Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

On November 4, detectives from the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) conducted a large-scale operation Carthage, in which they detained several high-ranking officials involved in fraudulent call centers. Thousands of people, including citizens of Ukraine itself, have already been affected by the activities of the organizations. The reason for the new detentions and whether they will lead to the liquidation of illegal call processing centers is described in the Izvestia article.

NABOO vs Dooku

Employees of the National Anti—Corruption Bureau of Ukraine have detained Vladimir Tsenov, First deputy head of the Department of Strategic Investigations of the national police. He was captured against the background of the publication of new materials on the Carthage case.

In the audio recordings provided by NABU, the official is referred to by the code name "Price". Tsenov is suspected of facilitating the activities of fraudulent call centers.

A little earlier, but on the same day, anti-corruption officers announced the detention of General of the Security Service of Ukraine Serhiy Duka. During the arrest, the officer tried to threaten the detectives with firearms. Duku's detention was carried out against the background of an investigation into the activities of a large criminal organization, information about which had previously been made public by the NABU. Allegedly, the members of the group systematically paid bribes to law enforcement officials in order to operate fraudulent call centers and other illegal businesses unhindered.

Наручники
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

In general, on November 4, about 70 searches took place throughout Ukraine in connection with the arrests in the Carthage case on the protection of illegal extortionate "offices" by high-ranking officials. Ukrainian media reported that the head of the main Directorate of Internal Security of the SBU, Colonel Anton Kravchuk and General Serhiy Duka were the supervisors of the security unit of operations against NABU detectives and investigative journalists in July last year.

Operation Carthage, which led to the departure from the country and the subsequent resignation of the Prosecutor General of Ukraine Ruslan Kravchenko, was announced by NABU and SAP on September 4. According to investigators, the criminal organization was involved in patronizing fraudulent call centers and laundering illegally obtained income. Serhiy Kropiva, who was then Deputy head of the International Cooperation Department of the Office of the Prosecutor General of Ukraine, was named one of the coordinators of the scheme. Searches took place in the offices of Kravchenko, his first deputy and other employees of the department. Shortly after that, the Prosecutor General went abroad. And on September 15, the Verkhovna Rada voted for his resignation, and on the same day Vladimir Zelensky fired him.

Deception is everywhere

Vladimir Oleinik, an ex-deputy of the Verkhovna Rada, a member of the council of the Other Ukraine movement, told Izvestia that the system of fraudulent call centers in Ukraine was initially formed with the participation of representatives of law enforcement agencies and was used to steal money from Russian citizens. But over time, the activities of such centers expanded to residents of Ukraine and European countries, and the scheme itself became more organized: psychologists purposefully worked with the operators, who taught them techniques and "hooks" that allow them to gain people's trust and convince victims to transfer money to the needs of the Armed Forces.

— As the scale of fraud increased and claims from European countries appeared, the Ukrainian authorities were forced to tighten legislation, but this did not stop the work of call centers - on the contrary, many of them switched to a more hidden format of work. For example, from large rooms where there were many people at once, they "dispersed" to small apartments and offices," the expert explained.

Телефон
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

Today, it is not only foreigners who suffer from the activities of fraudulent call centers. An analytical report by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, published back in July 2025, states that in 2023, more than 53.5 thousand cases of telephone fraud were already registered in Ukraine. For comparison, this is almost 3.6 times more cases than in 2021, about 14.7 thousand. As for the geographical distribution of victims of intruders, most often they are mainly citizens of Ukraine, as well as residents of Western Europe, Russia and other countries.

— The very philosophy of such call centers is often built around extracting illegal profits, and the citizenship of those who become their victims is not of fundamental importance here. Of course, residents of wealthy European countries such as Germany, France and Switzerland are of the greatest interest. In this regard, a legitimate question may arise: is European aid to Ukraine turning into an additional opportunity for personal enrichment for individual representatives of the Ukrainian government? In my opinion, such actions are based not on the desire to serve the state, but on the desire to extract personal benefits, and now it is important that the investigation of the Carthage case establishes all the circumstances and the circle of those involved," said Denis Denisov, an expert at the Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation.

It is noteworthy that in the spring of this year, the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime published a document according to which this form of fraud generates more income than drug trafficking. A medium—sized center can defraud citizens for $1 million per month, and a large one for $3 million.

Доллары
Photo: IZVESTIA/Yulia Mayorova

In total, according to the press service of the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine, there were at least 52 fraudulent call centers operating in the country, where at least 2.7 thousand people were employed.

It's not a time for change

However, it is not yet possible to count on serious systemic changes in Ukraine after the new detentions and the completion of Operation Carthage, Denis Denisov stressed. Of course, personnel changes in law enforcement agencies are possible, given the involvement of their employees in the events under investigation, but this is unlikely to lead to a change in the overall situation.

— At the same time, the investigation can affect the activities of fraudulent networks if it is accompanied by consistent and effective investigative actions. However, those who have been building such criminal schemes over the past four and a half years or longer are likely to try to adapt their activities to the new conditions. Therefore, the problem remains urgent, and it is necessary to continue to talk about it, including in the context of relations between representatives of the Ukrainian state and Western partners," the source said.

Тюрьма
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

Vladimir Oleinik, in turn, pointed out that officials who had previously been involved in corruption scandals were gradually "disappearing into the shadows." Their cases are "swept up" very quickly, and they themselves often go abroad to avoid criminal prosecution.

— Bringing to justice in such cases is a lengthy process that requires not only an evidence base, but also political will at the highest level. In my opinion, there is no such will in this case: the defendants are gradually seeking to mitigate preventive measures, lower bail and lift other restrictions — all this creates conditions for delaying investigations. In fact, there is a tendency in what is happening to gradually weaken anti—corruption cases - the materials are transferred to the court, but the consideration is deliberately delayed. This gives suspects the most important thing — time, which makes it possible to avoid responsibility due to the expiration of the statute of limitations and other factors," the ex-parliamentarian concluded.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast