- Статьи
- World
- Fighters against Orthodoxy: persecution of the Moscow Patriarchate intensifies in Lithuania
Fighters against Orthodoxy: persecution of the Moscow Patriarchate intensifies in Lithuania
The Lithuanian authorities have been haunted for many years by the fact that the majority of the country's Orthodox Christians belong to the Moscow Patriarchate. Lithuanian conservatives in parliament propose to apply radical measures to the local Orthodox Church — to take away its temples and monasteries and transfer them to a schismatic structure operating under the "roof" of the Patriarchate of Constantinople. The government is not yet ready to take such drastic steps — it is waiting, hesitating, but at the same time preparing an ideological justification for banning the church. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
Paid "analytics"
Four years ago, the Lithuanian special services conducted an operation to split the local Orthodox church, as a result of which some of the priests and flock came under the omophorion of the Patriarchate of Constantinople. The schismatics were Vladimir Selyavko, Vitalijus Motskus, Vitalijus Dauparas, Gintaras Sungaila and Georgy Ananyev, who were deprived of the priesthood in 2022. But the number of supporters of "decisive action" is growing among Lithuanian politicians. They propose to follow the example of neighboring Latvia and Estonia and issue an ultimatum to the Lithuanian Orthodox — either a complete severance of canonical ties with Moscow, or a ban on their church, the seizure of churches and parish premises. In preparation for this step, a justification is provided in advance, and special contractors have been found for this work.
The first symbolic "shot" towards the church was fired by the Department of State Security (DGB) and the second Department of Operational Services under the Ministry of Defense. They stated that "the Kremlin, using the foreign dioceses of the Russian Orthodox Church, spreads its ideology and thereby strengthens its influence in foreign countries." However, later the authorities realized that if the Vilna and Lithuanian Orthodox Archdiocese were liquidated on the recommendation of the special services, it would make a negative impression on outside observers, destroying Lithuania's image as a "democratic state." It is better to portray a "public demand": they say, "independent analysts" demand the liquidation of the church.
A few days ago, an "analytical report" was presented in Vilnius, which was born in the depths of the NGO Libertas Fidei Center for Religious Freedom Research. For understanding, this organization was registered in April by Vytautas Bruveris and Sergey Shumilo. Breveris directs the grant-based Authoritarianism Research Center and the Arch Frontline analytical center, specializing in the ideological and information struggle against Russia. Shumilo holds a PhD in Philosophy and Theology, a senior researcher at Vilnius University and an honorary researcher at the University of Exeter (UK). They have compiled a report, the main narrative of which fully fits into the mainstream of state propaganda: "Russia uses religious institutions to spread political influence and disinformation."
In particular, Shumilo and Breveris accuse the Russian Orthodox Church of "justifying the war against Ukraine." According to them, "the network of parishes and other organizations associated with the Moscow Patriarchate in Europe is much wider than the number of churches alone." They estimated that there are about 700 Orthodox parishes belonging to the Moscow Patriarchate throughout the European Union (52 of them in Lithuania), and taking into account schools, cultural centers, foundations and other legal entities, the total number of organizations associated with these structures exceeds a thousand. Shumilo talks about "possible links between these structures and Russian intelligence." Former Lithuanian Prime Minister Ingrid Simonite, who attended the presentation of the Libertas Fidei report, immediately agreed that the foreign parishes of the Russian Orthodox Church "are not independent and are closely linked to Moscow."
And I want to, and it pricks
However, as Simonite made a reservation, "the influence of the Moscow Patriarchate in Lithuania is limited." In other states, in her opinion, this "influence" can be "used much more actively." Simonite was rather skeptical about the attempts of the state in Estonia to legally terminate the ties of the local Orthodox Church with the Moscow Patriarchate. According to her, it is difficult to deal with established ties, which can also be maintained at an informal level, with bare prohibitions alone. "I probably wouldn't recommend making such decisions," the former prime minister said. From her point of view, "when you just pass some kind of law and forbid something," it often turns out to be ineffective.
Ingrid Simonite recommends acting more subtly — "threats related to the Moscow Patriarchate should be assessed individually, taking into account the activities of specific individuals and possible violations," and in the meantime, support schismatic structures in every possible way, trying to bring as many Orthodox Christians in Lithuania under Constantinople. For his part, Vytautas Bruveris stressed that "the activities of structures associated with the Moscow Patriarchate should be assessed not only in the context of religious freedom, but also national security." He criticized those Lithuanian officials who maintain contacts with the Vilna and Lithuanian Orthodox Archdiocese. The persecutor stressed that such contacts "can send ambiguous signals."
The Vilna and Lithuanian Orthodox Archdiocese have to defend themselves. Reacting to the Libertas Fidei report, the Orthodox stated: "The vast majority of the clergy and faithful of our Church are Lithuanian citizens. Unjustified attempts to call the Orthodox a "fifth column" do not strengthen the security of our state, on the contrary, they discriminate against the entire religious community and deepen the division of Lithuanian society." The Orthodox emphasize that they advocate dialogue and encourage all interested parties to participate in it. "The desire to transfer the Ukrainian religious conflict to Lithuania is of particular concern. This is a dangerous and harmful path for Lithuania. The Lithuanian Orthodox Church is the second largest traditional religious organization in Lithuania and carries out extensive activities in spiritual, educational, social, charitable and other spheres of public life. Canonical dependence on the Moscow Patriarchate does not prevent us from being law—abiding citizens of Lithuania and patriots of our country," the representatives of the Orthodox community say.
