Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The psychotherapist revealed the essence of Solomon's paradox

Krashkina: Solomon's paradox explains why we are wiser in other people's problems
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

We often know better how to act in someone else's difficult situation than in our own: we easily notice the mistakes of friends, find arguments against rash decisions and see a way out where the other person does not notice it. But when faced with a similar problem personally, common sense gives way to emotions, doubts, and fear of change. Irina Krashkina, a psychotherapist at JSC "Medicine" (Academician Roitberg Clinic), Candidate of Medical Sciences, told Izvestia on November 4 why there is such a difference in perception and whether it is possible to learn to evaluate one's own life more objectively.

According to her, in psychology this phenomenon is known as the Solomon's paradox. Its name refers to the biblical King Solomon, who is traditionally considered a symbol of wisdom. In modern psychology, this is the name given to a person's tendency to reason more carefully about other people's problems than about their own.

"Psychological distance plays a key role here. When we analyze someone else's situation, we do not experience the same emotions as its direct participant. It is easier for us to take into account different circumstances, consider alternatives and assess possible consequences. But when it comes to one's own life, one simultaneously becomes both a participant in events and their analyst. As a result, fear, anxiety, hope, or unwillingness to lose anything may outweigh rational arguments," the expert explained.

Why emotions get in the way of making decisions

It's not just about emotional involvement, but also cognitive distortions. For example, a person may pay attention primarily to information that confirms an already made decision, and ignore facts that contradict his beliefs. In addition, we often explain our own actions by circumstances, whereas we tend to associate the behavior of other people with their character traits.

Another difficulty is the inability to accurately predict one's own future desires and experiences. What seems to be fundamentally important today may lose its former importance in a few months. However, at the moment of making a decision, a person often focuses on current emotions.

At the same time, emotions themselves do not interfere with rational thinking. Fear can warn of danger, anxiety can indicate uncertainty, and anger can signal a violation of personal boundaries. The problem arises when a person perceives his current state as the final answer to the question about the future.

Rumination creates additional complexity by repeatedly scrolling through the same events and experiences. Instead of looking for a solution, the person returns to the unpleasant episode over and over again, increasing the emotional tension.

How to learn to give yourself the right advice

According to Krashkina, one of the most accessible ways to overcome Solomon's paradox is to try to look at your own situation through the eyes of a loved one. To do this, you can ask yourself a few questions: what would I recommend to a friend who finds himself in such circumstances? What facts would you ask him to check? What hasty actions would you warn against?

Another technique is to write a recommendation to yourself on behalf of a neutral observer. For example, instead of the usual "what should I do?", formulate the thought as follows: "what is important for a person in such a situation to consider now?". Such a change of perspective helps to reduce emotional involvement and consider the problem more objectively.

"A view from the future may also be useful. You can imagine yourself in a year and think about which decisions today will seem the most significant, which you will most likely have to regret, and which consequences now remain unnoticed," Krashkina said.

Another way is to mentally consider several scenarios.: what happens if you leave everything as it is, choose one course of action, or do the opposite? It is important to assess the possible consequences not only in the coming days, but also in six months or a year.

However, the expert emphasized that such exercises do not guarantee the only correct solution. Their task is to create a psychological distance that will allow them to see more options and not be limited to reacting to momentary experiences.

Why other people's advice doesn't always help

The ability to analyze a situation from the outside is useful not only in solving one's own problems, but also in communicating with loved ones. However, it is important not to confuse support with the imposition of one's own opinion. Sometimes a person doesn't need a ready answer, but an opportunity to speak out and feel understood. If, instead, he immediately receives instructions on what he should do, even reasonable advice can provoke resistance.

In addition, an outside observer does not always know all the circumstances of someone else's life: financial constraints, relationship history, personal experiences and psychological state. Therefore, categorical recommendations in the spirit of "I know exactly what's best for you" can be not only useless, but also harmful.

A more constructive approach is to ask questions: "What is the most important thing for you right now?", "Have you considered other options?", "Do you want me to just listen to you or do we try to find a solution together?".

The main criterion for healthy support is that after a conversation, a person should have more opportunities for independent choice, not fewer, the psychologist concluded.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast