Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

What are the true reasons for the conflict between Zelensky and Klitschko? Analysis

Klitschko blamed the Ukrainian government for the problems of Kiev's air defense systems
0
Photo: REUTERS/Yves Herman
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

A conflict that has been going on for more than seven years has escalated between President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky and Mayor of Kiev Vitali Klitschko. They blamed each other for the failure to prepare the capital for winter amid the intensifying energy crisis. Zelensky made it clear that he intends to seek Klitschko's removal from the post of mayor. The confrontation threatens to turn into a new political crisis. What you need to know about what is happening is in the Izvestia article.

How the conflict escalated

• After a series of upheavals that have occurred with Ukrainian politics in recent months, the central conflict has become the confrontation between the country's President, Vladimir Zelensky, and the mayor of Kiev, Vitali Klitschko. In October, there is an increasing exchange of accusations between them, which both, despite long-standing contradictions, had previously avoided.

• The formal reason for the intensification of the confrontation was the preparation for the heating season in the capital of Ukraine. Since the beginning of autumn, massive emergency power outages and water supply disruptions have been taking place in Kiev due to the destruction of energy infrastructure. Zelensky accused the Moscow authorities of "almost completely failing to meet the deadlines of the resilience plan" — the sustainability strategy adopted in 2024 in the realities of the current conflict with Russia. The plan specifies specific steps to ensure the viability of cities, such as the development of distributed generation, increasing the autonomy of residential buildings, protecting critical infrastructure and creating a fuel reserve. Zelensky later said that the "resilience plans" in Kiev were being implemented worse than even in the frontline regions.

• In response, Klitschko rejected the allegations about the disruption of the heating season and accused the president of trying to weaken local government by shifting the conflict from a technical plane to a political one. Zelensky's Servant of the People party invited the mayor of Kiev to make a report to the Verkhovna Rada, and he used this opportunity to criticize the government more loudly. He asked the audience about the work of air defense and the protection of Ukrenergo facilities, and also accused the central government of "frozen payments" and the withdrawal of 8 billion hryvnias from the budget of Kiev. At the same time, the Association of Ukrainian Cities, headed by Klitschko, complained about restrictions on budget payments imposed by the government.

Zelensky also defiantly held consultations about the critical situation in Kiev with representatives of the security services, business and local government, while the mayor of the city was not invited to the meeting. Although it was stated that the president discussed the protection of energy facilities and critical infrastructure in the capital, this event clearly signaled Zelensky's dissatisfaction with the current leadership of Kiev and his intention to replace it.

Why the conflict has been going on for years

• The confrontation between Klitschko and Zelensky has become noticeable since 2019, when the latter won the presidential election. According to some reports, by that time they already had a personal conflict, but it turned into a political one due to the duality of power in the capital, which is both purely local and embedded in the central vertical.

• Klitschko has been the mayor of Kiev since 2014 and at the same time the head of the Kiev City State Administration (KSCA). The first position is elective, and the second is appointed by the President of Ukraine, but this mechanism is only a formality. Because of this, the head of state has limited influence on the head of the city, but at the same time he has the right to appoint the heads of the districts of Kiev. For Zelensky and Klitschko, such uncertainty about the division of powers has become a reason for disputes that escalate at critical moments for the capital.

• In 2022, the conflict escalated again. Zelensky has created the Kiev City Military Administration (CCHA), which should be responsible for defense and security in the city. Its head reports directly to the president, and Timur Tkachenko currently holds this position. Although the CGA did not receive significant powers to govern the city, this intensified the political conflict between the local government and the central government. Since then, Kiev has become a zone of constant legal and political bargaining between Klitschko and Zelensky.

What are the goals of the parties

Zelensky uses accusations against Klitschko to create an excuse for his removal and establish full control over the city administration. For this purpose, the most painful reason for the residents of the capital was chosen — the energy crisis on the eve of winter. At any other time, the president's claims against the mayor would not have sounded as relevant as they do now, when the authorities need to literally save the city from the consequences of the strikes.

• Kiev is an extremely important asset for Zelensky for a number of reasons. Firstly, it is the city from which protest activity in Ukraine begins, which can lead to a change of government. Historically, its residents are politically charged and less loyal to the central authorities than is the case in the regions. Secondly, Kiev remains the financial and economic center of the country, with the largest budget among not only cities, but also individual regions. Currently, the office of the President does not have full control over the funds that Kiev has.

• Klitschko positions himself as a defender of local self-government, who has his own electoral legitimacy and this differs from those whom Zelensky appoints directly. At the same time, he emphasizes that Kiev's defense issues should remain within the competence of the central authorities, namely, due to insufficient protection, the current energy crisis is taking place. It is important for Klitschko to demonstrate that it is not the miscalculations of the city administration that lead to the problems of the capital, but the oversight of the president's office.

• Klitschko's political ambitions play an important role in the conflict. Although he does not disclose his own plans, in a situation where several politicians are already directly talking about the need to change the head of state, the mayor of the capital cannot but apply for a promotion. Klitschko presents himself as Zelensky's main opponent and is thus trying to build up political capital that he can use in future elections.

What is the threat of conflict

• The main practical threat of the conflict between the president and the mayor is the lack of normal interaction between the center and the city at a time when Kiev is in danger. Decisions on protecting energy infrastructure, building shelters, and providing backup power may be delayed or blocked due to mutual claims.

• In political terms, the dispute between Zelensky and Klitschko threatens a broader domestic political crisis if local elites, who have accumulated grievances against the central government, are involved in it. Attempts to weaken self-government may result in the consolidation of the municipal opposition and the emergence of a new point of tension that will put pressure on Zelensky. The challenge to local self-government may turn out to be as serious a test for the authorities as the fight against independent anti-corruption bodies and the dismissal of Defense Minister Mikhail Fedorov.

• The hints of corruption used by both sides threaten to undermine the already fragile trust of Western partners. Ukraine's position on the world stage is currently extremely unstable, and a new political crisis will only lead to further reputational losses. If the president's office decides to increase pressure on the Kiev authorities through law enforcement agencies, and such a scenario is not excluded, it will also lead to a serious revision of Ukraine's relations with the West.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast