Brainwash: how the assessment of the quality of education in Russia will change
In Russia, a new edition of the decree of the Government of the Russian Federation on the list of measures to assess the quality of education in schools and the rules for their implementation is being prepared. The participants of the All-Russian verification work will be more clearly identified, and it will also be possible to count the VPR as a certification. Read more about how the quality of education is assessed in the country now and what will change in the near future in the Izvestia article.
When will the VPR be conducted in schools?
Last week, Rosobrnadzor held a meeting with schools and vocational education organizations, where they discussed the organization of an assessment of the quality of education in the new academic year. The head of the department, Anzor Muzayev, stressed that the service considers verification work to be a fundamentally important part of this process. He recalled that in the USSR and Russia there had already been experiments with the abolition of tests and exams, which "led to the degradation of the education system."
The dates of the verification work were also announced. VPR has already started in PDF organizations. They will be held in schools for students in grades 4-8 and 10 from April 19 to May 21, 2027. And in October, national comparative studies will be held, during which educational work in schools, as well as functional and financial literacy of students, will be evaluated. Moreover, the "educational potential" will be tested so far in 29 regions, the rest will be affected in 2027-2028.
In November, a study of the subject, methodological and general pedagogical competencies of primary school teachers, teachers of the Russian language, mathematics, physics, chemistry and biology will be conducted.
At the meeting, Rosobrnadzor recalled that a new version of the decree of the Government of the Russian Federation is being prepared, which establishes a list of measures to assess the quality of education and the rules for their implementation.
How will the education quality assessment system change
The press service of Rosobrnadzor told Izvestia about the main changes that are included in the new government decree. In particular, the document clarifies the range of participants in the All-Russian verification work: now it is clearly stated that these are full-time students (previously they were simply "students of educational organizations"). At the same time, schools and colleges have been given the right to decide for themselves whether students will write VPR on full-time and part-time forms.
The federal service noted that the implementation of the current version of the resolution showed difficulties in organizing the participation of students in these forms of education in the verification work. Difficulties also arose for those who are in family education or engaged in self-education, so it was decided to make clarifications.
In addition, the possibility of using the VPR as a form of interim assessment of students at the end of the school year has been fixed, especially since these works are carried out at the end of the second academic half of the year.
In addition, the new version of the government decree will not fix the number of academic subjects in which the VPR is conducted, their number will be approved by Rosobrnadzor by its order no later than three months before the start of the school year. This will allow at the same time to maintain the current volume of testing work and "consolidate a more flexible procedure for determining a specific list of subjects for the relevant academic year," the federal service noted.
"The purpose of the changes is to make regulation clearer and more practice—oriented, to ensure the predictability of assessment procedures for educational organizations and at the same time to preserve the ability to quickly determine their parameters within the established powers of Rosobrnadzor," the agency stressed.
What is the purpose of assessing the quality of education in the Russian Federation?
The Rosobrnadzor press service added that the quality of education is a complex characteristic that is assessed taking into account educational outcomes and the conditions in which education is provided. For example, the vlookups, which are a key element of this assessment, provide information about how the curriculum has been mastered in schools and show educational deficits. They can be used to analyze results for individual subjects and classes and compare data over time.
— Assessment of students' functional literacy is of particular importance: the ability to solve educational problems and life—related problematic situations," the federal service said, explaining that it is about the skills to analyze information, establish cause-and-effect relationships, work with various sources, plan activities and solve complex problems.
In general, the quality control of education involves the analysis of the results of assessment procedures, the dynamics of student achievements, the conditions for the implementation of educational programs and the effectiveness of management decisions.
Russia has a GIS "Federal Information System for assessing the quality of Education", thanks to which each school can see its results in comparison with the indicators of other educational institutions in its municipality, region and country, the director of the Federal Institute for Educational Quality Assessment (FIOKO) added in a comment to Izvestia Vladimir Starichkov. The analysis can be carried out down to the dynamics of achievements of each specific class.
However, the main purpose of evaluating students' results is not the dynamics, but still the achievement of the required level, fixed by the requirements of the federal state educational standard, the expert emphasized. At the same time, absolute indicators and their dynamics complement each other in assessing the quality of education.
—This approach allows us to determine how effectively the educational process is organized and what measures are needed to further improve the quality of education," explained Vladimir Starichkov.
Principal FIOKO stated that all schools are evaluated according to the same rules, regardless of the student body and other conditions. But the analysis of the results of this assessment, of course, involves consideration of the conditions in which the training takes place.
