Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The federal law adopted in 2026 gave the subjects of the Russian Federation the right to independently decide on the exclusion of cultural heritage sites from regional registers — previously this could only be done in consultation with the government of the Russian Federation. The first regions have already begun to carry out such work: the parliament of the Altai Territory has adopted amendments that transfer these powers to the level of the regional government. Moreover, the authorities explicitly stated that they were going to significantly thin out the regional registry — at least 39 physically lost objects, as well as buildings that were included "unreasonably", could be removed from there. Izvestia investigated how the regions would make decisions and whether the new order protected them from possible abuses in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

How are they going to thin out the registry in the Altai Territory

At the end of October, the Parliament of the Altai Territory discussed and adopted a package of amendments to the legislation on windows. The main change is the transfer to the authorities of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation of the right to exclude cultural heritage sites of regional significance from the register. In fact, these are technical changes that are conditioned by the adoption of such an order at the federal level.

The authorities of the Altai Territory stated that they were not going to destroy valuable objects, but intended to "restore order" in the registry. It is claimed that in the region of 4.5 thousand WINDOWS 39 are physically lost and cannot be restored, hindering the development of the urban environment. Moreover, there are already other facilities in place of some of them. At the same time, many buildings were allegedly included in the register unreasonably.

министерство культуры
Photo: IZVESTIA/Konstantin Kokoshkin

At a parliamentary meeting, the chairman of the Legislative Assembly Committee on Sports, Culture and Youth Policy, Tatyana Ilyuchenko, said that "the mechanism [for the seizure of objects] remains practically the same, but the process will be faster": first, a historical and cultural examination of the object will be carried out, after which the regional government will prepare a package of documents on the exclusion of the window and send it to the Ministry of Culture. Russian Federation. The Federal Ministry will review the issue and make a decision within 30 days.

Deputy Sergey Pisarev also spoke at the meeting, who said that in 1994 the region was waiting to receive federal money for the restoration of cultural heritage sites, therefore, when compiling the register of windows, "such a number of objects were included in Barnaul — mother, do not grieve."

At the same time, the list of objects that will be excluded from the register of cultural heritage sites has not yet been formed, Elena Kabanova, deputy head of the Department of State Protection of the Altai Territory, stressed in a comment to Izvestia. However, there are 39 objects listed there that were physically lost before 2010, she confirmed.

— It is important to understand that this is the number of physically lost objects, and not an approved exclusion list. In respect of each of them, it is necessary to go through the procedure established by law with justification of the appropriate grounds for exclusion from the register," the editorial interlocutor said.

разрушенный дом
Photo: Global Look Press/Timofey Gerasimov/URA.RU

Elena Kabanova explained that, as before, the customers of the state historical and cultural expertise can be both state authorities and local governments, as well as individuals and legal entities. The examination report will be posted on the official website of the Department of State Protection of Cultural Heritage sites — the conclusions of the experts and their justification are available to the public.

— The validity of the exclusion must be confirmed by the examination materials. The open publication of her act makes it possible to get acquainted with the arguments of experts, compare them with the available historical and archival information and draw attention to circumstances that might not have been taken into account. By itself, the poor condition of the building does not mean that it has no historical or cultural value and should not replace an expert assessment," the specialist noted.

How many regional windows are there in Russia

In June, Olga Lyubimova, the head of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation, said that 162,000 cultural heritage sites were on the department's register. Of these, 14 thousand are in poor condition. As of 2023 (at that time there were 154 thousand items in the register), there were 78.5 thousand objects of regional significance, 4 thousand of local significance. Such data was provided in the Strategy of Cultural Policy.

Regional lists and registers of cultural heritage sites were formed mainly in the 1990s and 2000s. Until 2002, the objects were recorded on the basis of separate lists of monuments of union, republican and local significance. Decisions on window protection were made by regional authorities based on previously collected documents and expert opinions, in particular, based on the lists of the 1960s and 1980s.

папка с документами в руках
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

In 2002, a law was passed on the creation of a Unified State Register of Cultural Heritage Sites. From that moment on, the inclusion of new facilities in the list began to be carried out according to the procedure established by federal law, which subsequently changed and became more complicated.

Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation. No response has been received at the time of publication.

Why a new mechanism can be dangerous

Despite the statements of the regional authorities, it cannot be said that the mechanism for excluding objects from the register remains practically the same, said Evgenia Tvardovskaya, a member of the Commission for the Preservation of the Windows of the Peoples of the Russian Federation of the Public Council under the Ministry of Construction of Russia, editor-in-chief of the State-Protected magazine.

— If the process needed to be accelerated, it means that the quality of decision-making will be reduced. The previous procedure for removing objects from the register, with the closure of this process at the level of the prime minister, was not chosen by chance — this indicated the seriousness of the action and the understanding that removal from the register almost always means either demolition or reconstruction beyond recognition, that is, loss forever," the Izvestia interlocutor noted.

She pointed out the corruption risks arising from the adopted changes. The construction market in the regions is often divided between developers, and each region of the Russian Federation has its own permanent restoration offices, experts, and developers. At the same time, an informed decision will be sent to the Ministry of Culture.

