Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Europe is once again looking for a replacement for Starlink after the October restrictions in the operation of the system in Ukraine. The dispute over access to American satellite communications became one of the topics of the EU summit and intensified the desire to develop their own technologies. But the Europeans do not have a ready-made alternative yet, it will appear no earlier than 2029. How much an independent connection will cost Europe and why political decisions alone are not enough for this — in the Izvestia article.

On someone else's connection

In October, Ukraine faced restrictions in the operation of satellite communications. Sergei Sternenko, a former adviser to the country's defense minister, said that when traveling at speeds of more than 160 km/h, the terminals began to lose connection. "A number of important missions have been disrupted. SpaceX probably resorted to such measures at the request of the administration of [US President Donald] Trump. The usual satellite communication terminals are working," he wrote on social media.

The involvement of the American administration was his assumption. The reports of restrictions included both the commercial Starlink system and SpaceX's military service, Starshield.

On October 22nd, Trump announced that Elon Musk had lifted the restrictions. According to The Wall Street Journal, the American president personally called the entrepreneur and asked him to restore the system. However, Ukrainian sources continued to report problems. The Ministry of Defense of Ukraine announced the restoration of communications only on October 24.

The connection resumed, but the sediment remained. While Kiev was pushing for the lifting of restrictions, the Europeans were once again talking about dependence on American technology. According to Bloomberg, the EU summit on October 15-16 discussed building up its own defense capabilities and diversifying suppliers of key technologies.

However, Brussels does not expect to accomplish this task quickly. "Ukraine really needs Starlink. But unfortunately, Europe will not be able to replace this technology in the near future," said Kaya Kallas, head of European diplomacy, before the start of the second day of the summit.

A similar position was expressed by the European Commissioner for Defense and Space, Andrius Kubilius. He acknowledged Europe's dependence on American space capabilities and called for preparations for Washington to shift its attention to another region. "The EU should be very practical. If the United States one day transfers its resources to the Asia-Pacific region, we must be ready to replace them," he stressed.

Its own orbit

Europe will not have to start from scratch: it has its own satellite operators. One of them is Eutelsat with the OneWeb low—orbit network. The company already provides communications in Ukraine through its low-orbit and geostationary satellites. But having an operating operator does not mean that it is possible to quickly replace the American system in all military tasks.

Brussels expects to close part of the needs of government and military users through GovSatCom. The system is designed for crisis communication, border protection, maritime surveillance, and critical infrastructure management. In 2027, the list of available resources is planned to be expanded at the expense of commercial operators.

A separate international agreement is provided for Ukraine's participation. On March 9, 2026, the EU Council authorized the European Commission to begin negotiations on Kiev's access to GovSatCom and the public services of the European secure Communications program. But such permission does not grant the right to use the system.

The EU's main calculation for the future is related to IRIS2, its own secure satellite communications network. The total number of IRIS satellites will be 348 units. It should serve government agencies, military and emergency services, as well as provide commercial services. The program was approved in 2023. In December 2024, the European Commission signed a 12-year contract with the SpaceRISE consortium, which includes operators SES, Eutelsat and Hispasat.

The designated dates have already been reviewed. When approving the program, it was assumed that the system would be fully operational by 2027. Now it is expected that the European satellite system will be able to fully function no earlier than 2029.

What the expert says

Experts interviewed by Izvestia are skeptical about the prospects for reducing the EU's dependence on the United States. The association has long relied on American capabilities and is now facing the consequences of this choice, according to military analyst Anatoly Matviychuk.

— Europe understands that it is hooked on the security of the United States, and now it is necessary to solve this problem. Yes, there is a technological base, they are making an electronic digital base. Great Britain and France are launching satellites. But I don't see a system in Europe that could replace Starlink in the near future," the expert notes.

Creating your own network will require large investments, he continues, recalling that European countries used to use Russian services to launch satellites into orbit, but this cooperation has stopped. Now the EU will have to look for other opportunities and incur additional costs.

— Once upon a time we provided our space services to the Europeans: Great Britain, France, Germany launched satellites with our help. Today it is not there, everything is destroyed. This is very expensive, and as you know, there is no money in Europe today," the analyst emphasizes.

In addition to financial difficulties, Matviychuk sees political obstacles. According to him, there is an influential pro-American lobby in Europe, and close ties with businesses from the United States will prevent reducing dependence on Washington.

— Even if they want to get off the American needle, American businesses and American banks will practically not allow them to do so. In general, most likely, all this will remain conversations," the Izvestia interlocutor believes.

Military expert, captain of the 1st rank of the reserve Vasily Dandykin also doubts that the Europeans will be able to quickly replace Starlink. British satellites used to be launched from Baikonur with the participation of Russia, he points out. According to the expert, Europe has its own devices and launch capabilities, but it has seriously lagged behind in creating a network comparable to the American one.

At the same time, disagreements over satellite communications do not mean the end of American support for Ukraine, Dandykin draws attention. European countries continue to purchase weapons for Kiev, including from the United States. Therefore, despite the disputes about independence, defense cooperation with Washington remains.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast