Trust the attorney: the court protected the driver from an expired breathalyzer
Checking the driver for intoxication should be carried out using alcohol analyzers that have been tested and have the appropriate certificate, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation ruled. The use of devices that do not meet these requirements is a violation, and the results obtained with their help cannot be grounds for bringing motorists to justice, lawyers and experts say. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
Breathe into the tube
In November last year, in Tatarstan, traffic police stopped the driver Ifanov (surname changed. — Ed.), suspecting him of driving under the influence. A breathalyzer test confirmed their suspicions: the device detected an excess of the set threshold (more than 0.16 mg per liter of exhaled air) of ethyl alcohol in the motorist's body. Based on the protocol drawn up by traffic police inspectors, the justice of the peace of judicial district No. 4 in the Leninogorsky judicial district of the Republic of Tatarstan found Ifanov guilty under Part 1 of Article 12.8 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation "Driving a vehicle by a driver in a state of intoxication", deprived him of his rights for a year and a half and imposed a fine of 45 thousand rubles.
The motorist did not agree with this decision and challenged it in the Leninogorsk City Court of the Republic of Tatarstan, and then in the Sixth Court of Cassation of General Jurisdiction. As an argument, Ifanov pointed out that the breathalyzer on which the study was conducted had not been tested in accordance with the established procedure at that time. However, all the judicial authorities ignored this argument and upheld the decision of the world court. As a result, the driver filed a complaint with the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (SC RF).
Different dates
After reviewing the case materials, the Supreme Court declared the decisions of the lower courts illegal. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation recalled that the survey should be carried out using measuring instruments of an approved type, certified in accordance with the established procedure in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation on ensuring the uniformity of measurements. At the same time, the Supreme Court found that it follows from the alcohol intoxication examination report that the Jupiter breathalyzer, which was used to monitor sobriety, was tested on July 3, 2025 and had a valid certificate that damages the accuracy of its measurements. However, it follows from the copy of the verification certificate of this device attached to the case file that the device was verified on May 20, 2024, and the verification certificate itself is valid until May 19, 2025.
"Thus, the data on the verification of the named technical means, indicated in the act of the alcohol intoxication examination, contradict the verification certificate. The judge of the city court did not request a certificate of verification of the ethanol vapor analyzer in exhaled air, <..."the relevant arguments of the complaint have not been properly verified, and they have been formally rejected," the Russian Supreme Court said in a statement.
As a result, the Supreme Court overturned the decisions of the lower courts and sent the case for a new hearing.
The punishment must be legal
The main evidence of guilt in this situation is the results of a breathalyzer examination, said Sergei Radko, a lawyer for the Freedom of Choice movement. Since the validity period of the verification certificate has expired for this device, its testimony is considered inadmissible evidence, the lawyer emphasized.
— The legislation clearly prescribes the procedure and rules for conducting an inebriation examination. Since there is every reason to believe that this procedure was not followed, it is logical that the Supreme Court overturned the decisions of the lower courts, which formally examined all the circumstances, and returned the case for a new hearing, Sergei Radko told Izvestia.
Sergey Smirnov, an auto lawyer, shares a similar point of view. In any case, the driver's license is likely to be returned to the motorist, he said.
— The statute of limitations for cases involving drunk driving is one year. Given the current practice, it is likely that the court simply will not have time to review the case again, and it will eventually be closed due to the expiration of the statute of limitations. But even if the case is reviewed again, given the inconsistencies in the dates of the breathalyzer test, the driver will most likely be found innocent. In both cases, he will remain with his rights," believes Sergey Smirnov.
Drunk driving is a gross violation of traffic regulations, and a drunk driver is a potential criminal, said Valery Soldunov, a member of the Public Association, a member of the Public Council under the Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation, chairman of the All—Russian Society of Motorists. Such motorists deserve the most severe punishment, he believes.
— However, the decision to impose such a punishment must be made in strict accordance with the norms and rules established by law. The requirement for mandatory verification of the breathalyzer, which confirms that the device produces correct and correct measurement results, is one of the fundamental conditions for the driver sobriety control procedure. And any deviations from this requirement are unacceptable," Valery Soldunov believes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»