реставрация здания
Photo: RIA Novosti/Kirill Shipitsin

— When the decision is prepared by the region, and the federation is only "considering", the center of gravity of the examination shifts to the regional level, — the first deputy chairman of the All-Russian Society for the Protection of Historical and Cultural Monuments (VOOPIK) agreed in an interview with Izvestia Denis Yudin. — The risk of abuse is real. We have already seen how buildings that could be restored were excluded under the guise of "lost" objects, and how objects that hindered investors were declared "unreasonably included".

The approval of the Ministry of Culture in this case, according to the head of the Conservation project, Evgeny Neighbors, is formal: the ministry will not consider the issue on its merits, it will only examine the completeness of the documentation. Although before that, the federal Ministry was responsible for making the decision.

"At the same time, nothing prevented the exclusion of unreasonably included objects before: it was a very clearly prescribed procedure, and those who wanted to use it," the Izvestia interlocutor emphasized. — The only thing that prevented this was, of course, the federal decision—making level. It was much more difficult to get their interests (often corrupt) through the chairman of the Russian government than through regional security agencies.

Viktor Ageev, First Deputy General Director of the Institute of Urban Economics Foundation, Director of Urban Planning and Real Estate, however, believes that the current institutional shift in this area can be used "both for good and for harm." First of all, because the previous procedure worked slowly, and the deadline for considering the exclusion of the object "could reach five years."

стройка
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Volkov

"At that time, the area around the "dead" facility remained in a restricted area: major construction could not be carried out within a radius of 100-200 m, which, in fact, blocked the development of the territory due to an error in the documents," the expert explained to Izvestia.

At the same time, he acknowledged that risks do arise. The main ones are the dependence on the regional authorities of experts conducting historical and cultural expertise, as well as a decrease in the possibilities of public control due to the shortened time frame for considering the exclusion of an object from the register.

Which objects should be excluded

Denis Yudin confirmed that the previous procedure for exclusion from the register was indeed slow for lost objects. However, this procedure should not be a way to legalize illegal construction or remove restrictions from the land.

"If there is another object in place of the lost WINDOW, the question is not how to exclude the monument, but how this other object ended up there and what to do with it," the expert noted.

экскаватор снес здание
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

Unscrupulous market participants may perceive statements about lost monuments as a signal: destroy the objects, then they will be removed from state protection, Evgeny Neighbors warned.

— Instead of telling the public how many criminal cases have been initiated into the loss of monuments, how they are being investigated, why these monuments were lost, they simply say that they do not exist and they should not be protected. This is a wrong and dangerous message," he stressed.

Evgenia Tvardovskaya also pointed out the importance of the question of how other objects were built on the site of the monuments, because this is a direct violation of the law on heritage. According to the editorial's interlocutor, this is a continuing violation that is likely to go unpunished. Removing such monuments from the register, in fact, turns out to be a form of avoiding responsibility.

A similar logic applies to demolished objects: sometimes buildings are deliberately brought to such a state to make it easier to get rid of them. At the same time, the real ruins are often "nobody cares" — they are not located in the city, they interfere with few people, etc., the expert noted.

— First of all, the new law will affect objects located on profitable land plots in the historical part of cities and villages, in respect of which there is a direct commercial interest, — Evgeniya Tvardovskaya is convinced.

Деревянный дом
Photo: RIA Novosti/Yuri Kaver

"Superfluous" objects are often understood as ordinary historical buildings, Denis Yudin added. These are houses that are not architectural masterpieces, but at the same time form a historical environment: for example, wooden buildings, buildings from the post-war period, objects related to everyday life and everyday life of past eras.

— The historical environment consists not of individual masterpieces, but of a set of ordinary objects. To remove such buildings means to destroy the context in which monuments exist," the specialist emphasized.

As an example, Evgenia Tvardovskaya cited the Lenin Museum in Samara, around which two streets of historical buildings were preserved at once. Now they are perceived not so much in a revolutionary context as in a historical and visual one. Another thing is that the ring of new buildings is gradually shrinking around such facilities, the expert said. For example, this is happening, in particular, around the Leonid Andreev Museum in Orel, where 10-15 years ago there was a preserved historical environment that immersed in the 19th century.

How to preserve historical buildings

Nevertheless, according to Denis Yudin, the tools for preserving such objects remain. The main one is public control at the stage of preparing an exclusion decision. In addition, public organizations can initiate and pay for an independent expert examination, which refutes the conclusions of the regional body. It works — in a number of regions, such checks stopped the exclusion of objects.

фемида
Photo: IZVESTIA/Alexey Maishev

— The third tool is a judicial appeal. There is a practice of challenging decisions on exclusion from the register," the expert noted.

It is important to make each case public, documented and expertly verified, he stressed.

And Viktor Ageev added that in a global sense, it is important for the state to create conditions for investors so that the preservation of the historical site becomes economically meaningful. In this context, Evgenia Tvardovskaya recalled the words of Vyacheslav Glazychev, a scientist, specialist in the organization and development of the urban environment, who said that "reducing the historical complexity of the city reduces the capitalization of the environment."

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast