Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Why Brent no longer reflects the real price of oil. Analysis

The cost of oil delivery has increased sevenfold amid the war with Iran
0
Photo: Global Look Press/Christian Charisius
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The main thing in the material:

— Shipments from the Persian Gulf are recovering, sometimes approaching and exceeding pre-war levels, but this has not led to normalization of prices and shipping costs.

— Due to the war with Iran, the gap between stock quotes and the final cost of oil for buyers has increased. The average cost of shipping oil by sea has increased approximately sevenfold over the year, from $3 to more than $20 per barrel.

— High freight rates have attracted supertankers to the Persian Gulf, causing a shortage of ships in other destinations. In early October, the cost of transporting 2 million barrels of oil from the United States to China rose to $80 million.

— Shipowners have dramatically increased orders for new supertankers, but most of the vessels will enter service only in 2028-2029. It will not be possible to eliminate the shortage of tankers quickly.

— The rising cost of shipping has also affected Russian oil exports. Due to the increased cost of delivery, Urals has become comparable in final price to some Middle Eastern varieties, which reduces its attractiveness to Indian buyers. At the same time, the volume of maritime exports from Russia remains significant.

Oil supplies from the Persian Gulf are recovering, sometimes approaching or even exceeding pre-war levels, but there is still no steady normalization of the market. Brent rose above $117 per barrel in October, shipping costs reached record levels, and shipping routes changed again. At the same time, global oil reserves decreased by more than half a billion barrels, and the shortage of petroleum products turned out to be much more stable than the shortage of raw materials. Izvestia investigated why the return of oil to the world market does not make it cheaper and how the war with Iran weakened the binding of regional prices to reference quotations.

Oil returns, reserves dissolve

According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), in September, global oil supplies increased by 2.5 million barrels per day, to 102.3 million. The main contribution was made by the producers of the Persian Gulf, primarily Saudi Arabia. Oil exports from the region increased by 4.4 million barrels per day in a month, to 13.9 million, recovering to more than 75% of the pre-war level. At the same time, almost 11 million barrels per day passed through the Strait of Hormuz. In October, the flow recovery continued: according to Kpler, supplies from the region exceeded 24 million barrels per day in the week to October 18, compared with about 23 million before the conflict began.

However, the increase in supplies has not yet led to normalization of the global oil market. From the end of February to the end of September, global oil reserves decreased by 509 million barrels. At the same time, their structure has changed: the volume of oil in onshore storage decreased by 113 million barrels in September, reaching a minimum over the past 10 years, and increased by 103 million barrels on water. This suggests that the market has not yet regained its stability and remains extremely vulnerable to new disruptions.

These risks are reflected in oil quotes. According to the IEA's October report, the North Sea benchmark Dated Brent (for delivery in the coming weeks) rose in price by 43% to $134 per barrel, while individual grades traded at prices up to $160. At the same time, Brent futures were at around $107 per barrel. Later, exchange-traded contracts also rose in price: on October 23, Brent rose above $117.

The discrepancy between physical and futures quotes indicates the heterogeneity of the market — the presence of oil in the global system no longer means that it is affordable at the price of an exchange benchmark. Transportation costs are added to the cost of a barrel for the end customer. For example, in October, the average price of oil bound for Asia before shipment was $93 per barrel compared to $106 in April. However, taking into account the delivery, the cost of raw materials increased from $116 to $131 over the same period.

Izvestia reference

According to Goldman Sachs estimates, the average global cost of shipping crude oil has increased approximately sevenfold over the year, from $3 to more than $20 per barrel. In some Middle Eastern destinations, the price of transportation exceeded $35 per barrel.

Moreover, only part of the price increase is directly related to military risks. Analysts estimate the premium for the passage of the Strait of Hormuz at about $7 per barrel. Another $4 has been added due to the rise in the cost of marine fuel, the same amount due to the need for oil transshipment between ships. Changing the routes of tankers already in transit leads to an increase in the cost of a barrel by about $3, and restrictions on the use of Iranian vessels add another $2.

Tankers leave for expensive freight

At first, freight rates increased on Middle Eastern routes, primarily for super-large VLCC tankers, then the increase spread to other international destinations. In fact, there has been a restructuring of the shipping map. Record freight rates have attracted new vessels to the Persian Gulf region. In early October, more than 40% of the world's fleet of approximately 850 VLCC supertankers were in the Gulf or within a few days of it.

This exacerbates the situation with the global shortage of ships and supports further growth of freight rates. In January, the cost of transporting oil along the Persian Gulf — China route was less than $40,000 per day, immediately before the war — $231,000, at the end of September, rates soared to record levels of $ 1.2 million per day. In the first week of October, the cost of transportation in this direction increased further, to a historic $1.4 million per day. This is 500% more than before the start of the military campaign. In the second half of October, rates in a number of areas began to decline, but they still remained exceptionally high.

At the same time, instead of direct flights to customers, manufacturers are increasingly using supertankers for short shuttle services: ships are loaded in the Persian Gulf, pass through the strait and transfer oil to other tankers for further delivery. For such a voyage, shipowners request $ 30-40 million, that is, about $ 15-20 per barrel. At the same time, military insurance can reach 6-10% of the cost of the vessel, for example, $ 20 million for a supertanker.

In addition, shipowners have to offer crews increased remuneration for passage through the Strait of Hormuz. According to the Financial Times, captains of individual tankers were offered up to $100,000 per month and an additional bonus of $50,000 per flight, with a typical monthly salary of about $15,000. Ordinary sailors were promised payments four to six times higher than usual.

The changing economy of Hormuz is also affecting longer-range routes. In early October, the cost of transporting 2 million barrels of oil from the U.S. Gulf of Mexico to China reached $80 million, or about $40 per barrel. Before the war, a similar delivery cost about $8.60 per barrel. According to analysts, such prices undermine the economic feasibility of shipping raw materials along this route. Therefore, Asian buyers began to consider alternative supplies, including from the UAE.

