Breaking Bad: why Europe is gripped by a wave of protests
Barricades are burning in the center of Milan: protests against the rising cost of living have escalated into clashes with the police. Demonstrators pelted security forces with stones and smashed storefronts, while police responded with water cannons and tear gas. Riots also occurred in Turin and Bologna, hundreds of participants were taken to the police. Italy has become another European country where social discontent has brought people to the streets. Mass demonstrations continue in France as well, with protesters blocking the Louvre Museum in Paris. Why a wave of discontent has engulfed several European countries at once, who is taking people to the streets and what it threatens governments — in the Izvestia article.
You can't do anything without money.
Italy followed France in mass protests. Only after Sunday's riots in Milan, the police took 271 people to police stations, 220 of them minors. 32 demonstrators have been arrested, and 28 more are being investigated as suspects.
The reason for the speeches was dissatisfaction with the rising cost of living, fuel prices and taxes. In September, a liter of gasoline in the country cost about 2.1 euros, and the tax burden reached 42.8% of GDP, one of the highest levels among the countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
The actions did not remain peaceful for long. In Milan, teenagers threw chairs at storefronts, vandalized shops and took out goods. Among the affected facilities are Carrefour, Under Armour and Levi's. The Victor Emmanuel II Gallery had to be placed under heavy security, and the Milan Cathedral was temporarily closed to tourists.
The clashes with the police lasted for several hours. Bottles, firecrackers and improvised incendiary devices flew at the security forces. Police responded with water cannons and tear gas, but individual groups managed to break through to the Piazza del Duomo.
One of the features of these riots was the age of the participants. Children aged 11-13 were taken to the police. Many people had never participated in political actions before and came to the center after seeing what was happening on social networks. One of the teenagers explained to a Corriere journalist: "If you're poor, you can't have anything." Another said that for him, smashing up a city means protesting against a state that "doesn't see young people."
In the morning after the clashes, a queue formed at the police stations. Parents came to pick up their children, often only finding out at night that they were in the city center at all. One teenager boasted that he had spent 15 hours in the police station. The father greeted the other with the words: "I would be glad if you got your head smashed in. I would have broken it for you myself." Two of the released men told reporters that there were 28 people in the room with them.
The preliminary damage from the riots in the country is estimated at 1.1–1.6 million euros. About three quarters of the amount is accounted for by shops, restaurants and cafes — this is damaged property and lost revenue. The rest is damage to urban infrastructure.
After the weekend, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni called a special security meeting. The Government will have to decide how to respond to the form of street riots involving teenagers.
France after the pogroms
Monday morning in Paris started with problems at the Louvre. Students of the Louvre School blocked access to the museum in support of protesting schoolchildren and against the actions of the police. They couldn't open the museum at nine in the morning. "We are proud to block the largest museum in the world," the protesters said.
In France, the scale of the riots turned out to be significantly larger than in Italy. On October 17 alone, according to the preliminary estimate of the Federation of Trade and Distribution, about 1.5 thousand retail outlets were affected. The damage to the industry may amount to several hundred million euros.
On the night of October 18, a temporary synagogue building was vandalized in Paris. In Limoges, demonstrators set fire to the city hall. The building, built in 1883 and included in the list of historical monuments of France, has been completely destroyed.
The capital suffered especially badly. In the Republic Square area, masked men spent hours opening metal shutters with crowbars and hammers, smashing storefronts and taking out everything that could be quickly picked up or resold. Groceries and alcohol were being dragged from supermarkets, appliances from electronics stores, and clothes from boutiques. They were looking for expensive Pokemon collectible cards at the Manga Story store. "People filmed themselves. There was complete lawlessness," an employee of the store told reporters.
A few blocks from Republic Square, the La Barrique bar-restaurant almost completely burned down. Its owner, Alin, was inside during the attack and ended up in the hospital with a head injury. When the fire was extinguished, only charred walls remained of the establishment. However, the very next evening, young people were climbing into the ruins again in search of cigarettes, alcohol, and anything else they could carry.
The bad example turned out to be contagious. A video posted on social media showed several police officers in protective gear carrying boxes out of a vandalized building. The authors of the publications claim that the security forces allegedly "take" goods from the stores themselves. Later, this version began to be disputed: some French media and users pointed out that the footage could contain goods and physical evidence seized from looters.
Interior Minister Laurent Nunes has already offered his resignation to President Emmanuel Macron, but the head of state has not accepted it. "Those who staged pogroms, attacked prefectures and shops, and even robbed our city halls will be brought to justice and punished. <...> We will all unite in the face of those who sow chaos, seek only to destroy our institutions and prevent people from peacefully expressing their demands," the French leader said.
After the weekend, Prime Minister Sebastian Lecornu demanded that local authorities impose a partial curfew if necessary. We are not talking about restrictions for the whole of France: the decision should be made by the prefects based on the situation on the ground.
What the experts say
The current protest wave has already spread beyond France, but it is too early to talk about a single pan-European movement, said Andrei Yashlavsky, a leading researcher at the IMEMO RAS. In almost every country, he said, people are taken to the streets for different reasons.
— In France, the tone was initially set by schoolchildren and young people in general, who were dissatisfied with the state of schools — dilapidated buildings, a shortage of teachers and other problems. In Spain, rising house prices have come to the fore. Italy was no exception, with protests taking place in Milan. There were actions in Portugal, and youth performances in Albania are continuing. That is, each country has its own reasons, its own reasons and its own triggers," he said.
At the same time, the protests are gradually ceasing to be exclusively youth-oriented. In France, schoolchildren and students are joined by their parents and pensioners. Yashlavsky sees one of the reasons for the current unrest as the fact that the European authorities are not sufficiently dealing with internal problems.
"The only thing they can be advised to do is pay more attention to the desperation of their own citizens, and not to the wishes of Kiev clients, where the attention of European politicians is now redirected — both political, financial, and so on," he said.
At the same time, Izvestia's interlocutor does not expect drastic political changes. In his opinion, the authorities may make some concessions, make new promises, or dismiss some of the ministers, but there is no need to expect a drastic change in the situation in the foreseeable future.
Meanwhile, Natalia Eremina, a professor at St. Petersburg State University, draws attention to the political component of the youth protests. According to her, student and school communities in France have long been on the radar of parties that are trying to work with future voters and use protest activity to their advantage.
— On the one hand, young people are really dissatisfied with rising prices, job prospects, and changes in labor and pension legislation. On the other hand, political forces that need to rely on the protest electorate are showing interest in street performances. For example, Jean-Luc Melenchon, the leader of Unconquered France, visited the demonstrators," the source said.
Young French people have accumulated a whole set of complaints and concerns, she pointed out. They are worried about job prospects, rising living costs, and environmental issues. All this pushes young people to unite and makes them more receptive to the protest agenda.
— A critical mass of questions has accumulated today: life is becoming more expensive, and work and prospects are becoming more difficult. Young people feel this especially acutely," she concluded.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»