The triumphant Middle Ages: the number of underage marriages is growing in Germany
Germany is faced with the problem of child marriage. There is a huge and growing migrant community in the country. Many of these people came to Germany from countries where underage marriages are quite acceptable, and now they embody this, as they claim, "ancient beautiful custom" in their new homeland. The German authorities are showing their impotence in the fight against this medieval tradition. Officials fear that with the hypertrophied political correctness being imposed in the country, the dissolution of such a marriage may be perceived as interference with "cultural traditions." Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
The problem is close at hand
Child marriage is a global problem. UNICEF estimates that 15 million girls worldwide marry before they reach the age of 18 every year. In the mass consciousness, this problem is usually associated with countries that are called backward, belonging to the "third world". But only a few could have guessed that the marriage of a minor is a completely common thing for the Federal Republic of Germany, a state that is considered to be among the "developed" and "civilized".
Not so long ago, information appeared that 358 child marriages have been officially registered in the German federal state of Baden-Württemberg since 2012. However, only eight of them were legally annulled. The remaining 350 cases, as the documents casually state, were closed "by other means," that is, without a court decision to annul the marriage. Among the documented cases were the "marriages" of 11- and 12-year-old girls. This information is contained in the response of the Government of Baden-Wuerttemberg to a request from deputies of the local parliament from the opposition Alternative for Germany party Nikolaos Butakoglou and Emeli Knorr.
The reason for this request was the publication in the summer of 2026 of instructions for teachers prepared by the human rights organization Terre des Femmes. This instruction is intended for cases when schoolgirls are going to be taken abroad for forced marriage. Human rights activists strongly recommend that teachers identify children at risk. The signs of this are clear — for example, a girl is under the control of relatives who forbid her to participate in school activities; her siblings were forced to marry at a minor age; her parents come from countries with strict patriarchal family structures. An immediate alarm call is when the girl (or young man) herself informs that she will have to leave school after the holidays or that a festive celebration is being prepared for her in her parents' country.
If a student has asked for help, the teacher is advised to contact a specialized counseling center with her and connect the youth affairs authorities to the situation, which can decide on removal from the family. Since many teenagers are wary of the guardianship authorities, the document recommends conducting an explanatory conversation with them. If, despite the threat, the child still leaves, he is advised to take with him copies of his passport, return ticket, cash, phone number and addresses of the German embassies, and leave the second copies to a trusted person in Germany. Before leaving, the child must provide the trusted person with the exact address of the destination and a notarized statement stating that he fears forced marriage in his homeland and definitely wants to return to Germany. If the student has not shown up at school after the holidays, the teacher is instructed to notify the authorities who may try to help return the victim to Germany.
Nikolaos Butakoglou and Emeli Knorr found out for themselves and informed the public about some of the egregious cases. One of them was the marriage of an 11-year-old Iraqi girl to a 17-year-old Iraqi boy. This marriage was annulled by the German authorities in 2020. But despite the fact that it was terminated, the very fact of its official registration in Germany raises serious questions about the control system. Earlier, in 2018, the marriage of a 14-year-old Afghan woman with a 30-year-old man was annulled. In 2024, the marriages of a 16-year-old German citizen with a 25-year-old Pakistani man and a 16-year-old Syrian woman with a 27-year-old compatriot were annulled. As for the 350 cases of minor marriages that have never been officially annulled, they often also involve very young girls. So, in 2020, the union of a 12-year-old Afghan woman with an 18-year-old man was formed. Two years later, the marriage of a 12-year-old Syrian woman with a 28-year-old compatriot was somehow registered. In 2023, a 12-year-old Afghan woman married a 21-year-old native of this country. The documents also contain information about numerous cases of this kind involving 13- and 14-year-old girls.
They brought their own customs with them
Butakoglou and Knorr put the question bluntly: So why haven't these 350 marriages been officially annulled? The Government of Baden-Wuerttemberg cited several reasons in its defense. This turned out to be either the early death of one of the spouses, or the coming of age — by the time the case was considered, the bride had already become an adult, and there was no need for an annulment. Indeed, from the point of view of the law, a girl, having reached adulthood, becomes independent and is not obliged to live in an imposed marriage. These explanations have raised serious doubts. Reaching the age of 18 does not negate the fact that the marriage was concluded with a minor and, therefore, is invalid under German law.
Without an official revocation, victims do not receive official recognition of their status, do not gain access to protective mechanisms, and the perpetrators are not responsible. In addition, many are unable to take advantage of the opportunity that coming of age gives them. After all, in order to free oneself from an imposed marriage, one must openly protest at the age of 18, which many, having become psychologically dependent on their enslavers, do not do and continue to live as before. The authorities often interpret the very absence of active resistance as "confirmation" and dismiss the issue, even if the victim had no real freedom of choice.