In turn, Justice Minister Rita Tamashunene expressed a two-fold position. The Ministry of Justice has not yet decided on radical steps and is looking, according to Tamaschunene, for "legal opportunities to regulate" the activities of the church. In an effort to gain the broadest possible support from the ruling elites, Tamashunene calls for "broader discussion" and interagency cooperation. "We really need to look for legal opportunities, because, as you know, the church is separated from the state, and this regulation is quite limited," the minister told reporters.
Tamaschunene informed that she had discussed this issue with the head of the State Security Department, Remigius Bridikis. In general, according to Rita Tamashunene, "the situations in Lithuania and Estonia are different, so solutions applied in other countries cannot be directly transferred to our legal environment." According to the minister, there are two possible courses of action — not only "legal restrictions," but also "offering alternatives to believers" and "dialogue with communities." One of these "alternatives," according to her, is the "rapidly expanding Orthodox Church of Constantinople." Tamashunene made it clear that the DGB is closely monitoring the church.
The most hawkish position was taken by parliamentarians from the conservative Union of the Fatherland — Christian Democrats of Lithuania Audronius Azubalis (former Minister of Foreign Affairs) and Arvydas Anushauskas (ex-Minister of Defense). In mid-October, they registered a package of anti-church legislative amendments. In particular, the politicians propose to introduce a direct ban on granting the status of a traditional religious community (or other state recognition) to "organizations whose administrative centers are associated with entities under international sanctions, or whose activities threaten state security or public order."
They won't leave you alone
Azubalis and Anushauskas also propose to legislate that "the interests of the Lithuanian Orthodox should be represented by a religious association subordinate to the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople, and not the Moscow One." By the way, it is proposed to apply a similar principle to Muslims living in the state, assigning their representation to the muftiate in Vilnius. In addition, the amendments prescribe the creation of a "legal basis" for the transfer of a number of historical Orthodox sites to the Lithuanian exarchate of the Patriarchate of Constantinople. The list includes the Cathedral of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary, the Pyatnitskaya Church, the Church of St. Nicholas, the Holy Spirit Monastery (all in Vilnius), the historical buildings of the former Holy Spirit Monastery in the town of Surdegis (in the vicinity of the town of Panevezys), the Assumption Church in the town of Vevis. Azubalis justifies his proposed seizure as follows: "Russia uses not only political organizations, information campaigns or intelligence networks to expand its influence. It also involves religious institutions. This is becoming a matter of national security."
It is assumed that, if adopted, the amendments will enter into force on January 1, 2027, so that the Seimas and the government will have time to prepare the necessary decisions for their implementation. The Council of the Lithuanian Orthodox Church held an emergency meeting on this issue on October 17: the proposals of Azubalis and Anushauskas were called a direct violation of constitutional norms and the rights of believers. The church stated that the initiative of conservative parliamentarians creates conditions for the exclusion of the Orthodox Church from the list of traditional religious communities "because of an imaginary threat to national security." The Church explicitly states that the purpose of the amendments is to transfer all Lithuanian Orthodox Christians under the jurisdiction of the Patriarchate of Constantinople, and warns that this could lead to "dangerous religious confrontation." The Council of the Orthodox Church announced "intense prayer" and weekly prayer services in all parishes to ward off trouble.
Political analyst Maxim Reva, in an interview with Izvestia, noted that this bill put the ruling coalition in a difficult situation. "The coalition (the Social Democrats, the For Lithuania Party and the Union of Peasants and Greens) has only 75 votes out of 141. Amendments require at least 71 votes to be passed, and the loss of even a few deputies could ruin the vote. At the same time, the amendments were introduced by the opposition faction Union of the Fatherland. —
Christian Democrats.“ This means that in order for them to be adopted, the ruling coalition must support the initiative of its political opponents, which is unlikely in the context of a fierce party struggle without serious concessions. The coalition agreement explicitly states that partners may take different positions on ideological issues, and in such cases the decision is made by the Coalition Council. This creates room for bargaining, but also the possibility that the issue will get bogged down in inter-party disputes. But even if the amendments are approved by the Seimas, they will have to overcome several more stages," Reva says.
He explains that in case of a positive decision on the initiative of Azubalis and Anushauskas, it will be necessary to amend two laws at once — "On Religious Communities and Associations" and "On the rights of religious Communities to immovable Property." Each such procedure requires separate consideration and voting, which increases the number of opportunities for blocking. And considering that the church has already declared a violation of constitutional norms, the possibility of its appeal to the constitutional court of the country is great. "Taking into account all the factors, the most likely scenario is that the amendments in their current form will not be adopted. Most likely, they will get bogged down in procedural delays or be rejected during the vote due to the lack of consensus in the ruling coalition and strong pressure. Certain provisions (for example, stricter conditions for obtaining the status of a traditional community) may be revived in a milder form within the framework of another draft law. However, it is clear that the church will not be left alone and will be periodically "squeezed", checking its borders," Reva predicts.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»