The collapse began in Asia, and then continued in America. Investors began to liquidate positions in shares of manufacturers of chips and server equipment, fearing that the new political situation in Washington would create problems for trillion-dollar investments in artificial intelligence (AI) and data centers (data centers). Why quotes collapsed, how Democrats in Congress can harm the neural network industry and how this will affect the AI race between the United States and China — in the Izvestia article.
Political fears
Asian indices collapsed immediately after the start of the session on November 5. Japan's Nikkei 225 Average fell 1.5%, while Taiwan's main index fell 2.5%. South Korea was the hardest hit, where the local Kospi, which is half made up of quotes from two companies, Samsung and Hynix (both major chip manufacturers), sank by 4.8%. The fall is easily explained: Asia is home to the main "manufacturers of shovels" for the AI boom. They have invested a lot of money in capacity expansion to meet the almost bottomless demand. If it turns out to be lower than expected, all these investments will have to be written off.
Interestingly, on the day after the election (November 4), American indices reacted normally — the largest technology companies even grew. Investors in America usually take the idea of a "divided government" positively, when the legislative branch is under the control of one party and the executive branch is under the control of another. This usually means that there will be no new taxes.
But the very next day, the mood changed radically. The high-tech Nasdaq index flew down and fell by 5% in the first hours of trading on November 5. All the chips related to the AI sector collapsed, as well as various hardware vendors. For example, AMD lost almost 15%, while Qualcomm lost 12%.
Over the past 24 hours, many high-profile statements have been made, primarily from newly elected senators. Some, like Sherrod Brown, are calling for a complete moratorium on the construction of new data centers. Others, such as Yassamin Ansari and Abdul El-Sayed, demand that the development of new artificial intelligence models be stopped for several years. To make matters worse for the industry, in some key states for development, including Texas (where the high-tech industry is now moving en masse), the "donkey party" also sensationally won. Of course, not all Democrats take such positions, but the left wing is gaining strength and in the new composition of Congress it can force them to take into account their demands.
Another question is how much the congress can stimulate or discourage the development of the leading industry of the economy in the context of such a divided government. And here the Democrats' possibilities for administrative and fiscal strangulation of the sector seem quite serious, despite the likely presidential veto.
Energy is the head of everything
The most vulnerable point of the artificial intelligence boom is the physical infrastructure: data centers that consume huge amounts of electricity and fresh water. Congress can deal the most painful blow through environmental regulation. Legislators are able to oblige the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to introduce protective rules for connecting data centers to backbone networks, assigning technology companies all the costs of their modernization. In addition, the expansion of the federal environmental assessment (within the framework of NEPA and the Clean Water Act) for energy-intensive facilities is guaranteed to delay obtaining construction permits from several months to several years. In arid states such as Arizona and Nevada, moratoriums on industrial water use can physically stop the expansion of server farms.
The second, equally effective lever is budgetary and tax. Congress has the exclusive right to amend the Tax Code. The cancellation of accelerated depreciation, which allowed corporations to write off the cost of purchasing servers with Nvidia chips, will dramatically reduce the return on capital investment. The introduction of special excise taxes on "overconsumption of computing power" will become an additional burden that can cool the ardor of investors. These measures can be implemented through the budget reconciliation procedure by a simple majority vote, bypassing the threat of a Senate filibuster (delaying the adoption of the law).
Finally, legislators can strike at the software side through data and copyright regulation. Stripping AI developers of their immunity (similar to possible changes to section 230 of the Communications Decency Act) will open the floodgates to thousands of lawsuits for hallucinations and model errors.
Chinese revenge
If the scenario of a regulatory freeze in the United States is implemented, it will radically change the balance of power in the global arena. Today, Silicon Valley's leadership is based on a concentration of talent, huge investments, and access to cutting-edge hardware. Artificially slowing down this ecosystem will give China critically needed time to close the gap.
The key advantage of China lies in infrastructure scaling. There is no environmental lobby or lengthy litigation in the country that can block the construction of power plants for data centers. The state program "Eastern Data — Western Computing" allows Beijing to centrally build gigawatt AI clusters in regions with an excess of hydro and wind generation.
The second important factor is the algorithmic efficiency of Chinese engineers. Models from 2024-2026, such as Qwen, Kimi, and DeepSeek developments, have demonstrated that Chinese laboratories are able to achieve results comparable to Western standards (slightly worse, but by no means radically), while using significantly less computing power. They compensate for the hardware hunger with innovations in architecture and optimization of attention algorithms. If the American giants are shackled by bureaucracy and lawsuits, Chinese engineers will be able to close the already gradually narrowing technological gap in 6-12 months.
Finally, the regulatory pause in the United States will give China the most valuable thing — time. The weakest point of China remains the US sanctions on advanced chips and lithographic equipment ASML. Slowing down the pace of AI development in the United States will give Chinese manufacturers a head start in 2-3 years. During this time, they will be able to increase their own production of accelerators (Ascend series) and HBM memory to acceptable commercial parameters, reducing the rejection rate when using DUV lithography available to them. And with an optimistic development, they will be able to ensure the production of equipment for the most modern EUV lithography.
The only constraining factor for Chinese models will remain ideological censorship (affecting the quality of data synthesis in non-technical fields) and the high cost of internal silicon.
It should be understood that the national security argument and the fear that China will become a leader serve as the main shield for the American technology sector. The Pentagon and the US National Security Council will never allow Congress to completely stop the development of artificial intelligence. Therefore, despite the panic of Asian investors and the rhetoric of individual congressmen, the real outcome of the elections is unlikely to be a shutdown of the industry. The transition to targeted environmental and antitrust pressure is much more likely, which will complicate the lives of corporations, but will not cancel the digital race itself.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»