Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The European Union has decided to take control of companies engaged in the extraction of raw materials. MEPs have proposed the establishment of a specialized agency that will be able to acquire shares in such a business, if necessary. The measure is designed to protect European industry and reduce dependence on external suppliers. However, the EU may face difficulties in implementing it due to strict legislation and a fragmented market. What Europe risks in the struggle for raw material independence is in the Izvestia article.

Heavy share

MEPs have proposed the establishment of a European Center for Critical Raw Materials, which will have the right, if necessary, to acquire shares in raw materials companies. According to the plan of the legislators, according to the Financial Times newspaper, the initiative should protect the European industry and reduce dependence on external suppliers.

It is assumed that the new specialized agency will have its own financing and management. It should combine market analysis, sustainability planning, inventory creation, joint purchases, financial instruments, and stakeholder engagement.

Портфель
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

The parliamentarians also want the central government to gain access to the €2 billion commodity fund provided for in the EU's long-term budget for 2028-2034.

In addition, the European Parliament proposes to empower the European Commission (EC) to identify "large companies" in strategic sectors, obliging them to map supply chains and reduce vulnerability when obtaining critical raw materials.

The deputies voted for the creation of the new center last week. The report was adopted by 470 votes. Another 83 voted against, and 108 abstained.

It is noteworthy that the EC announced the creation of the European center for raw materials within the framework of the RESourceEU action plan at the end of 2025. In fact, now the European Parliament just wants to expand the powers of the future agency, which is largely due to the slow progress in achieving the EU's goals on raw materials.

Евро
Photo: Global Look Press/IMAGO

But the deputies' support for the new mechanism does not mean that it will be implemented. The proposal has yet to be approved by the EU member states themselves, and difficulties may arise here.

Raw Needle

The European Union is actively looking for ways to mitigate the difficult situation with critical raw materials in the countries of the region. Earlier, the head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, noted that the EU still has "many dependencies from the outside," which is dangerous for unification.

"We depend on the supply of critical elements from China for more than 80%, and on rare earth elements for 90%. We have done a lot, but we are not the only ones trying to diversify. We urgently need to assess and increase resources, but each country cannot do this alone, so we need to think differently," stressed the head of the EC.

Урсула

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen

Photo: REUTERS/Yves Herman/File Photo

The cornerstone of the association's raw materials policy is the law on critical raw materials, which entered into force in May 2024. In it, the EU set ambitious goals for itself — to increase the volume of mining within the association to 10% of the annual demand, to receive up to 40% of the volume from processing and at least 25% through recycling (recycling) by 2030.

However, the process is going slower than planned, and the European Union is trying to develop new mechanisms. At the end of June 2026, the European Parliament's Committee on Industry, Research and Energy supported new measures to ensure the supply of critical raw materials to the EU. It was about targeted support for strategic projects ranging from mining and processing of minerals to resource recycling.

The Commission of the European Parliament proposed to clarify the procedure for submitting applications for such projects. According to the deputies, the relevant contests should be held at least twice a year. At the same time, the possibility of announcing additional contests in case of bottlenecks was not excluded. On October 20, the European Parliament supported these changes.

In fact, the raw materials initiatives are part of a broader EU economic sovereignty strategy known as "European economic patriotism." Back in 2024, former Italian Prime Minister Enrico Letta and former President of the European Central Bank Mario Draghi spoke directly about the need to create a tool for joint purchases and investments in critical supply chains.

Минералы
Photo: Global Look Press/Alad

Critical raw materials in the EU are considered economically significant because they are used in clean energy, electronics, and defense industries. But these raw materials are at increased risk of supply disruptions, which is why the European Union is seeking to diversify its sources.

Barrier environment

In the last decade, there has been a clash of two multidirectional trends in Europe, says Vladimir Krotkov, Doctor of Political Science, Professor at the Faculty of Political Science at the National University of National Economy. The first concerns issues related to nationalization and the activities of European elites to control and retain capital.

— And the second line is related to supranational regional processes that force capital and elites to compete. Modern conditions suggest that various forms of asset management are possible. And the model in which the state participates is not unique, it is possible, it is being successfully implemented and has now been proposed in the European Union," the expert says.

However, there are a number of difficulties that the EU will have to face in implementing this initiative. Unlike the United States or Japan, where similar mechanisms exist, Europe is characterized by a fragmented market and strict antitrust policies. And the first barrier is the legal one. Article 107 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU prohibits state aid that distorts competition. Therefore, any purchase of a stake in the company must go through a tough sieve of the European Commission.

Еврокомиссия
Photo: Global Look Press/Marius Burgelman

Due to the fact that the European area is considered one of the most legal, that is, the norms of law play a major role in it, a change in the configuration in the shares of companies often leads to various lawsuits, adds Vladimir Krotkov.

— They can be long. And EU legislation is complex: not only national and European, but also supranational and global. The results of such lawsuits can be completely different. But in any case, this means costs for the players who will be involved in such controversial procedures," he points out.

The EU does not have a single tax union, so it is unclear exactly how capital will be contributed to the agency. If the contributions are proportional, richer states like Germany and the Netherlands will automatically have more influence on the agency's decisions than the Baltic or Southern European countries, which will strengthen the economic stratification of the association.

At the same time, an attempt to copy the American instrument carries enormous risks in terms of intensifying trade wars. The United States can print dollars to subsidize its industry, but the euro does not have the status of a global reserve currency, which is why the issue can lead to an inflationary shock and a fall in the exchange rate.

Trade wars have long been the norm and are not considered in the modern world as some kind of deviation, recalls Vladimir Krotkov. Therefore, different configurations of capital and power lead to confrontations in one way or another.

Евро
Photo: Global Look Press/IMAGO

— Since the second term of [US President Donald] Under Trump, we see new trade wars, protectionism, sanctions, and restrictions. In other words, it is a modern instrument of political and economic struggle. The European market and the European business are highly segmented, therefore, in some cases, economic pressure may increase, - the interlocutor of Izvestia does not exclude.

For a number of export-dependent countries, including Germany, the EU's attempt to protect the raw materials market and block access from external players will be a serious problem. Large suppliers, such as the United States and China, may impose mirror duties that will affect the aviation, engineering and pharmaceutical industries of the association. And the European model may not be able to withstand such an escalation of the trade war.

Half-life

Another important aspect is political. It is still unclear who exactly will determine the threshold of "critical dependence". Formally, the European Commission should deal with this, but the EU Council will also have influence, which will give countries whose national production falls under the definition of "critical" a lever to knock out subsidies in other areas. The definition of dependence in this case will be reduced to a multi-level bargaining between Brussels and the national capitals.

And this will increase the risk of internal fragmentation. Germany, for example, may start lobbying for the protection of supply chains for the automotive industry (lithium, graphite, chips), using its financial superiority. At the same time, France will be interested in directing resources to protect nuclear energy (uranium, zirconium) and the aerospace industry. And Southern Europe will require priority for agricultural raw materials.

Завод
Photo: TASS/Helmut Fricke

Fragmentation of the association is already taking place — there is a struggle between protectionism and regional cooperation, says Vladimir Krotkov. And these two principles are related to both the capital and the capabilities of the EU.

— It is important for political elites to keep jobs, pay taxes, etc. And capital, by and large, is interested in minimizing this, especially in times of crisis, including a serious energy crisis. Because energy for the European economic area, as well as for any economic area in general, is one of the key pillars, it is the main factor of development," explains the interlocutor of the editorial board.

First of all, the European bureaucracy is trying to intercept the energy agenda that has begun to spread, according to international commentator Andrei Kuzmak. The principle of "every man for himself" is increasingly in force in Europe, and this is clearly confirmed by the visit of the Slovak delegation to Russia at the end of October.

— This happens in the absence of resources, because of which everyone is trying to pull the blanket over themselves. And [French President Emmanuel] Macron, who visited the Gulf countries in search of diesel for the country, is also proof of this, the expert believes.

In times of crisis, the European Commission is trying to consolidate its influence, seeking to achieve some kind of consolidation, or at least its appearance, he argues.

Танкер
Photo: RIA Novosti/Vitaly Timkiv

"But I'm not sure that many EU members will be thrilled with this idea," the Izvestia interlocutor emphasizes.

The new initiative has the potential to create informal internal barriers where companies from one EU country will face discrimination when trying to integrate into a neighbor's "secure" supply chain. In fact, an agency can provoke internal fragmentation to combat external fragmentation.

The priority is survival

A separate issue is the EU's willingness to turn a blind eye to its own environmental standards. Theoretically, the EU should not take such a step, but in practice it is already making concessions. The regulations on critical raw materials require that the projects in which the association participates meet high environmental and social standards, but the extraction of rare earth metals and lithium is by definition a "dirty" process that requires a huge consumption of water and chemicals.

In the last 5-7 years, the environmental agenda in the EU has ceased to be mainstream and has lost its priority, Vladimir Krotkov believes. The situation has changed especially after the Ukrainian crisis of 2022, when supplies of raw materials, including gas, plummeted.

Газ
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Volkov

— It was already announced at that time that coal would be actively used within the framework of the European Union. And coal is an extremely unecological raw material," the expert recalls.

As a result, there is a conflict of goals: the EU's climate agenda requires accelerated energy transition, which implies rapid production, but strict compliance with European standards makes it 30-50% more expensive than Chinese or Russian competitors.

The confrontation of these lines will only intensify in the future, Vladimir Krotkov believes. Environmental standards are enshrined in legislation, but the EU countries are still large economies, including industrial ones, which have needs for raw materials.

— Therefore, the European Union is already gradually moving away from environmental standards. The initiatives that have been actively developing in the past decades no longer sound so relevant. More pressing economic interests are prevailing," the political scientist emphasizes.

Уголь
Photo: TASS/SASCHA STEINBACH

In fact, the EU is trying to sit on two chairs, moving from liberal politics to pragmatic mercantilism without significantly changing its legal foundation. But the center of critical raw materials in its current form carries more risks than benefits. Europe is almost guaranteed to receive new trade conflicts and increased internal protectionism, while the agency itself could potentially turn into a slow and bureaucratic body unable to compete in speed with Chinese or American state-owned corporations.

The success of the model directly depends on the ability of the European Union to find a balance between the speed of supplies and its own rules, but the union has not been able to do this in crisis conditions in its entire history.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast