- Статьи
- World
- Raft of hope: The European Commission has come up with a new way to combat illegal migration
Raft of hope: The European Commission has come up with a new way to combat illegal migration
The European Commission (EC) intends to turn the Frontex border agency into a key agency dealing with deportations of migrants who do not have the right to remain in the territory of the European Union (EU). A rapid response pool is also planned within this structure, which should arrive at the site within two days in case of an acute security crisis. However, there are concerns that the new agency will not be able to perform many functions without adequate funding. Whether strengthening Frontex will become a real response to the migration crisis in Europe or will it remain just another attempt to solve a systemic problem using superficial methods is in the Izvestia article.
Migrants overboard
The European Commission plans to turn the Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex) into the central agency of the European Union for the deportation of illegal migrants. European Commissioner for Internal Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner said this in an interview with the newspaper Welt am Sonntag.
"We are consistently continuing the European migration transformation. In particular, Frontex needs to be transformed into the EU's central agency for deportations. Those who do not have the right to remain in the EU must really leave it," the politician said.
Brunner noted that he plans to present a legislative initiative as early as October 27 in order to "make Frontex more versatile and strong." One of the most important points of the plan is the establishment of a "deportation coordination center", in which the European border Agency will take a leading role. And although the European Commissioner has not yet disclosed details about the content of the document, the decisions taken earlier allow us to judge the scale of the upcoming transformations. For example, as the newspaper notes, starting next year, the permanent Frontex corps, numbering up to 10,000 border guards, should be fully ready to perform operational tasks.
The structure is also considering creating a kind of "rapid response pool" — it is proposed to use it in the event of serious security threats or a sharp increase in the flow of refugees. The forces will have to arrive at the scene within 48 hours and resolve the problems that have arisen. This, in particular, is being done in order to avoid cases like the July migration crisis in the Spanish exclave of Ceuta.
Further — more
However, Magnus Brunner clarified that the expansion of the agency's powers would require increased funding. "In the draft of the next long—term budget of the EU (2028-2034), the European Commission proposed doubling the amount of allocated funds," he said.
The European Commission's proposal provides for the allocation of €12 billion in a new financial plan, but, according to Welt am Sonntag, Ireland, which holds the presidency of the EU Council, proposed halving this amount as part of a compromise draft budget. In this case, Frontex probably won't be able to fully handle the new tasks.
According to the publication, the agency is already facing a lack of funding to achieve certain goals. For example, it has already exhausted the funds allocated for 2026 for the implementation of the European reintegration program. This initiative provides for the payment of one-time assistance to migrants in settling in their homeland after their voluntary return from the EU. The newspaper cites a significant increase in interest in the program as the reason for this.
According to the EC, as of October 2026, approximately 21 thousand people have signed up for the support program, which is 59% more than in the same period last year. The European Commission eventually requested an additional €50 million. It is expected that a decision on the allocation of these funds will be made in the coming weeks.
The implementation of the new Frontex program will require certain costs, since working with refugees is far from a cheap occupation, confirmed Alexey Portansky, a leading researcher at the IMEMO RAS Foreign Economic Policy Sector. However, according to the expert, this will not become some serious factor of pressure on the European budget. Officials will be able to find funds for these needs, as the issue of illegal migration has remained significant for EU citizens for a long time.
In turn, Elena Sidorova, Head of the International Monetary and Financial Relations Sector at IMEMO RAS, clarified that the EC is determined to expand the role of Frontex in the deportation processes - it seeks to increase the amount of resources allocated to it, as well as increase the efficiency of its deployment.
— Given the general trend towards increased spending on defense, security, and increased attention to the military-industrial complex, it can be assumed that Frontex will receive this budget, albeit through the redistribution of some "civilian" programs. In addition, another reform (expansion of powers) of Europol was also announced in the summer, the third in the last six years with a budget of €3 billion. By the way, it is also interesting that around the same time, the European Framework for Emergency Response is being discussed to strengthen the EU's response to "artificially organized and weaponized" migration, the expert said.
It is also worth noting that representatives of European states and the European Parliament positively assess the results of reintegration. According to their calculations, financial support for migrants under this program costs the EU significantly less than the maintenance of people who arrived in Europe and were denied asylum.
In early June, the EU Council and the European Parliament preliminarily agreed on new pan-European rules governing the procedure for the return of foreign citizens who do not have legal grounds to stay in the territory of the economic association. The adopted rules provide for the possibility of establishing "return centers" in third countries, which can be used as final or transit points for human accommodation before subsequent return to their homeland or to other countries.
There is a crisis
Experts say that strengthening the role of the Frontex agency in organizing events for the return of migrants who do not have the right to remain in the European Union may simplify the implementation of deportation decisions, but it will not eliminate key obstacles along the way. The main problem is that the decision on expulsion does not mean its execution. It is necessary to complete all the documents, arrange transportation and obtain the consent of the country to which the refugee is returning.
Sergey Shein, a leading researcher at the Center for Comprehensive European and International Studies at the National Research University Higher School of Economics, shared with Izvestia the opinion that the European Commission's initiative is an attempt to strengthen the centralization of the European Union's migration policy, which is currently being implemented at several levels. For example, EU institutions establish common rules, member states coordinate approaches and financing, and national governments are responsible for the practical implementation of migration measures.
— In turn, the expansion of the coordinating role of Frontex can simplify cooperation between countries and reduce the administrative burden on national authorities when organizing the return of migrants who do not have the right to remain in the EU. However, I would not overestimate the effect of this reform, because even with a more centralized system, the execution of decisions on return largely depends on the cooperation of third countries and the willingness to accept people back," the expert explained.
Frontex's capabilities are objectively limited. In particular, the agency cannot independently ensure the return of a person if his State of origin or another country of destination refuses to accept him. The outcome of the new central agency of the European Union for the deportation of illegal migrants will depend on many factors. Among them, one can note not only the level of cooperation with various States, but also the availability of necessary documentation, accessibility of logistics chains and compliance with legal procedures, including the principle of not sending people to places where they are threatened with persecution or serious harm.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»