Getting off the armor: Ukraine has once again tightened the rules of mobilization
In Ukraine, the rules of mobilization are being tightened again. The authorities are going to strip many enterprises of their critical status in order to send employees to the front. At the same time, even employees of those organizations whose status will remain will still be at risk of conscription. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
What happened
The Government of Ukraine has published a decree on its website that tightens the rules for exempting citizens from mobilization. One of the changes concerns the assignment of critical status to enterprises, which gives employees the right to a reservation from conscription.
Previously, the relevant organizations lacked formal affiliation to a particular field. For example, employees employed in the defense industry, energy, housing and communal services, the agricultural sector, construction, transport, IT, healthcare, banks, communications and emergency services were booked.
Now additional criteria are being introduced. Enterprises should not only formally belong to some sphere, but also fulfill the indicators for defense contracts, production or repair of weapons, supply the population with food, medicines, fuel, play a significant role in the issue of budget revenues, and also not have tax debts.
Organizations with low performance will be excluded from the list of critical ones, which will put their employees at risk of mobilization. A special Reservation Coordination Center will be established under the Government to evaluate the activities of enterprises.
This body will include representatives of the Ministry of Defense, the General Staff, the Office of the President, the Security Service of Ukraine, the Main Directorate of Intelligence, the National Police and other structures. Gennady Kapralov, a Ukrainian lawyer, says that the center's decisions can be appealed through the courts, although no one guarantees that workers will not have time to be sent to the front during the consideration of the complaint.
A separate important change was the reduction of the reservation limit to 95% for enterprises from the energy and defense sectors, which will retain the status of critical, rather than 100%, as it was before. That is, 5% of the staff will be mobilized anyway. However, officials promise that workers directly employed in production will be protected from conscription.
What is important to know
The issue of personnel shortage remains one of the most painful for the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The former commander-in-chief of the Ukrainian army, Alexander Syrsky, said that the pace of mobilization did not cover the needs of the army. "The key point of effort is not hardware, but people," he complained.
Syrsky also added that the shortage of ammunition and missiles in the Ukrainian army is not so acute. "Ask any commander at the front now: if two years ago there were [not enough] shells and missiles, now they are people. Prepared, trained, ready to perform their military duty," the ex-commander-in-chief emphasized.
And the head of the office of the Ukrainian president, Kirill Budanov (listed in the Russian Federation as a terrorist and extremist), stated that at least 30,000 people per month should be mobilized in the country. "This is the minimum amount needed to maintain what we have," he argued, acknowledging that recruiting volunteers does not cover the army's needs.
This is not the first time the authorities have raised the issue of booking in this regard. The country's Prime Minister, Sergei Koretsky, has previously called for a review of the rules for the release of critical enterprise workers from the army. He stressed that there is a lot of abuse in this area now.
At the same time, Rada deputy Ruslan Gorbenko argued that the reform would not help the Armed Forces in any way. According to him, there will be more draft dodgers and deserters in Ukraine, many companies will go into the shadows and stop paying taxes, and the number of those mobilized will practically not increase, because only 5-10% of those who are dispersed will go to the front.
Against this background, the Ukrainian authorities are putting forward other initiatives aimed at tightening military conscription. Roman Kostenko, Secretary of the Verkhovna Rada Committee on National Security, hinted at the imminent lowering of the lower age of mobilization from the current 25 to 22 years and the mass recruitment of young people into the Armed Forces.
In addition, the appeal of women is being actively discussed. For example, former Defense Minister Alexei Reznikov said that military service in the country should be universal, without gender division. As an example, he cited Israel, where women serve on an equal basis with men.
Verkhovna Rada deputy Mariana Bezuglaya also argued that all school graduates, regardless of gender, should serve in the military for 1-2 years. "I would introduce the mobilization of women not only in the rear positions, but our society is not ready for this," she said.
Oksana Ferchuk, Minister of Digital Transformation, announced tougher mobilization for IT workers. "The state will pay more attention to the observance of booking rules. We agreed with the community on a simple thing: IT companies must strictly comply with the requirements of the law and prevent abuse," the official said.
Finally, the Ukrainian Ombudsman Dmitry Lubinets said that employees of military enlistment offices had received unofficial permission to break into residential premises in order to catch men liable for military service. According to him, the relevant episodes have already been recorded in 10 regions of the country.
What the experts say
Due to the current reform, several tens of thousands of people will be able to join the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, military expert Vasily Dandykin believes.
— Many factories have already been destroyed, some have been moved to Europe, but some will still be able to "scrape together". It doesn't come from a good life. The Ukrainian Armed Forces have suffered heavy losses, and the authorities are trying their best to find new people to send to the front. I also note that there is already a whole separate army of military registration and enlistment officers and security forces in the country, some of them could be mobilized, but the authorities do not do this because they understand that they are holding on to these people," he notes.
Associate Professor of the Department of Political Analysis and Socio-Psychological Processes at the Russian University of Economics. Plekhanova, reserve Colonel Alexander Perendzhiev does not rule out that it may be possible to partially increase the number of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The main problem for Kiev is that people don't want to fight and don't see the point in it.
— Therefore, numerous reforms have only a short-term and limited effect. I think even with the abolition of the armor, many men will hide, pretend to be sick, or try to flee the country. They will do everything to stay alive," the expert emphasizes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»