Carousel shores: how the new law will affect the operation of attractions
Russia has adopted the law "On Attractions", which establishes uniform rules for the operation, state registration and accounting of all carousels, slides and other devices in amusement parks. Until now, the standards in the country could differ from each other depending on the region, which made it more difficult to monitor the safety of such equipment. However, bringing the entire industry to uniform standards may have an unexpected impact on the market: experts predict a possible risk of closure of a part of the business that operates mobile amusement parks. Izvestia investigated how the federal law would affect the operation of the attractions.
What changes with the adoption of the law
Russian President Vladimir Putin signed Federal Law No. 343-FZ "On Attractions" on November 2, the document will enter into force on March 1, 2027.
The new rule establishes uniform rules of operation and control for all devices in amusement parks operating in Russia. Until now, these powers have been assigned to the regions.
The law applies to both stationary and transportable attractions with a potential risk of RB1, RB2 or RB3. This classification was introduced by the EAEU Technical Regulation 038/2016 "On the Safety of Attractions", which has been in force since 2018.
RB1 is a roller coaster with great height and speed, free fall towers, powerful catapults, and extreme pendulums. RB-2 — large ferris wheels, medium-height and high-speed swings and slides, family mechanized rides. RB-3 — low carousels, slides, children's rides with moderate dynamics.
There are also RB4 rides that have nothing to do with the new law — these are simple spring rocking chairs, low inflatable structures like mazes without any significant lifting, children's electric cars and steam trains with minimal speed, etc.
Devices of categories RB1 – RB3 will now be subject to mandatory unified state registration. The operator will receive a special registration mark, which will be entered into the regional information system. It will contain information about the manufacturer, type and type of attraction, the year of its release and the degree of biomechanical risk.
Requirements for the design, manufacture and installation of devices have also been established: they will have to comply with the already mentioned technical regulations and be completely safe for visitors. All owners will enter information about the admission of the attraction to operation in the accounting logs on a daily basis.
The law also has requirements for the qualification of personnel and their certification, which must be carried out by the operator.
In addition, there are clear grounds for prohibiting operation: if there is no registration, verification has failed, the service life has expired, the operation of the attraction must stop.
In fact, the new rule resembles the existing practice of control and supervision of attractions, which was in force before its adoption, Igor Rodionov, vice president of the Russian Association of Amusement Parks and Manufacturers, told Izvestia.
— The law largely repeats the current technical regulations "On the safety of attractions" and refers to it, — the expert noted.
At the same time, as Dmitry Batsaev, director of Expert Diagnostics LLC, stated, the need to clarify the rules for confirming the safety of devices in amusement parks has been overdue for a long time.
— With a centralized, uniform approach to the registration of attractions, the regional State Technical Supervision authorities will not have different interpretations of regulatory requirements. For example, now some regional bodies of Gostekhnadzor register rides where the operator is an individual without registration of the sole proprietor, — the interlocutor of the editorial office drew attention.
Why does the law threaten mobile attractions
First of all, the new law creates difficulties for mobile amusement parks, which will now have to confirm the safety of equipment through a technical inspection procedure every time they change their location during the season, Igor Rodionov noted.
— Previously, it was enough to undergo this procedure once a year. This incurs additional financial costs for entrepreneurs. But the main thing is that there are not enough testing laboratories in our country that will be able to check the rides "on the road," the Izvestia interlocutor emphasized.
There is a risk of closure of some companies and entrepreneurs who are engaged in mobile attractions, he warned.
Alexey Kolechenok, Deputy Head of the State Supervision Inspectorate for the technical condition of self—propelled vehicles and other types of equipment in the Vladimir region, explained to Izvestia that this is about clause 1 in Article 15 of the new law, which states that the technical condition of the attraction is assessed by an accredited organization at least once every 12 months, and also - most importantly in this regard situations — in case of a change in the installation location or location of the attraction.
— That is, when the owner of an attraction needs to bring it to another city for a holiday for one day, then, if we understand this law literally, an inspection should be carried out at the new installation location of the device, — he explained. — This technical condition assessment should be carried out by accredited organizations, in fact, certifying authorities, laboratories. Summoning them for one day is a very large sum, especially since they have greatly increased the cost this year.
