Put on pause: can the Central Bank return to tightening monetary policy
The upcoming pivotal meeting of the Board of Directors of the Bank of Russia may determine the vector of development of the Russian economy in the near future. The expected decision on the key rate is worrisome — in September, the regulator took a pause in the key reduction cycle, which potentially creates the possibility of a return to monetary policy tightening. At the same time, the rigidity of recent years has already created difficulties for businesses. What the new growth cycle threatens is in the material of Izvestia.
On different sides of the barricades
At the last meeting of the Board of Directors, the Bank of Russia kept the key rate at 14%. This was the first pause in the decline cycle that began last summer. Such a suspension is an alarming signal for businesses. There is a possibility that, given the continuing inflationary pressure, the Central Bank may move to raise the "key".
At the same time, statements about excessive rigidity of PREP have been made for a long time. Critics of this course argue that the structure of the modern Russian economy is facing shocks that cannot be fixed solely by clamping down on the money supply. The discussion on this issue, in particular, began during the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum. Dmitry Mazepin, founder of the Uralchem Group, said that the Central Bank's actions aimed at cooling the economy have already become an internal challenge at this stage, as they lead to its hypothermia.
And the owner of infrastructure and mining assets, Roman Tortsenko, recalled the "Volcker shock" — the aggressive increase in interest rates by the US Federal Reserve System in the last century, which provoked a prolonged recession in the American economy. He noted that Russia, in fact, repeats this experiment, calling the current situation a "Zabotkin trap."
According to the head of Sberbank, German Gref, the Russian economy today is facing the four horsemen of the apocalypse — a high interest rate, a growing tax burden, a strong ruble and administrative barriers. Earlier, he also said that the Central Bank reacts by keeping the rate at a high level to any shock, whether it is an increase in VAT, tariff indexation, closure of the Strait of Hormuz or strikes on refineries. However, the new conditions require a more accommodative monetary policy.
It is not only business that insists on excessive high rates, but also the economic block of the government. Back in 2023, when the Bank of Russia had just started its next increase cycle, Maxim Reshetnikov, the Minister of Economic Development of the Russian Federation, criticized the Central Bank for overly harsh PREP, calling it a risk to the economy.
Meanwhile, Russian President Vladimir Putin does not consider the actions of the regulator to be erroneous. During the Eastern Economic Forum in 2026, he stated that the PREP in Russia is not "very tough." He called the high key rate a conscious decision, stressing that without a stable macroeconomic situation it is impossible to count on full-fledged investment growth.
Dangerous vulnerability
The main cost of maintaining rigidity is borne by the market segment that generates the least inflation. Investments in fixed assets are declining, and loan rates, although they have decreased recently, are still too high for businesses. This is especially true for small and medium-sized enterprises. For grocery stores, for example, margins rarely exceed 10-15%, and even with loan rates of 17-19%, the store continues to work "for the bank."
The rate of closure of SMEs is now at a record high (12-15 thousand companies cease to function every month, which is about three times higher than the value of the previous nine years). And such a decline, according to some estimates, will continue until the middle of 2027. The situation can change only in the case of a sharp decrease in the "key", tax relief and stabilization of the geopolitical situation.
At the same time, the business has no safety margin left, so further tightening of conditions for the private sector, according to experts, will not be an additional cooling, but a depression. There are increasingly opinions that the 4% inflation target is, in fact, a striving for the ideal of the past. It was established at a time when prices were rising smoothly, and economic and geopolitical shocks were rather rare. Technically, it is possible to achieve the target, but it is unlikely to secure it for a long time. And the price for this will be high.
Tough, but not enough
The main goal of the Russian monetary policy is to ensure the stability of the national currency and price stability. At first glance, the mechanism underlying the formation of the DKP seems simple — the regulator must determine how much money will be in the system, taking into account the state of the economy, maneuvering between soft (stimulating) and hard (restraining) policies.
The choice in favor of the latter is made if the economy is developing at an excessively high pace. To stabilize the situation, the Central Bank raises its key interest rate, regulates the amount of money that commercial banks keep in its accounts, and sells assets on the open market. As a result, banks have fewer funds to lend, which makes loans more expensive.
However, the increase cycle initiated by the Central Bank in 2023 did not meet its expectations — monetary policy has remained tight for several years, but inflation in the country remains high.
Rigid PREP works, but it cannot eliminate all the causes of inflation, investment adviser Yulia Kuznetsova said in an interview with Izvestia. The key interest rate primarily affects demand, and a significant part of the inflationary pressure in recent years has been formed due to other factors.
— The Russian economy is simultaneously faced with several supply constraints: a shortage of personnel, a restructuring of logistics, rising costs, a shortage of production facilities and a change in the structure of imports. In the summer of 2026, the fuel factor was added. The rate increase affects such reasons only indirectly," the expert emphasized.
The effect of the rigid PREP turned out to be insufficient to quickly return inflation to the target, confirmed Anna Fedyunina, Associate Professor at the Faculty of Economics at the National Research University Higher School of Economics. The same low unemployment with a high shortage of personnel limits the ability of enterprises to rapidly increase output in response to demand and at the same time supports the growth of wages and costs.
In a conversation with Izvestia, the Bank of Russia itself stressed that tight monetary policy had nevertheless produced a result — by the end of 2025, inflation had dropped to its lowest level in the last five years, amounting to 5.6%. Under the influence of one-time factors, it has increased somewhat. Since July, the indirect and secondary effects of the fuel situation have shifted steady inflation to the range of 5-6%.
