Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

In Biysk, Altai Territory, houses that were built in 2011-2012 under the resettlement program from dilapidated and dilapidated housing began to be demolished. A little over 10 years after their construction, they were declared uninhabitable.: the floors were falling in, there were serious problems with ventilation, etc. Unfortunately, this is not an isolated case — residents of houses recognized as emergency are forced to re-enter the resettlement program in many regions of Russia. Izvestia investigated why this was happening and whether there was a danger of such problems continuing.

They were moved from emergency homes to emergency ones

The project to dismantle three three-storey houses on Specova Street in Biysk was approved back in December 2025, and demolition work is now actively underway.

молоток судья
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

This was preceded by a long legal process — the tenants from the new housing should have been resettled even earlier. Although the houses were built only in 2011-2012, a few years later its residents needed new apartments. Complaints from people began to arrive almost immediately: there were problems with ventilation, there was a strong smell of building materials, floors collapsed, etc. As a result, after numerous complaints and examinations, the houses were declared unusable.

A criminal case was opened against the former head of Biysk, Alexander Studenikin, under the article on negligence, due to the fact that in the period from 2017 to 2022 he did not take measures to resettle people from these houses. In February 2026, the official was found guilty, but released from punishment due to the expiration of the statute of limitations.

ключ
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Konkov

The Ministry of Construction of the Altai Territory informed Izvestia that there are no more facilities in the region that were built for the resettlement of citizens, but were subsequently declared uninhabitable. At the same time, the residents of the houses on Specova Street have already been resettled.

—The timing of the implementation of these measures, sources and amounts of their financing were determined by the local government independently," the regional ministry noted.

How often do houses for displaced people turn out to be substandard

This story is not an isolated one. For example, in 2020, the Housing and Communal Services Reform Fund (formerly the Territorial Development Fund) reported that every tenth of the houses built, inspected by specialists of the state corporation, had significant construction defects.

Many houses built for the resettlement of residents have already been declared emergency. In the Penza region in 2020, it was stated that such buildings looked more like "construction cabins sheathed in siding" or "cardboard boxes". They were built in 2014. The Investigative Committee then took control of the case.

ск
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

In Isilkul, Omsk region, in 2015-2016, in houses built using "innovative technologies", aerated concrete walls quickly cracked, and there was a threat of collapse. And in Barabinsk, Novosibirsk region, a wall collapsed near a shelter for displaced people.

As of October 23, the Territorial Development Fund has 123 applications in the register regarding the quality of residential premises intended for the resettlement of citizens from emergency housing. Most of them are from the Sakhalin Region (31) and the Udmurt Republic (22). 36 entries in the register are dated 2025, 36 appeals were sent in 2026. At the same time, the problems of 15 appeals from 2021 have not yet been resolved, and two have been dragging on since 2018. And both went home from the Vnukovo microdistrict of the city of Dmitrov, Moscow region. It is not clear what specific problems are being discussed in the case of these buildings, but it is known that they relate to buildings erected in 2015.

The vast majority of requests from the registry (more than 85%) either missed deadlines or the regions did not report at all.

гвозди
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

The case in Biysk is the so—called reproduction of emergency housing: that is, public funds are spent not on solving the problem, but on postponing and multiplying it, said Viktor Ageev, First Deputy General Director, Director of Urban Planning and Real Estate at the Institute of Urban Economics Foundation.

This is also a serious problem because the resettlement program is far from being completed, and such incidents only make the situation worse. According to the expert, more than 16 million square meters have been settled in Russia since 2019. More than 1 million people have received emergency housing and improved their living conditions. But as of January 1, 2026, 689 thousand more people out of 11.5 million square meters of emergency and uninhabitable housing were subject to resettlement.

— We understand that the program is working, but the incoming flow of the new emergency fund is not drying up. Each such case, as in Biysk, adds to this flow objects that were supposed to be part of the solution, but became part of the problem. This is not just a "minus" in the resettlement statistics, it is the discrediting of the program itself in the eyes of people and an additional burden on the budget in the future," the Izvestia interlocutor emphasized.

Why did new houses become dilapidated

Viktor Ageev cited the lack of effective quality control at the acceptance stage and the unavoidable responsibility for the result as the main reason for cases similar to the Biysk one. In the case of Biysk, the ex-mayor was found guilty of negligence, but only after the problem arose.

