Market ruins: why oil prices on stock exchanges have lost their meaning
The global oil trading system is increasingly fragmented. The difference in prices between similar grades of oil can be one and a half times, and some regions are already accustomed to paying more than others. In fact, price benchmarks have become very conditional indicators, and invisible fluctuations in specific contracts are much more significant than stock prices. How much the Gulf War has divided the world and what effect this difference will have on global trade in the foreseeable future is in the Izvestia article.
The Wonders of Arbitration
For many decades (starting from the 1970s and 1980s), the global oil market functioned as a single mechanism. Prices were formed around several key benchmarks (benchmarks) — North Sea Brent, American WTI and Middle East Dubai/Oman. The cost difference between hundreds of different grades of oil around the world has always existed, of course. However, this gap was mainly determined by the physicochemical properties of the raw materials, such as the density and sulfur content. Light and low-sulfur oil was more expensive because it was easier to get gasoline and jet fuel from it, while heavy and sulfurous oil was sold at a discount due to more complex processing. The difference could be several percent, and there were some regional nuances in this picture, but on the whole the market was predictable.
Price distortions were quickly eliminated by the commodity arbitration mechanism, and transportation costs were minimal. Before the outbreak of hostilities in the Middle East, shipping one barrel by sea cost on average less than $3. If oil in Asia suddenly rose in price relative to Europe, traders loaded VLCC-class supertankers in the Atlantic and sent them to the east, capitalizing on the difference in quotations and quickly returning the market to a state of equilibrium.
Logistics is the head of everything
The blocking of Hormuz and the problems in the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait in the last six months have led to the collapse of the established model. Logistics has become the main price-forming factor. Sea freight rates and insurance premiums for military risks have reached prohibitive levels. According to rough estimates by industry experts, the average cost of transporting a barrel of crude oil via inter-regional routes has soared to $20-25.
The arbitration window has closed. The movement of volumes between macroregions has lost much of its commercial meaning, and the single space has split into zones of acute deficit and local surplus. Oil can now be both extremely expensive and abnormally cheap — it all depends on where the buyer is located.
There is a surplus of raw materials in North and South America. Canadian Western Canadian Select grade oil, which was traditionally supplied to refineries in the American Midwest, and its surplus was exported to Asia, was trapped on the continent. The high cost of freight has made flights from the ports of the Gulf of Mexico or the west coast of Canada to the Asia-Pacific region unprofitable. Left without foreign markets, the WCS grade is being sold at prices of about $70 per barrel, at a record discount to global benchmarks. The average price of American shale oil on the Gulf coast is kept around $100.
West African varieties (produced in Nigeria and Angola) are also trading at unprecedented discounts, often $10-20 cheaper than Brent. This is due to the high cost of their delivery to key consumers in India and China.
In energy-deficient regions, the picture is the opposite. European refineries are forced to overpay for raw materials from nearby sources in order to minimize transportation costs. Brent, which is mined in the North Sea a few hundred miles from the main European hub in Rotterdam, is trading at a huge premium precisely because of the short delivery leverage. Its price in Europe reaches $125 per barrel. Asian importers are in an even more difficult position: Omani oil shipped to southern China is estimated to be closer to $150 per barrel due to the enormous risks of passage through the blocked straits.
To the north
The Russian oil industry is also facing deep fragmentation of pricing. Until 2022, the price of the main Urals export grade was formed in European ports at a clear and stable discount to Brent. After the reorientation of supplies to the east, its structure began to depend on the route and transport.
In 2026, the gap in the cost of Russian varieties became particularly noticeable. ESPO oil, shipped from the port of Kozmino in the Far East, is in high demand from Chinese independent refineries. This route is completely free from Middle Eastern risks, and the delivery time to the ports of China is only a few days. Due to logistical security, ESPO shipments trade at a minimal discount or premium to other regional benchmarks, bringing exporters high returns even under sanctions.
The situation with Urals shipped from the Baltic and Black Sea ports looks different. To deliver this oil to India or China, tankers have to go around Africa. The cost of freight on such a long route eats up a significant portion of the suppliers' profits. The price of Free on Board (that is, when loading in a Russian port) is decreasing due to high transportation costs (it recently dropped to almost $80 per barrel), but the cost to the end customer in an Indian port, including shipping and insurance, remains extremely high. In October, it sometimes exceeded $130 per barrel.
In such conditions, the strategic importance of the Northern Sea Route increases dramatically. Summer-autumn navigation allows Russian companies to deliver raw materials to Asia faster and safer than using the southern route, which makes it possible to keep export revenues at an acceptable level. Nevertheless, the problem of expensive logistics, which is common to the entire market, also affects domestic companies, reducing the profitability of supplies from the European part of the Russian Federation.
Regionalization on the march
The United States is to some extent the main beneficiary of the current situation. The United States covers 75% of its import needs due to supplies from Canada, Mexico and Venezuela, countries whose oil almost never leaves the Western Hemisphere and is sold at significant discounts. The total bill for raw materials for American refineries is kept below $ 100, while the European and Asian industries are forced to work in conditions of prices from $ 120 to $ 160. At the same time, it should be understood that according to the Hamburg account, America loses less than others rather than gains something.
There is currently no single global oil market. Stock indicators like ICE Brent or NYMEX WTI have become purely local benchmarks that do not reflect the real cost of energy for most of the planet. Each importing country has its own price, depending on the length of the safe sea route.
If the military conflicts in the Persian Gulf and the Red Sea become protracted and last until the end of this year, the regionalization of commodity markets will be consolidated definitively. Eurasian countries will face a long-term decline in industrial competitiveness due to permanently expensive raw materials. Importers will have to factor a twofold increase in logistics costs into the production cycle (not only the direct cost of transportation, but also insurance), which will inevitably lead to a new round of inflation in the Eastern Hemisphere while maintaining relative stability in North America.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»