The lawyer spoke about the risk of legal action for negative reviews
Lawyer Alexander Manko explained in which cases a negative online review can lead to a court case. In an interview with the "Paragraph" on Monday, October 19, he noted that Russians may face lawsuits due to negative reviews of goods and services if the accusations contained in them cannot be confirmed.
As an example, the expert cited the case of 2024, when a dental clinic sued a patient who accused doctors of removing the wrong tooth and called them cripples. Since the author of the review could not confirm his words with a medical examination, the court ordered him to delete the publication, post a rebuttal and pay the clinic 150,000 rubles for damage to business reputation.
Manko explained that it is important to distinguish between a subjective opinion and a statement about specific facts. For example, a restaurant visitor has the right to complain about slow service, but accusations of using stale products will require proof.
The lawyer added that in many cases, it is possible to resolve a conflict over a negative review by deleting a controversial publication. kp.ru .
In September, Anton Arifulin, a consumer rights lawyer and member of the Russian Bar Association, spoke about the rules for writing negative reviews, notes 360.ru . He stressed that clients can share their experiences with companies, but publications should contain real circumstances and not humiliate a person. For false information discrediting the business reputation, the author may be required to delete the publication and compensate for losses, writes NSN.
Also in September, lawyer Marcel Kirlan, in an interview with RIAMO, stated that it is important to distinguish personal opinion from statements about specific facts. For example, reports of damaged goods, violation of refund deadlines, or lack of response to a claim are verifiable, so the reviewer needs to have proof of his words.
In April, media technologist and lawyer Ekaterina Dashevskaya told Izvestia that slander in messengers can lead to criminal liability even when discussing in closed chats. In addition, the procedure for handling libel cases has changed.: They have been transferred to the category of private-public charges, which limits the possibility of their termination upon reconciliation of the parties.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»