But as supply in the fuel market normalizes, steady price increases will decrease again, the Central Bank said. Annual inflation at the end of the year, according to the regulator's forecast, will be 6-7%, taking into account the impact of all events that have occurred this year, including the planned indexation of housing and communal services tariffs from October 1. And the current monetary policy will reduce price growth to 4% next year.
In standby mode
The result of increasing the "key" was largely influenced by the atypical situation with the lag of the transmission mechanism. The impact of PREP on the economy as a whole is delayed. It should take some time between the economic shock and the effect of the regulator's steps — bank rates, credit conditions and savings behavior are adjusted gradually. The duration of the reaction of the economy to the monetary policy of the state can range from several months to one and a half years.
— But today there is an additional feature. Not all the economy is financed at the market rate. There are preferential lending programs that are much less responsive to changes in the key interest rate. Some large companies have their own cash flows and can continue investing for a while, even with an expensive loan. Therefore, the 14% rate does not mean that the entire economy is simultaneously facing the same cost of money," Yulia Kuznetsova pointed out.
As a result, according to her, there is a heterogeneity — small and medium-sized businesses, market mortgages, consumer loans and companies with a high debt burden are the most sensitive to the rate. And other segments continue to receive financing or maintain demand, which is why tight monetary conditions have to be maintained for longer to achieve the same disinflationary effect.
The heterogeneity of the transmission mechanism structure was also confirmed by Anna Fedyunina. PREP significantly cools individual components of demand, but reduces aggregate inflationary pressure much more slowly.
The Central Bank itself also says that the cycle of tightening the PREP, which began in July 2023, is taking place in conditions radically different from previous episodes of key rate increases. According to the regulator, the current geopolitical and macroeconomic conditions in which monetary policy has to be shaped are unprecedented.
At the same time, the Central Bank argues that the decrease in the importance of some transmission channels and the large delays in transferring the regulator's rate decisions do not mean that a tight monetary policy is unable to bring inflation to the target. The Bank of Russia is convinced that inflationary processes in the economy will eventually be able to slow down, but this will require a longer period of maintaining harsh conditions.
Demand does not generate supply
One of the key effects was the structural adjustment of demand. During the transition to a tight monetary policy, it fell on sectors affected by sanctions and requiring emergency import substitution, but now it is increasingly shifting to industries where there is a shortage of supply. According to Yulia Kuznetsova, it turned out to be unable to rebuild at the same rate as demand. A company cannot quickly increase output if it lacks workers, equipment, or production facilities.
— It starts competing for employees by increasing salaries, purchasing more expensive equipment, and changing logistics. The costs are rising and are partially transferred to the final prices," the expert explained. And the resulting inflation cannot be eliminated by a single rate increase.
The Central Bank also acknowledged the impact of changes in the structure of demand on prices in a conversation with Izvestia. However, they stressed that imbalances in individual markets are a temporary phenomenon. In order to assess inflation, according to the regulator, it is more important to look at how general demand (consumer, investment, government, and external) is growing and how it balances with the expansion of the economy's production capabilities.
— The Bank of Russia's monetary policy affects the growth rate of overall demand. And if some of it is growing faster, then the other should grow more slowly so that overall inflation is low," the Central Bank noted.
Ruble deposit
The situation with the ruble exchange rate also plays a role. Recently, there has been a tendency for the national currency to weaken. And this, as Yulia Kuznetsova pointed out, is a pro-inflationary factor — imported goods, components and equipment are becoming more expensive.
However, the transfer of the exchange rate to consumer prices does not occur simultaneously, as companies may sell old stocks or reduce margins for some time. And the share of the imported component varies significantly by product category. The impact of the weakening of the ruble on domestic prices has generally become more heterogeneous due to changes in the structure of imports, supply chains and the currency of payments, Anna Fedyunina added.
In general, the impact of the exchange rate on inflation is moderate, the Central Bank stressed. A 1% weakening of the ruble accelerates inflation by no more than 0.1 percentage points, and such temporary fluctuations do not have a noticeable effect on the dynamics of overall inflation.
— This year's exchange rate fluctuations were related both to the impact of the conflict in the Middle East and to the depletion of refining capacity, which required more imports. However, since last spring, the exchange rate has remained in a wide but stable range of 75-85 rubles," the regulator drew attention, noting that this value is close to what companies included in their business plans and pricing policies at the beginning of the year, so the scale of the transfer of exchange rate dynamics to prices will be limited.
Measure it out seven times
Taking into account all these conditions, it is impossible to exclude the possibility of raising the key rate in the near future, Yulia Kuznetsova admitted. But it is premature to say that the Bank of Russia is already preparing for a new cycle of tightening the PREP.
— The regulator will look primarily at stable inflation, inflation expectations, lending, budget parameters and the secondary effects of price increases. If sustained inflationary pressure continues to grow, lending turns out to be too active, the budget impulse will be stronger than expected, and the weakening of the ruble will begin to transfer more noticeably into prices, the likelihood of a tightening of the PREP will increase, the expert admitted.
In turn, Anna Fedyunina recalled that the Bank of Russia had not given a signal about the direction of future changes. At the same time, the regulator's management has repeatedly stressed that it is aware of the risks of too rigid PREP. Therefore, according to the economist, one should be moderately optimistic about the new decision of the Central Bank.
— The base scenario of the Central Bank still assumes a gradual reduction in the rate to a neutral range on the horizon of 2027. The price of keeping rates at 14% for a long time can be high, and everyone understands this," the expert said.
The Central Bank itself did not tell Izvestia about the likelihood of a transition to a new cycle of raising the "key", but recalled that, according to the baseline forecast, the average annual key rate would be 10.5–12.5%.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»