Coming and going: how right—wing forces plan to reform the European Union
The European right is increasingly advocating a revision of the principles of the European Union, demanding that more powers be returned to nation states and that the influence of Brussels be limited. Only recently, such demands have been voiced by politicians in three countries at once — Italy, France and Germany. And although their points of view differ on some issues, the basic idea of creating a "confederation of independent states" is quite clear. How realistic such plans are and whether they are capable of changing the political course of the European Union from the inside is described in the Izvestia article.
Got into a pose
The leader of the German opposition Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, Alice Weidel, demanded that the European Union be turned into an association of "sovereign states," the British newspaper The Telegraph reported. According to the publication, the implementation of this plan will lead to a weakening of ties between the participating countries and actually endanger the existence of the EU.
"We would like to rebuild and reform the European Union. The EU is no longer a union of sovereign states. National parliaments and governments must take the decision—making process into their own hands," Weidel said.
The AFD leader also warned that if this initiative fails, the party will seek Dexit, Germany's exit from the EU by analogy with the United Kingdom. One of the key stages in the implementation of such a scenario will be the victory of Alternative for Germany over the center-right CDU/CSU bloc, which is part of the current ruling coalition. If successful, the AfD is ready to put the issue of the country's withdrawal from the union to a referendum.
The party also advocates a significant change in the principles of the country's interaction with the European Union. Among the proposals are the replacement of the European Court of Justice by an arbitration body, a reduction in Germany's financial contribution to the overall budget of the association and a revision of the course towards achieving zero emissions.
In addition, the party calls for the abolition of direct elections to the European Parliament: deputies, according to the initiative, should be appointed by national parliaments. Among other things, the EU member States are invited to grant the right to waive the application of a number of pan—European legislative norms.
All these initiatives, as The Telegraph notes, may face serious resistance from Germany's pro-European center-right leaders.
Have you found any allies
However, Alternative for Germany is not the only European right—wing political force advocating a revision of the principles of the European Union. More recently, similar statements were made by the current Prime Minister of Italy, Giorgio Meloni, and the candidate for the presidency of France from the National Unification Party, Marine Le Pen.
Back in September, Meloni said that the EU should abandon the course of federalization in favor of a confederate model — the concept of a "Europe of native lands." As part of this approach, the member States of the association would maintain their political independence while strengthening cooperation with each other.
"Just the opposite is needed: a confederate European model in which member states retain broad sovereignty but cooperate more effectively on issues of strategic importance," the Italian prime minister said in an interview with Il Foglio newspaper.
Le Pen, in turn, during an October speech in Brussels, announced her intention to turn the European Commission into a "secretariat" subordinate to the member countries of the association. She expressed dissatisfaction with the fact that the heads of EU institutions are appropriating powers that were not delegated to them. As examples, the politician cited plans to create her own intelligence service and form an EU army, as well as the association's participation in diplomatic activities.
The French politician noted that reforms in the European Union can be carried out in the coming years — after the elections in Spain and Poland, where, according to analysts, right-wing forces may come to power. "This will be our common project for years and decades to come. <...> It will not be limited to simply undoing what has been very poorly done on the European stage over the past 30 years," Le Pen stressed. According to her, the new "Europe of Nations" should be built on the basis of EU institutions that do not have power over the member states of the association.
The idea of "restructuring" the EU is not new at all. For example, back in July 2021, 16 European right-wing parties signed a Joint Declaration on the Future of the European Union, which, in fact, represented a kind of manifesto of freedom and patriotism for many politicians. At that time, the conservatives opposed the transformation of the EU into a centralized supranational "superstate" with the concentration of power in Brussels and demanded that the members of the European Union be given the status of sovereign nations.
The signatories of the declaration included Viktor Orban's Hungarian Fidesz party, Jaroslaw Kaczynski's Polish Law and Justice Party, Matteo Salvini's Italian League and Giorgi Meloni's Brothers of Italy, Marine Le Pen's French National Union, the Spanish Vox party led by Santiago Abascal, as well as the Austrian party freedom. They were also joined by representatives of right-wing political movements in Belgium, the Netherlands, Denmark, Finland, Greece, Bulgaria, Romania, Lithuania and Estonia.
The document became a challenge to European political elites: it was published in response to the call by French President Emmanuel Macron and EU leaders for Europeans to participate in the "Conference on the Future of Europe." This large-scale project involved civil consultations on development issues. However, behind the democratic rhetoric of the European elites, there was a desire to counteract the position of eurosceptics and ultimately strengthen the centralization of power in the EU, limiting the influence of individual states on key decision-making.
Shock therapy
Nevertheless, the original goal of the European populists is not so much the collapse of the European Union as the revision of the principles of its functioning. We are talking about a reassessment of certain mechanisms and provisions of the Lisbon Treaty, signed in 2007 and reformed the management system of the association. In particular, the document provided for the creation of the post of President of the European Council, consolidated the status of the EU as a legal entity and abolished the "three pillars" system, which defined the principles of its functioning from 1993 to 2009.
— From the very beginning, the right-wing forces have criticized the European Union due to various internal crises. For example, Alternative for Germany, founded in 2013 as a party of moderate euroscepticism, advocated Germany's exit from the eurozone so that German taxpayers would not finance the rescue of southern European countries. However, Brexit has shown many countries, including France and the Netherlands, how difficult and painful it can be to exit the European integration project. That is why the populists' focus has shifted to changing the EU from within and returning powers to nation states," says Sergey Shein, a leading researcher at the Center for Comprehensive European and International Studies at the National Research University Higher School of Economics.
The expert also notes that right-wing political forces are primarily concerned about the EU's migration and climate policies, budget expenditures and the further centralization of power in Brussels. At the same time, they do not have a single clear idea of what a "Europe of Nations" should look like. And the question of how feasible these transformations are, even if the right comes to power in Germany or France, remains open.
They don't need that.
Loud statements by right-wing politicians, according to experts, force Brussels and other European elites to restrict the access of populists to power. For this purpose, in particular, coalition agreements between representatives of traditional political forces are used, as well as mechanisms of political isolation similar to the "Firewall" in Germany. However, even the coming of conservatives to power in France or Germany will not necessarily lead to a radical revision of the European course. Much will depend on the position of other states and the willingness of EU institutions to make concessions during the negotiations.
One should not overestimate the likelihood that Alternative for Germany will receive enough votes in the upcoming elections and will have impressive weight to be able to form a monolithic government and implement changes in the country's life, and not just conflict with the EU, says international commentator Andrei Kuzmak.
At the same time, abandoning the current course may mean de facto recognition of the failure of the pan-European project launched after the Maastricht Treaty, which will increase skepticism about further integration.
— In my opinion, much will depend on the development of the conflict over Ukraine and Europe's ability to act as an independent political entity. If the EU does not achieve its stated political goals, but at the same time suffers economic losses, states will increasingly be guided by the principle of "every man for himself", abandoning common initiatives and values, the expert concludes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»