How do countries prevent Russia from returning to world hockey? Answers to the main questions
- Новости
- Sport
- How do countries prevent Russia from returning to world hockey? Answers to the main questions
The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has returned the Russian national hockey teams the right to participate in international tournaments. However, many countries have threatened to boycott matches with the Russians, reject visa applications for athletes, or cancel competitions. This creates problems for the International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF), which faces both the threat of canceling championships and legal consequences if it refuses to comply with CAS decisions. The current situation in world hockey is described in the Izvestia article.
What exactly did the Court of Arbitration for Sport decide?
• The Court of Arbitration for Sport has considered the appeal of the Russian Ice Hockey Federation (RIHF) against the IIHF decision of January 2026. Then the main hockey organization announced that it was extending the non-admission of the Russian and Belarusian national teams to participate in their championships for the 2026/27 season. The IIHF cited security issues as justification for this decision. She stated that the current situation at that time did not allow to provide the necessary conditions for the organization of tournaments, guaranteeing the safety of all participants.
• The CAS panel, composed of arbitrators from Italy, Egypt and the United Kingdom, found that the IIHF's arguments referring to safety were not supported by sufficient evidence to establish legal requirements for suspension. The arbitrators pointed out that the security threats must be sufficiently justified for the IIHF to restrict the rights of athletes of a certain nationality to participate in competitions.
• The CAS decision came into force immediately, and in its press release, the court specifically indicated which tournaments the Russian national team should now be allowed to participate in. These are the world championships among men's youth teams (Canada, December 26, 2026 – January 5, 2027), among girls under 18 (Czech Republic, January 8-16, 2027), among boys under 18 (USA, April 22 – May 2, 2027), among men's national teams (Germany, May 14-30, 2027 year) and among women (Canada, November 2027). The next IIHF tournament, which starts on November 6 in Denmark, the Women's World Cup, formally refers to the 2025/26 season.
How did the IIHF react?
• The IIHF's reaction to the CAS decision was comparable to shock. The organization expressed its disappointment and disagreement with the referees of the sports court. The IIHF noted that they respect the authority of the CAS and will act in accordance with its decisions, but warned of "significant practical consequences for the competition," which the CAS did not take into account in the satisfied appeal.
• A week later, the IIHF issued a new statement. The organization pointed out that the immediate return of the Russian national teams is fraught with significant difficulties, such as the visa and entry requirements of the host countries, security measures, logistical constraints and implications for competition formats. All this is compounded by the lack of time remaining before the start of the tournaments. The IIHF has not announced what further steps it intends to take to make the CAS decision a reality.
Is the IIHF obligated to comply with the CAS decision?
• The IIHF has no right not to comply with CAS decisions. The Court of Arbitration for Sport is the highest legal body in the Olympic sports system, which includes the International Olympic Committee and its recognized international sports federations. All subjects of this system undertake to make CAS decisions under threat of exclusion from it.
• In some cases, CAS verdicts may be reviewed by the Swiss Federal Court (which is where the CAS meets), and then it becomes the final authority in disputes. But he can only point to procedural violations in the work of the CAS, and not review the claims on the merits. At the same time, in the case of the RIHF appeal, the IIHF signed an agreement not to challenge the CAS decision in Switzerland in order to speed up the process.
• If the IIHF still refuses to comply with the CAS decision, the consequences for the organization will be truly devastating. First of all, she will face exclusion from the Olympic family. This does not mean that hockey will disappear from the Olympic Games program, but specifically the IIHF will cease to be responsible for this tournament. Instead, a new world hockey organization will be established in the future, which will receive recognition from the IOC. This has already happened with boxing, where a new structure called World Boxing took the place of the suspended International Boxing Association (IBA).
• If the IIHF continues to exist without the Olympic system, it may face proceedings in the Swiss State courts. The FHR will have the right to require the IIHF to enforce the CAS decision under threat of various sanctions, from monetary fines to forced liquidation. The IIHF, whose headquarters are located in Zurich, is obliged to comply not only with CAS decisions, but also with Swiss law.
What problems prevent the implementation of the CAS solution?
• The main challenge facing the IIHF is that the list of participants in all five tournaments has already been approved. The addition of the Russian national team (and in the future, Belarus, which can file its claim with the CAS) will either lead to the exclusion of teams that have earned the right to participate, or to a change in the format of the championships and additional matches. At the World Cup in Germany, the last team to qualify is the national team of Ukraine, and according to the sporting principle, it is her place that the IIHF should transfer to Russia.
• In addition, many countries have announced that they do not accept the CAS decision and will take action to prevent the return of the Russian national team. So, the head of the German Hockey Union, Frank Lutz, admitted that the country would refuse to host the World Cup. There has only been one such case in the history of hockey: in 1970, Canada refused to host a tournament because the IIHF forbade the participation of professional players.
What are the consequences for countries and national teams if they refuse to play with the Russians?
• If Germany withdraws from the World Cup, the IIHF will have only seven months to find a new organizer and reschedule the tournament, which will need to include the Russian national team. For a competition of this level, this is an unthinkable time. The only time the preparation period was shorter was for the 2021 World Cup. Then the IIHF deprived Belarus of the opportunity to host matches four months before the tournament, but handed them over to Latvia, which already acted as a co-organizer. In addition, fans were not allowed in the stands at that time due to the coronavirus pandemic, which made it easier to organize.
• At the moment, the tournament in Germany is not even in danger of postponement, but cancellation, since too few countries are ready to host matches with Russia. Only Belarus and Slovakia supported the CAS decision, while the United States, France, Switzerland, Slovenia and Kazakhstan did not speak out against it. The rest of the World Cup participants either do not want the Russian national team to play at all, or intend to boycott matches with its participation.
• The latter include Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Norway, Latvia, the Czech Republic and Austria. If the IIHF puts a match with the Russian national team on their schedule, but they refuse to go on the ice, they will be awarded a technical defeat. In the group stage, this will lead to the loss of points needed to reach the quarterfinals, and in the playoffs it will result in premature departure from the tournament. At the same time, boycotts for political reasons may be followed by sanctions up to disqualification, as sports federations are trying to combat this phenomenon.
• Visa restrictions for Russian hockey players may become a separate topic. The Czech Republic and Canada have already announced that they do not intend to allow entry, which will affect three of the five upcoming tournaments. Currently, the IOC's recommendation is in force in world sports that qualifying competitions for the Olympic Games should be held in countries that allow Russians to enter their territory. The hockey championships for adults are taken into account when selecting for the Olympics, but the rest of the tournaments no longer have such an impact. The IIHF can only influence the Czech Republic and Canada by threatening to postpone their championships, but, as already mentioned, such a step is extremely difficult and would rather lead to the complete cancellation of the competitions than to their postponement.
What will the IIHF do?
• The IIHF has not determined how to implement the CAS decision. The next tournament, the World Youth Championship in Canada, is only seven weeks away. Neither the organizers nor the government intend to allow Russians to participate, even if the IIHF requires them to do so. The most likely option would be that the federation would still include the Russian national team in the membership, but responsibility for its admission would be shifted to the Canadian Migration Service.
• The same can happen with the rest of the tournaments. Formally, the IIHF will comply with the CAS order, but the Russians will not be allowed to compete due to the lack of visas, which is a fairly common practice in modern sports. If the United States or Germany do issue visas, as they do for representatives of other sports, the IIHF may face opposition from some national teams and sponsors, who also do not accept the CAS decision. Then the federation may still face the issue of postponing or canceling tournaments.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»