— The important question is why the houses were accepted and occupied if they did not meet the requirements? The answer, I think, is typical: the program was carried out according to the indicators of the resettled square meters and resettled residents of emergency homes, and not according to the criterion of their quality of life in the new fund. When deadlines are tight and reporting requires numbers, control weakens," the expert explained.

дом
Photo: IZVESTIA/Gleb Shchelkunov

Meanwhile, Oleg Filippov, Chairman of the Opora Russia Construction Committee, noted that the resettlement program had long stimulated rapid and maximally cheap construction, while responsibility for the result was blurred between the municipality, the regional customer, technical supervision and the contractor. The cost and duration of construction turned out to be more important than the life cycle of the building. As a result, the contractor who offered a low price and a short period of time won. And the low price was achieved due to cheaper or unsuitable materials, simplification of design solutions, insufficient preparation of the base, violations of insulation technology, waterproofing and installation, etc.

— On paper, such a house may correspond to the project, but the actual quality of the hidden work — foundations, floors, insulation, engineering networks — often becomes obvious after settlement, — explained the interlocutor of Izvestia.

The prosecutor's office explicitly mentioned three groups of reasons in official materials: the dishonesty of developers, the abuse of officials and improper control by regional and municipal authorities, he recalled.

стройка
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Bednyakov

At the same time, the mechanism of public control turned out to be weaker than, for example, with shared-equity construction.

— The risks remain even now, although the system has become more formalized. The current rules provide for construction control, verification of compliance of materials with the project and technical regulations, as well as the responsibility of municipalities and contractors for improper fulfillment of obligations," Oleg Filippov added.

Do the risks still exist now

The Ministry of Construction of the Altai Territory noted that since 2018, the updated edition of the Urban Planning Code of the Russian Federation has been in force in the country. It obliges to carry out state construction supervision during the construction of apartment buildings of any number of storeys. In addition, municipalities in 2014 had the right to purchase residential premises for the resettlement of citizens.

The requirements for the quality of newly constructed housing are now really significantly tightened, Viktor Ageev confirmed. Modern resettlement programs require stricter acceptance procedures, the function of construction supervisors has been strengthened, and effective public control by relocated citizens operates in a number of regions.

"However, in order to build substandard housing, it has become really more difficult, we need not only new requirements, but also mechanisms for their inevitable fulfillment: bank guarantees for a long time, developer liability insurance, real personal responsibility of officials not only for inaction after the fact, but also for the acceptance of objects," he drew attention.

капитальный ремонт
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

Expert of the Popular Front project. Analyst Pavel Sklyanchuk suggested that it would be necessary to allocate a separate category of "new emergency workers" — not all migrants with problems, but those who moved into houses built under this program. The fact is that for a developer, such facilities are a kind of "social load," the expert said, and therefore the risks remain.

— At the same time, the market of construction companies has been cleared of very outspoken "fraudsters". There are problems, but they are no longer so egregious, besides, construction control is working," the Izvestia interlocutor admitted.

According to Oleg Filippov, the risks remain high where there is limited competition and the contractor's victory only at the lowest price, weak engineering service from the municipal customer, dependence of supervisors on the customer, lack of independent verification of hidden works, advance payment without sufficient security, acceptance of the object until all defects are eliminated, lack of public contractor history and shortage the time before the end of the reporting period.

"Therefore, it is more correct to say that the program retains the conditions for the appearance of individual, but very serious failures," he stressed. — Control can be considered sufficient only when it not only allows the house to be put into operation, but ensures safe operation during the entire established service life. Today, the system largely verifies the conformity of the facility with the project at the time of commissioning.

ремонт
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

The expert suggested several measures: firstly, the separation of the functions of the customer and the inspector, which should be independent of each other; secondly, the acceptance of facilities with the participation of residents; thirdly, withhold part of the payment not for a short warranty period, but until the confirmation of the normal operation of the house. The fourth measure is to impose responsibility not only on the contractor. It is important to personally evaluate the actions of the municipal and technical customers, the designer, the construction supervisor, etc.

"At the same time, responsibility should not be formal, but property—based: reimbursement of costs for re—resettlement, inspection and dismantling should not automatically fall on the budget," Oleg Filippov concluded.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast