Motherboard: what Russians are afraid of when planning pregnancy
The proportion of Russians who have not given birth to a child by the age of 45-49 is about 10%. This figure hides not only a conscious choice, but also fears, financial difficulties, and inability to build personal relationships. Why women who do not want to have children are referred to a medical psychologist for consultation, what arguments experts find and when the maternal instinct "turns on" — in the Izvestia material.
The main reasons for fear of pregnancy
The proportion of women in Russia who have not given birth to a single child by the end of their reproductive period (i.e. by the age of 45-49) is about 10%. This physiological condition is called "final childlessness," Lyubov Yerofeyeva, WHO expert on reproductive health and rights, gynecologist, senior lecturer at the Medical Faculty of the University of Synergy, tells Izvestia.
— If we compare with the indicators of other European countries, our indicator is one of the lowest. In the vast majority of Western European countries, this figure is 20-25%. Our incomplete 10% includes both voluntary childlessness, when a woman herself refuses pregnancy and childbirth, and forced, that is, infertility, lack of a partner or other difficult life circumstances, such as the loss of a loved one," she explains.
Almost 90% of women who do not want to have children cite financial difficulties as the main reasons: lack of housing, lack of confidence in the future and a partner who can share the hardships of everyday life. Someone refers to career prospects — the need to get an education, separate from parents and find a good job. Many people do not want to raise a child alone or are afraid of getting into an unstable relationship. In some cases, the husband does not want the baby to be born, and the wife is most likely influenced by him, the specialist notes.
— An important point is the state of health. Some women experience gynecological problems (menstrual irregularities, painful menstruation) and are afraid of their aggravation. There are those who hesitate to take up motherhood, remembering previous pregnancies that tragically ended or were interrupted for one reason or another. Someone's baby was stillborn or died at a very young age. Sometimes a woman refuses the joy of motherhood because she thinks she will be a bad mother. Perhaps this was suggested to her as a teenager: most often by relatives, maybe even by her mother," the gynecologist lists.
Candidate of Psychological Sciences Alina Koroleva also draws attention to the fact that fears of not becoming a good mother are usually associated with physical and psychological abuse that a woman suffered from her mother in childhood.
— And since psychotrauma changes reactions and leads in a "rolling manner," the fears in this case are very justified. Roughly speaking, it's like passing on a complex genetic disease. Here, work with a psychologist is relevant, but it is necessary for several years to help free oneself from the influence of childhood traumas resulting from violence and form new patterns of behavior and reactions in stressful situations," she believes.
All of these aspects have a huge impact on women's reproductive intentions.
— Sometimes the refusal is also based on conscious childfree (propaganda of the phenomenon is prohibited in Russia) — a personal position in which a person does not see the point in parenthood. The proportion of women who voluntarily and consciously do not want to have children ranges from 2 to 4%," explains Lyubov Yerofeyeva.
Who is referred to psychologists
"Methodological recommendations for the medical examination of men and women of reproductive age for the purpose of assessing reproductive health," approved by the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation in February 2026, provide for the referral of a patient for a consultation with a medical psychologist. This is possible if a woman puts the number "0" in the questionnaire as an answer to the question: "How many children would you like to have, including those born". The initiative is of a recommendatory nature, but experts emphasize its importance. In some cases, such a measure cannot be dispensed with.
Alina Koroleva believes that in this case it matters what qualifications and experience the psychologist has and what approaches to the problem he will use to dispel the patient's inner fears.
If a woman puts a zero in the column answering the question of how many children she wants to have, then the goal is not to force her to become a mother, but to inform her, Lyubov Yerofeyeva emphasizes. In particular, about the available measures of state support for families, as well as about the possible consequences of refusal.
— This is the position of the Ministry of Health — using official information and scientific arguments to dispel fears of motherhood in a situation where a woman already has an unplanned pregnancy. The psychologist's task is to separate real obstacles from irrational, fictional ones, perhaps just deposited in the head from youth or childhood," the WHO expert points out.
Examples of support from various charities and religious organizations will also help convince a woman that having a child is not a financial disaster, she believes. Psychological issues are also subject to discussion.
— Someone, for example, has temporary crises in a relationship with a man. Then everything will get better, and spontaneous refusal of pregnancy can be fatal: a woman risks losing both the ability to procreate and the relationships that could form a family," the gynecologist emphasizes.
The interlocutor of the editorial office also draws attention to the fact that in the men's questionnaire the question about the number of children is formulated differently than in the women's questionnaire: "How many children would you like to have, given your current life circumstances". If the answer is "0", a referral to a psychologist is not provided.
— From the point of view of both gender equality and modern bioethics, this discrepancy can be called a typical case of a double standard. The right to make a decision about parenthood belongs equally to both men and women, but it is the female answer "0" that is a problem requiring psychological correction, and a similar male one is a normal life choice. Some experts already believe that this approach can lead to the fact that women simply stop being sincere with doctors, says Lyubov Yerofeyeva.
Absolute contraindications
Lyubov Yerofeyeva draws attention to the futility of trying to convince a woman whose decision is dictated by objective and insurmountable circumstances. These include absolute medical contraindications for pregnancy. In these cases, pregnancy can end in disaster, disability, or death.
"Modern medical ethics prohibits the manipulative and forced formation of certain favorable attitudes," the WHO expert on reproductive health emphasizes.
The Ministry of Health has clinical recommendations and a whole list of conditions in which pregnancy and childbirth pose a direct threat to women's lives and are considered absolute contraindications.
— These include severe diseases of the cardiovascular system, lungs, kidneys, liver and other vital organs. The list includes, in particular, heart failure of the 3rd and 4th functional class, aortic aneurysm, complex congenital heart defects, severe pulmonary hypertension, high-grade respiratory failure, chronic renal failure of the 4th and 5th stages, when dialysis is required, cirrhosis of the liver with signs of portal hypertension, oncological diseases. that require the immediate start of aggressive chemotherapy and radiation therapy, and others," the obstetrician-gynecologist lists.
The list also includes a group of systemic connective tissue diseases, especially in the active phase, when vital organs are already affected (systemic lupus erythematosus, severe pulmonary hypertension, kidney damage).
— Severe mental disorders are considered an absolute contraindication. In this situation, in the case of pregnancy, the decision is made only by a council of professional psychiatrists," adds the editorial interlocutor.
When the maternal instinct turns on
Modern biologists and psychologists agree that humans do not have a fully programmed maternal instinct as such, notes Alina Koroleva. The specialist calls what is meant by this term a complex interweaving of various factors that motivate a mother to take care of a child. These include socially approved behavior, hormonal levels, tenderness, oxytocin, which is produced when looking at a baby, as well as the experience of caring for younger children in the family or among friends.
Lyubov Yerofeyeva also considers it a myth that the maternal instinct wakes up automatically in all women at the right moment.
— Modern neuroscience and psychology do not use such a term as instinct in relation to complex reproductive parental behavior in humans. In this case, hormones work. During pregnancy, oxytocin (called the attachment hormone) and prolactin (the "hormone of motherhood") are released. These same hormones are present at high levels during childbirth and during breastfeeding. They can indeed form attachment and reduce anxiety, but this does not guarantee that a woman will automatically have a love for a child or a desire to take care of him," the gynecologist emphasizes.
For many women, an emotional connection is formed very slowly and gradually, the WHO expert emphasizes. It usually occurs during pregnancy or in the very first months of caring for a newborn — through interaction with him, putting him to the breast, tactile contact and the realization that the child is completely dependent on the mother and cannot exist without an adult.
— In reality, a fairly significant part of women (according to various scientific publications, up to 20%) do not have this instant click "I am a mother". Moreover, they may develop postpartum depression or have great difficulty becoming attached to a child. And these are, in principle, normal medical and psychological phenomena. They are not considered proof that a woman's instinct has broken down," says a reproductive health specialist.
At such a time, a young mother needs the support of her loved ones more than ever. Lyubov Yerofeyeva considers the everyday stereotype "when a child is born, and his mother will definitely love him" to be very harmful. Sometimes it prevents a woman from seeking help in time.
A dangerous trap
Society sometimes traps women on its own. According to Alina Koroleva, there are a lot of invisible demands on mom in society right now. In addition to caring (entertaining, watching, feeding, washing, putting to bed, soothing), a woman should ensure the psychological comfort of the child.
"At the same time, the educational aspects remain unclear — how exactly to raise a child, how to show him the limits of what is acceptable and provide the very psychological comfort that is so much talked about," she draws attention.
According to the unwritten laws of ideal motherhood, a woman is obliged to develop a baby in every possible way — by herself and with the help of clubs and sections. At the same time, the child's life should follow a strict schedule, where everything is subordinated to this development. The psychologist draws attention to the fact that in such a cycle there is no room for ordinary play, and the child is deprived of the opportunity to occupy himself independently.
— Mothers are also under pressure from elements of juvenile justice, which have somehow leaked to us. Women subconsciously fear that at some point, for unknown reasons, the child may be taken away. Thus, the pressure on a potential mother is unprecedented," the specialist believes.
She points out the need to form a new culture of support for young mothers based on mutual assistance.
— Previously, when several generations lived in the same apartment or house, most young mothers received such support. Now, when grandparents continue to work actively, and the young live separately, the level of family support has decreased, and new options for assistance have not yet been formed," notes Alina Koroleva.
The issue of having children often becomes a stumbling block in a relationship: if the positions of the partners differ, this often leads to the breakdown of the relationship, the specialist warns.
— It's a matter of values: you can have different opinions about how to put your socks away, but at the same time live together and feel emotional comfort, — says the interlocutor of the editorial office.
When there are differences in value issues and basic aspects of the family, such as the birth of a child, people move away from each other, as the opportunity to remain emotionally close disappears. If the pregnancy occurred before marriage, then some men suggest "waiting" and "living for yourself", convincing the partner to give up pregnancy for the sake of future relationships. In this case, it makes sense for a woman to think about the seriousness of her partner's intentions.
— You can't get a man's good attitude by making any concessions. Unfortunately, abortion is a useless sacrifice. A woman is usually left alone with serious consequences," warns Alina Koroleva.
Overcoming fears of pain, betrayal and financial difficulties helps the highest meaning of having a child — the continuation of oneself in the next generations, the psychologist believes. For those who have not yet met their "own" person, the editorial's interlocutor advises them to believe and keep looking.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»