Meanwhile, formally such marriages have no legal force from the very beginning. The law on combating child marriage has been in force in Germany since July 22, 2017. He set an age limit: marriage is allowed only from the age of 18, without any exceptions. But despite the existence of the law, its implementation leaves much to be desired. Officials justify themselves by saying that almost all registered child marriages were performed outside Germany, most often in the countries of origin of the families. The German authorities only find out about them when the family arrives in Germany and applies for social benefits or registration. The Government of Baden-Württemberg said it had no information about which countries these marriages were performed in. The Ministry of Education also does not collect data on school attendance by children in such marriages, which makes it difficult to identify and protect victims.
In addition to child marriages, there is the problem of forced marriages. These two problems are closely interrelated. The state advisory service YASEMIN, funded from the budget of the state of Baden-Wuerttemberg, registered 271 requests for help from girls, girls and women from migrant families in 2025. They complained of violence, family conflicts, genital mutilation, and in 80 cases, the threat of forced marriage. Among those who were threatened with forced marriage were 33 underage girls, four children under the age of 12, five children aged 12 and two 13-year-old children. These figures show that the problem is not limited to marriages that have already been concluded in other countries, but also includes active attempts to force minors to marry, which are already taking place on the territory of Germany itself.
The citizens of Ukraine also registered
MP Nikolaos Butakoglou, who submitted the request, which resulted in the publication of such inconvenient information for the state, called the revealed data shocking. According to him, the topic is "really terrible," but it is "taboo." His party colleague Emeli Knorr called for more effective protection of minors. "Child marriage is incompatible with our values. Children have the right to safety, to education, and to determine their own future. That is why we need effective protection, early intervention, and decisive action against forced marriage," Knorr emphasizes. A discussion ensued: so why are the German authorities unwilling to actively combat such a shameful phenomenon?
Experts cite the unwillingness of German state institutions to come into conflict with migrant communities as one of the main reasons why the German authorities turn a blind eye to child marriage. After all, child marriages are often formally, as officials console their conscience, part of the "cultural and religious traditions" in the countries of origin of these migrants. Therefore, direct government intervention can be perceived as "discrimination." So it turns out that the victims do not receive official recognition of their status, the forced nature of the marriage is not investigated, and the perpetrators are not responsible.
You need to understand that the Baden-Wuerttemberg data is just the tip of the iceberg. In 2017, when the law on combating child marriage was being passed, the Ministry of Justice reported that in the previous year alone, the German authorities had registered almost 500 foreign teenagers under the age of 16 as already married. Moreover, this number did not include 16-17-year-olds, as well as those who did not file a complaint with the authorities. At the moment, fresh and complete data is not available throughout Germany, as the federal government officially declares that it does not keep centralized records of child marriages. There is simply no single national statistic that would summarize data from all federal states.
Some very approximate conclusions can be drawn based on data from the Central Register of Foreigners (AZR), which registers foreign citizens residing in Germany. By the end of 2024, 279 minor foreigners with the status of "married" were registered in the country. Remarkably, 124 of them had Ukrainian citizenship. However, the AZR data suffers from critical incompleteness, because its statistics include only people aged 16 and 17, and only foreign citizens are counted. German citizens who are in a child marriage are not included in these statistics. Again, these figures reflect only those cases that have become known to the authorities. The actual number may be much higher, since, as mentioned above, many child marriages are performed abroad and are not registered in Germany. This confirms the conclusions of the Alternative for Germany deputies about the "scandalous inactivity" of the federal government and its lack of a reliable picture of the real scale of the problem.
Natalia Eremina, Doctor of Political Sciences, Professor at St. Petersburg State University, noted in a conversation with Izvestia that Germany, which is trying to present itself as an "advanced democracy," is, in fact, gradually slipping into the real Middle Ages. "The data from Baden-Wuerttemberg paints an alarming picture for the German state. 358 child marriages since 2012, 350 cases of which have been closed without a court decision, is evidence of a systemic failure to protect children, the most vulnerable members of society. The 2017 law formally banned child marriage, but its implementation mechanisms proved ineffective. Bureaucratic inertia, fear of accusations of discrimination, and a lack of data on the real scale of the problem allow thousands of cases to remain in the shadows. AFD politicians have uncovered a problem that the German authorities preferred to keep quiet about. And now the question is whether Germany is ready to protect children regardless of their origin," Eremina emphasizes. She recalls that demographic growth in Germany is ensured by migration, which means that the Middle Ages in the country will become more noticeable.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»