In principle, there are very few of these organizations in Russia, the expert confirmed. Andrey Ardashev, creative Director of the Vostok group of amusement manufacturer companies, member of the Presidium of the Union of Associations and Partners of the Entertainment Industry (SAPIR), also agreed with this. He noted that the availability of accredited laboratories is the main problem: their number is limited, especially in the regions.
— In addition, in the spring, specialists are loaded with annual inspections in stationary parks, and invitations to events sometimes arrive in just a week. As a result, even a serviceable attraction with a valid annual inspection may be left without work," the source told Izvestia.
The initial proposals on this issue were even tougher, and the final version of the bill was softened. According to Andrey Ardashev, the market will remain, but serious risks remain for small operators.
At the same time, SAPIR President Alexei Prosandeev drew attention to the fact that the law, on the contrary, contains a mechanism for reducing barriers to mobile attractions — the concept of "temporary registration" has appeared.
— In theory, this is aimed at facilitating the registration procedure for mobile attractions. But it is difficult to say what will happen in practice, since the procedure for temporary registration in the Federal Law is not described and will be formed in by—laws. We hope that it will be simple and reasonable," he stressed.
However, if the interpretation of the law proposed by his colleagues is correct, then this procedure (which, by the way, also applies within the framework of technical regulation 038), in fact, will make it impossible for attractions to travel to small towns for fairs and holidays, the source acknowledged.
— If a different procedure for temporary registration is determined, then there is hope that this business segment will begin to develop, - the specialist did not rule out.
Will the rides become safer
The new law has the potential to improve security, said Oleg Matyunin, Managing partner of the Moscow Law Firm Matyuniny and Partners, Chairman of the Guild of Russian Lawyers Commission on Business Protection and Security. For example, it is impossible to issue a positive act with the condition of subsequent elimination of comments — visitors must be allowed to enter the attraction, the reliability of which has already been confirmed.
— However, the registration record by itself does not guarantee the safety of each session, — said the interlocutor of Izvestia. — An incident is also possible on technically sound equipment. The danger may be caused by a violation of the launch procedure, improper boarding or locking of passengers, admission of a visitor who does not comply with the established restrictions, insufficient information about the rules of use.
According to him, staff training is a separate issue. Article 17 of the law provides for training and certification, but it can be conducted by the operator himself. In reality, the quality of requirements, the day-to-day organization of work, and the effectiveness of supervision are crucial.
In general, a big step forward has been made in the issue of amusement ride safety over the past seven years, and there have been significantly fewer incidents, Alexey Kolechenok recalled.
However, there are still problems with gray attractions that are operated without registration — this mainly concerns mobile amusement parks, Dmitry Batsaev added. According to him, it is now physically difficult for inspectors to track the placement of attractions without registration in the wrong places.
— In addition, there are still cases when the attraction formally has documents, but in fact it is operated with violations. A lot depends on the local Gostekhnadzor," the expert pointed out.
And those who did not follow the rules before, and now will not undergo an examination, Andrei Ardashev admitted. Gostekhnadzor simply will not have time to check them: the attraction, arriving for one day, simply collapses before the arrival of the inspectors.
— We had such a thing when strange people put trampolines near the subway, without fasteners, fences, with wires under their feet. Then the trampoline flew away — literally — the merchant folded up and disappeared in an unknown direction, and the checks came to us, to stationary facilities where everything was done according to the rules," the source told Izvestia.
What else needs to be taken into account in the law
The current Technical Regulations "require fundamental improvements and even changes," Igor Rodionov is convinced.
— Over the 10 years of the regulation's existence, the industry has stepped forward, and it does not cover many problems. The Ministry of Industry and Trade in the Russian Federation and our association are currently working on amendments to the Technical Regulations," the source told Izvestia.
According to Alexey Prosandeev, it is also necessary to create a unified federal register of registered attractions — now they remain under the jurisdiction of the subjects of the federation. This makes it difficult to carry out analytics on the entire amusement park in the Russian Federation and develop common measures in the field of safe operation, the expert explained.
Oleg Matyunin added that the participation of visitors would be a useful addition: the opportunity to check official information about the attraction and quickly report a violation.
— People are able to notice a dangerous landing order, lack of information about restrictions, leaving a working attraction unattended. Such messages should receive timely evaluation and feedback. At the same time, the technical inspection remains the task of specialists," he noted.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»