— This is especially important when identifying schools that require additional methodological, personnel or managerial support, — said the source. — Therefore, it is important to distinguish between two issues: whether students have achieved the necessary educational results and how effectively the school ensures their achievement in specific conditions. To answer the first question, objective measurements of the results are necessary, for the second, a broader analysis that takes into account the initial conditions and educational dynamics.
According to Rosobrnadzor, it is necessary to take into account the characteristics of the student body, staffing, availability of educational resources, socio-economic conditions of the territory, dynamics of results and other factors affecting the educational process. At the same time, the results of the verification activities should be considered as an important source of objective data, but not as a universal school rating.
"Their purpose is to help identify strengths and problems, identify necessary support measures and create conditions for improving the quality of education," the federal service explained.
And Vladimir Starichkov spoke separately about how the level of educational work in schools is assessed: for this purpose, students are surveyed, which allows them to analyze the climate in the educational institution, the relationship between students, the level of formation of value orientations, as well as a sense of security and psychological comfort.
How else can schools be evaluated
When assessing, which, as noted in Rosobrnadzor, affects managerial decision-making, it would also be worthwhile to take into account the role of the school for the local community, said Sergey Kosaretsky, vice-rector for Research at Moscow State Psychological and Pedagogical University. Sometimes continuing education becomes a condition for the preservation and development of the territory and lifestyle of a particular culture. This is, for example, the case of the indigenous small-numbered peoples of Russia.
As Boris Ilyukhin, a senior researcher at the Center for Economics of Continuing Education at the Presidential Academy, added, schools in the country are very different: if for one the quality criterion is the proportion of graduates who have enrolled in budget places at leading universities, then for the other it is the proportion of students who have received a certificate.
— Unfortunately, the assessment of schools in the context of clusters (comparison of similar with similar — Ed.) has not yet been adequately developed in domestic tools for assessing the quality of education. But it should be noted that the assessment tools themselves are constantly being improved at the federal level. On the one hand, they are becoming more diverse: new studies are emerging, for example, studying the readiness of schoolchildren to learn, assessing mathematical and natural science literacy, and others. On the other hand, existing tools are being improved, including military—technical cooperation," the expert explained.
According to Sergey Kosaretsky, the safety of the school environment, the school climate, and the well-being of students and teachers, including the absence of bullying, are becoming increasingly important when evaluating an educational organization. At the same time, different groups have different requirements for the quality of education: parents, for example, now have a strong demand for individualization of education.
— We must not forget the feeling of satisfaction of the students themselves, the joy or boredom of learning — especially now, when everyone is concerned about the decrease in motivation and interests of students. Combining all the indicators into a single index is an understandable desire, but it is difficult to implement," the Izvestia interlocutor emphasized.
The search for objective criteria that take into account the changing expectations of families, society, and the development of the labor market is underway all over the world. And there are very different approaches to evaluation.
— UNESCO suggests considering happiness as the main goal and basis of quality education. In the latest Pisa study, the OECD paid special attention to measuring perseverance: whether students continue to work until it is completed, and whether they make additional efforts when the work becomes difficult," explained Sergey Kosaretsky.
Why the assessment may not be objective
As practice shows, the most important thing for officials and school administrators is to have good performance on the VPR, said Dmitry Kazakov, chairman of the Teacher trade union. In addition, calmness in the information field is important: there should be no public conflicts with either parents or students. If no problems are fixed, this is considered a good result.
At the same time, there may be problems with the objectivity of such assessments. It is understood that the vlookup does not require additional training: the student must write it fluently. However, in reality, schools prepare students specifically for test work, the source told the editorial board.
— Because if the school does not write the VPR well, there will be not very good indicators, they may come with an inspection and so on. All of this happens regularly. Vlookup is a serious test for a school, which by the end of the year stops the entire normal educational and educational process in order for these vlookups to be written," he pointed out the problem.
At the same time, children who achieve high learning outcomes often do not write test papers well, because they need to "get" into the format. Dmitry Kazakov admitted that it is impossible not to measure the quality of education, but sometimes it affects the very quality of education.
In turn, Sergey Kosaretsky noted that the VPR and other assessment systems potentially have a positive impact when, based on the results of the audit, schools and teachers are given feedback that allows them to make changes to teaching, identify groups of students in need of targeted support, offer teachers professional development programs, etc.
— If the assessment does not have such consequences, then the objective burden that falls on schools and teachers, causes stress to students, becomes unjustified, — he stressed. — In addition, the use of evaluation results for pressure, rather than for development, encourages manipulation during verification work. But Rosobrnadzor also understands these risks, and it has long sought to use a "motivating monitoring" approach.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»