Due to the shortage of large vessels and record freight rates, traders began to use smaller tankers more often - Suezmax and Aframax. Most of the deals concluded by the beginning of October for the transportation of American oil to Asia with loading in November provided for such vessels. However, they carry less raw materials per voyage and are inferior to supertankers in terms of efficiency per barrel. Increased demand for Suezmax and Aframax has started to push up freight rates in these market segments as well.

Help:

Izvestia reference

The marine fuel market is experiencing its own shortage. According to Vitol, a large oil trader, monthly shipments of high-sulfur fuel oil (HSFO), used for tanker refueling, from the Persian Gulf decreased by about 800 thousand tons compared to February. The market receives about 1 million tons less per month due to the Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries.

The shortage is compounded by the fact that fuel oil is needed not only by shipowners, but also by refiners. In November, refineries in North Asia plan to use more than 1 million tons of high-sulfur fuel oil as raw materials for further processing. They are going to replace oil of medium and heavy grades, the supply of which was disrupted due to interruptions in exports from Saudi Arabia through the Red Sea.

In October, HSFO prices in Singapore, which is the world's largest supplier of marine fuel, reached their highest level since April. The spot premium for high-sulfur fuel oil fluctuated at $50 per ton against $5 at the end of February.

At the same time, the restoration of crude oil exports through the Strait of Hormuz does not automatically solve the problem: refining margins are now exceptionally high, and refineries prefer to produce more profitable petroleum products, primarily diesel fuel.

It will not be possible to quickly eliminate the shortage of available supertankers. Of the 319 VLCCs in the shipbuilders' order book at the beginning of October, only 20 are due to be handed over to owners in the fourth quarter of 2026 and the first quarter of 2027. The main wave of new shipments will occur in 2028-2029, presumably about 100 VLCC annually. For comparison, in 2025, shipowners received only six new supertankers, and in 2024 - one.

According to Veson Nautical, since the beginning of 2026, shipowners have ordered 198 new VLCC supertankers compared to 89 for the entire previous year. The order portfolio reached about 37% of the operating fleet, compared with 2% in 2023. Crude oil tankers now account for 80% of all new orders in the segment. At the same time, the price of building a new vessel has increased by 8.4% since the beginning of the year, to $138 million, and the five-year increased by 70%, to $196.3 million. The difference is primarily due to the timing: an existing vessel can immediately enter the market and earn high rates, while a new one will have to wait several years.

Further order growth is hampered by the limitations of the shipyards themselves. The largest shipbuilding enterprises in Japan, South Korea and China have almost fully loaded their capacities by 2030. There is also a shortage of marine engines and other equipment. Veson analysts expect that from 2027 the tanker market supply will start to grow faster than demand, creating the prerequisites for lower freight rates. However, the scale of the future surplus is still unclear.: According to Hartland, 47% of the operating VLCCs are at least 15 years old, so some of the new vessels may replace the aging fleet.

The price of the Russian barrel route

The rise in the cost of shipping has also affected Russian oil exports. Even the presence of an extensive tanker fleet that handles shipments bypassing Western restrictions does not protect Russia from changes in the global freight market. Much of the oil from the country's western ports is sent to India and China via long routes, which makes shipping costs particularly sensitive to rising rates. Additional pressure on shipments from the Black Sea ports is exerted by military risks in the region.

According to Reuters calculations, the cost of freight for the supply of Urals crude oil to Asia in early October exceeded $30 per barrel. For example, the transportation of barrels from the Black Sea to India on a Suezmax tanker cost $27-30 million per flight, compared to about $19 million in September. For shipments from Baltic ports to western India, Aframax tanker rates have increased to $21-23 million per voyage this month, compared with $13-16 million in September.

The rising cost of shipping has influenced the decisions of Indian buyers. According to Reuters, Russian oil has become comparable in final value to some Middle Eastern grades, primarily Iraqi ones. In September, India reduced purchases of Russian oil by 14% compared to August, to 1.8 million barrels per day, while increasing imports from the Middle East to 2.8 million barrels. Bharat Petroleum expects a further reduction in purchases of Russian raw materials in November. At the same time, premiums for December shipments have already dropped to $1-2 per barrel against $12-13 for October shipments.

At the same time, Russia's total offshore oil exports remain significant. According to S&P Global, overall seaborne crude shipments increased to 4.09 million barrels per day in September, compared with 3.8 million in August. According to Bloomberg, the week before October 25, shipments of Russian oil reached a monthly maximum of 3.85 million tons. During this period, 37 tankers took on board 27 million barrels against 22 million a week earlier. The main role was played by the restoration of the Baltic port of Primorsk, from where 12 tankers left against four the previous week.

Thus, Russian oil remains in demand, but its competitiveness increasingly depends on how much it costs to bring a barrel to a customer.

In the current crisis, the geography of supplies is becoming increasingly important economically. Proximity to sales markets, availability of tankers, and the ability to deliver via a predictable route are becoming independent competitive advantages. At the same time, the high cost of transportation changes the distribution of income between participants in the oil trade. Even if the freight is paid by the buyer, the exporter may be forced to lower the selling price in order for his oil to remain competitive. Some of the additional costs are borne by carriers, while others are spent on risk insurance, transshipment and route restructuring.

As a result, it becomes more difficult to assess the state of the oil market based on a single Brent quote. High global prices do not guarantee comparable revenue growth for exporters, and reducing the cost of raw materials at the port of departure does not necessarily make them cheaper for the refinery. However, freight growth should not be perceived as a permanent and irreversible process. As shipping normalizes and new tankers enter the market, some of the premium may disappear.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast