Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The European Union is changing its behavior in the Arctic. The draft of the updated EU Arctic strategy, presented on October 20 in Brussels, demonstrates the rejection of radical climate initiatives of previous years. If in the 2021 document the European commissioners demanded an unconditional international ban on any oil and gas production in the region, the new version softens the approaches. Why the Europeans have come to their senses, how this will affect the Arctic race and which states will receive the greatest benefits from the new regimes — in the Izvestia article.

The Norwegian Ultimatum

The text of the document states that the European Union will give priority to renewable sources and energy resources extracted outside the Arctic zone. However, the fight against the development of new oil and gas fields and the purchase of polar raw materials in the region will be conducted only when these projects "pose a threat to the Arctic ecosystem." Brussels' position on this issue has softened over the past five years due to changes in Europe's energy mix. After the reduction of Russian pipeline supplies and against the background of the logistical crisis in the Middle East, which complicated the delivery of liquefied natural gas (LNG), Norway assumed the status of the EU's main energy donor. Oslo provides over 30% of the total gas consumption of the association.

Нефтяная вышка
Photo: RIA Novosti/Maxim Bogodvid

The problem is the depletion of mature Norwegian deposits in the North and Norwegian Seas. A drop in production at these sites is expected as early as the early 2030s. In order to maintain export performance, it is necessary to "move" drilling rigs to the north, developing the shelf of the Barents Sea, which is located beyond the Arctic Circle.

Actually, these changes are largely a product of Norwegian lobbying. Oslo has repeatedly made it clear to the EU that exploration and drilling in the circumpolar seas will continue regardless of the wishes of the European Commission. A conflict with the main supplier and a neighbor against the background of problems with Russia, the Middle East and even America is the last thing Brussels would like.

Corporate interests

The mining clause, as long as it "does not threaten the ecosystem," is a loophole for large businesses. If the EU had maintained a total ban on Arctic projects, European banks and investment funds would have been forced to close credit lines for companies operating in the north due to strict ESG investment regulations.

The largest corporations of the continent operate in the Norwegian sector of the Barents Sea. Italian Eni is present there through a large stake in Var Energi, while French TotalEnergies and Anglo-Dutch Shell are also active. The state-owned Norwegian company Equinor is also widely represented in the portfolios of European investors.

Евросоюз
Photo: Global Look Press/Michael Kappeler

The new wording allows Oslo to certify its offshore platforms (operating in a part of the sea that is not frozen due to the Gulf Stream) as conforming to European environmental standards. This legalizes projects in the eyes of European auditors and preserves oil companies' access to cheap bank financing. Energy concerns investing in projects in Alaska or Canadian terminals are also receiving a positive signal — reducing reputational risks facilitates their participation in international consortia.

It is important to understand that the European Union regulates access to other people's resources, not manages its own. Of all the EU member states, only Finland, Sweden and Denmark belong to the Arctic geographically. At the same time, there are no offshore hydrocarbon reserves on the Scandinavian Peninsula. Denmark formally represents Greenland, but the island enjoys broad autonomy, has not been a member of the European Union since 1985, and pursues an independent economic policy. Back in 2021, the local government curtailed offshore exploration due to prohibitively high operating costs and environmental considerations.

Accordingly, for Brussels, the entire discussion about Arctic mining boils down solely to the right to invest in foreign projects and import raw materials obtained from there.

Geopolitics and the Battle for Metals

The previous strategy of 2021, based on environmental maximalism, has failed. The slogans about the need to "leave oil and gas in the ground" were ignored by all the key players in the region. Russia continued the development of the Northern Sea Route and the construction of Arctic LNG plants, China strengthened its presence through the concept of the "Polar Silk Road", and the United States stepped up drilling in Alaska. Brussels' threatening climate rhetoric only scared continental investors and led to European companies voluntarily ceding market share to geopolitical competitors.

In addition to saving gas imports, the updated strategy pursues another, not obvious, but very important goal. The document focuses on the extraction of rare earth metals and critical minerals, in particular lithium, cobalt, nickel and graphite.

Добыча ископаемых
Photo: RIA Novosti/Anton Vergun

There are deposits of this raw material in Europe. They are mostly located in the north of Sweden, Finland and Greenland. Access to them is necessary for the European industry to assemble electric vehicles, manufacture wind turbines and ensure the operation of the military-industrial complex (which in recent years has become one of the priorities). China's dominance in the rare earth processing market forces the EU to look for domestic sources of raw materials. Due to the radical environmental agenda, the issuance of licenses for the opening of new mines and mines in northern Europe was often blocked. The relaxation of the common Arctic rules should reduce administrative barriers for the mining sector.

Europeans are gradually moving towards a more pragmatic energy policy after experimenting with "energy idealism." At first glance, the facade of the document will remain, but the changes are such that politics can turn 180 degrees, since "expediency considerations" have gained the opportunity to overcome any ideological order. Of course, eco-activists and green parties will continue to fight this agenda to the best of their ability, but it is unlikely that the political mainstream will give them too many such opportunities. In general, the change of direction is more aimed at "keeping the pants on" in terms of the current production of European companies in the Arctic, rather than at any breakthroughs in energy sovereignty. The European Union will continue to depend on supplies from abroad, and Russia will need to take this into account.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast