The lawyer called the signs of an artificial discount before Black Friday
Customers should track the cost of goods in advance so as not to confuse a real discount with a marketing ploy. Sofya Lukinova, head of the Legal department at VMT Consult, told Izvestia on October 26 how to check the price before the sale and what to do if a pseudo-discount is suspected.
"The main mistake in the sales season is to evaluate the benefits by the size of the discount, and not by the final price. The inscription "minus 50%" in itself does not mean anything about savings. It is important how much the same product cost before and how much other sellers are asking for it now," the lawyer noted.
According to Lukinova, it is better to start monitoring prices for products of interest at least two to three weeks before the promotion. For expensive equipment and furniture, the observation period can be extended. This will allow you to see the dynamics of the cost and understand whether the product has really fallen in price or whether its price was first increased before the sale and then returned to its previous level.
For example, if the product cost 20 thousand rubles, and during the promotion a crossed-out cost of 30 thousand rubles appeared next to the same price, there is no actual savings relative to the previous offer. At the same time, it is necessary to compare the same products and conditions: model, package, seller, warranty and shipping cost.
How to recognize a pseudoscide
One of the signs of a possible pseudo-slip may be a sharp change in value immediately before the start of the sale. An unusual price change schedule can also alert you if the store or marketplace allows you to view it.
At the same time, the strange dynamics of the cost does not in itself prove a violation. The price may depend on the region, the personal coupon, the seller, or other conditions.
Before paying, it is important to look at the total cost of the order. Shipping, additional services and accessories can significantly change the amount. You should check the bonus conditions separately: a refund of a portion of the cost in points does not mean an immediate price reduction.
If the discount is provided only when a paid service is enabled, it is worth comparing the cost of the entire offer with the purchase of goods without it. A large discount percentage by itself does not mean that the purchase is really profitable.
You should not respond to messages like "two items left" or a countdown timer without additional verification. Even with the limited duration of the promotion, it is useful for the buyer to compare the price with the offers of other sellers and decide whether he needs the item without taking into account the pressure from advertising.
What the law says
Article 10 of the law "On Consumer Rights Protection" obliges the seller to provide the necessary and reliable information, including the price of the product in rubles and the terms of its purchase. At the same time, there is no general requirement in the article itself to always indicate the price of the product before the discount, and there is no universal deadline for maintaining the crossed-out value.
"Therefore, the lack of savings in relation to the price that was a week ago and the legally proven misleading of the buyer are not the same thing. When assessing the situation, the content of the advertisement, the terms of the promotion and the information that the consumer received are important," explained Lukinova.
If the price is in doubt, you must save the product card, the terms of the promotion, the order confirmation, the receipt and the correspondence with the seller. It is advisable to record the page address, date and time, product name, seller, and discount conditions in the screenshots.
How to prove a violation
According to Lukinova, the buyer should keep the confirmation of the value of the goods before the start of the promotion. This is especially important if the price has remained the same or increased during the sale.
"It is enough to fix prices using screenshots before the discount and send a claim to the store's support. This is acceptable evidence if the address bar is visible on the screenshot," the lawyer said.
The claim must describe a specific situation: what price was stated, how much the buyer paid, and what he sees as a violation. You can request an explanation of the cost change.
However, there is no automatic right to refund the difference between the current price and the previous value. If the buyer agreed to the specified price and paid exactly this amount, the mere fact that the product used to cost less is not enough to demand a refund.
If the seller refuses to resolve the issue, the buyer can contact Rospotrebnadzor. If it is necessary to recover funds or protect other property claims, the issue may require going to court.
Can the seller cancel the order and offer to buy the product at a higher price
A separate situation arises when, after placing an order, the seller reports a technical error or damage to the product and offers to purchase the same product again, but at a higher price. According to Lukinova, in this case it is important to talk not about the technical possibility of changing the price, but about legal restrictions. As a general rule, the seller does not have the right to arbitrarily change the terms of an already concluded contract. A reference to a technical failure by itself does not give him the unconditional right to waive his obligations to the buyer.
In such a situation, the buyer should keep a confirmation of the original order and its price, a cancellation message, as well as a new offer to sell the product. At the same time, it is not necessary to prove the premeditation of the seller's actions: the fact of the conclusion of the contract, the agreed terms and circumstances of the refusal to fulfill it are important.
Do you still have rights when buying at a discount?
By itself, the discount does not deprive the buyer of the rights provided for by law. Therefore, the wording "promotional items are non-refundable" cannot automatically override the established rules.
The specific exchange and refund options depend on the type of product, the method of purchase, and the reason for the request. If the discount was granted due to a pre-determined defect, it is not possible to make claims specifically for this known defect.
"My main recommendation is to come to the sale with a pre—determined need and a limited budget. A good purchase is the one that is needed and really profitable at full cost, not the one with the largest percentage on the red price tag," Lukinova concluded.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»