My soulmate: the mass distribution of benefits to foreigners causes outrage in Germany
New data from the German Federal Labor Agency has caused a storm of indignation in German society. Of the €23.2 billion taken out of the pocket of the German taxpayer and spent on unemployment benefits in the first half of 2026, €10.6 billion (46%) went to recipients without German citizenship. Their share in the country's population is only about 15%. This disparity, which has also more than tripled recently, has become not just a statistical fact, but a political detonator. Against the background of a record drop in the rating of the ruling coalition and the historic rise of the right-wing Alternative for Germany, the question of who receives social benefits and why has become one of the central topics of German politics. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
The numbers that shocked Germany
Recently, the German press received fresh statistics from the Federal Labor Agency regarding the payment of basic unemployment benefits (Bürgergeld). In the first six months of 2026, the total amount amounted to € 23.2 billion. Of this amount, recipients with a German passport accounted for €12.6 billion, while foreign citizens accounted for €10.6 billion, which corresponds to about 46% of all registered payments. This means that almost every second euro paid by employment centers has gone to people without German citizenship. However, compared to previous periods, the total government spending on unemployment benefits has decreased slightly. In the first half of 2025, they amounted to about € 23.5 billion, and in the first half of 2024, they amounted to almost €23.6 billion. Thus, the current €23.2 billion is a decrease of 325 million euros (1.4%) compared to last year.
The structural disparity also fell slightly: while payments to foreign recipients decreased by 4.2% over the year, payments to German citizens, on the contrary, increased by 1.2%. This means that the share of foreigners in the total benefits pie is gradually decreasing, but still remains disproportionately high. This year, the share of foreigners who received benefits was distributed as follows: Ukrainians — € 2.9 billion (-4.4% compared to the first half of 2025), Syrians — € 1.75 billion (-14.5%), Afghans — € 860 million (+ 3.2%), Somalis — € 106 million (+8.1%), immigrants from the Western Balkans — € 501 million. Thus, Ukrainians turned out to be the largest group of foreign recipients of Bürgergeld. As of June 2026, 633,807 Ukrainian citizens received benefits, of which 469,534 were considered able-bodied.
It is important to note that in 2022 Berlin provided Ukrainians with immediate access to benefits — faster than for most other refugee groups. The second largest group turned out to be Syrians: about 936 thousand people who first receive benefits for asylum seekers, and after approval of the application they switch to full social security. To understand the scale of the current disparity, it is necessary to compare the above figures with the demographic statistics of Germany. According to the Federal Statistical Office, at the end of 2025, about 12.4 million foreigners lived in Germany, accounting for 14.9% of the population. Thus, the share of foreigners in payments to Burgergeld is more than three times higher than their share in the population.
The NGO Bertelsmann Stiftung, which is engaged in analytical work, has published the coefficient of receiving social assistance — the proportion of people in each group who depend on basic security. Of these, German citizens accounted for 5.2%, citizens of most other EU countries living in Germany — 8.8%, Bulgarian citizens — 25.6%, Ukrainians — 52.1%, Syrians — 47.5%, Afghans — 45.7%. Based on these figures, Bertelsmann Stiftung made a neutral conclusion that the problem lies in the "structural dependence of certain groups on the social system." Such information further inflamed the mood of German society, which has long been signaling its discontent. A survey conducted in February 2026 by the Forsa sociological agency commissioned by Stern magazine showed that 64% of Germans believe that the current social support system (with all its benefits, pensions, and insurance) is too expensive for the country and will not last long in this form. "Simply put, people understand that there is not enough money for all this. The state spends more on social benefits than it collects taxes and contributions. And if nothing changes, either taxes will have to be raised, benefits will have to be cut, or debts will have to go deeper. This does not mean that Germans want to completely abandon social protection. They want the system to become sustainable, that is, for expenses to match income. But that's exactly the problem: now, according to the majority, there is no balance," political analyst Maxim Reva explains to Izvestia.
Solve the issue radically
It is noteworthy that the majority of those who do not believe in the future of the German social security system are supporters of the opposition Alternative for Germany party. However, many of them are also voters of the Social Democratic Party of Germany and the CDU/CSU. In a survey conducted in April 2026 for the public broadcaster WDR, 66% of respondents said that migrants should receive full social benefits only after a long period of work in Germany. Currently, access to benefits is determined by a combination of factors: citizenship, legal status (refugee, asylum seeker, EU citizen) and the availability of a residence and work permit. For EU citizens, the status of an employee is critically important, for Ukrainian refugees — the date of entry (those who entered after April 1, 2025, are paid not €563, as their predecessors, but only €455 per month), and for citizens of third countries — the type of residence permit.
The release of recent statistics on benefit payments has led to heated debates in the Bundestag. Labor Minister Berbel Bas (SPD), who stated that, they say, "no one is immigrating to our social systems," was harshly criticized. AFD MP Rene Springer asked her a direct question: why is the government not actually saving on "immigration into social systems"? Later, Bas herself admitted that her statement was "unfortunate." I must say that Alternative for Germany is actively using these statistics to advance its agenda. The faction's statement of February 10, 2026 says: "Two thirds of Germans have realized what the old parties stubbornly deny: the welfare state as we know it today is no longer funded. More and more people are not paying anything, but they are receiving benefits — the system is out of balance."
The AfD has put forward a specific requirement: exclusion of foreigners from third countries from the benefits system until they have worked in Germany for at least 10 years with mandatory social contributions. It is proposed to set this period for citizens of EU countries for at least five years. The right-wingers believe that those recipients who have been on benefits for more than six months should be sent to socially useful work. The party also insists on repealing the so-called integration law, according to which migrants are provided with compulsory German language courses and various related benefits at the expense of the state. The main argument of the AfD in favor of repealing the law is the high cost of integration courses. From 2021 to 2025, they cost German taxpayers €4.6 billion, with costs rising annually from €474.9 million in 2021 to €1.33 billion in 2025. According to the party, integration should be the personal responsibility of migrants themselves, and not the responsibility of the state.
AFD Parliamentary State Secretary Rene Springer said: "Anyone who comes to Germany and has not yet paid a cent into our system should not receive the same social benefits from day one as people who have worked for years and funded the welfare state." But these radical proposals have met with opposition from the systemic parties. They engaged experts from the NGO Hans Beckler Foundation, which is close to the trade unions, who claim that there is allegedly no evidence that migration to Germany is motivated primarily by social benefits. This controversial statement, to say the least, provoked criticism from the opposition. They note that even the existing picture of the disparity in benefits payments does not reflect the true state of affairs. After all, if a recipient of benefits receives German citizenship during the payment period, he automatically passes into the category of "German recipients", which distorts the picture in dynamics. By the way, there are 21.8 million people in Germany with a "migration history" (including naturalized citizens and their descendants) (26.3% of the population).
Amid these debates, the AfD has reached unprecedented heights in the opinion polls. According to the INSA sociological agency, in October 2026, for the first time, the party reached 30% of support at the federal level. A little later, the same institute recorded 30.5%. For comparison, the rating of the ruling CDU/CSU bloc, led by Chancellor Friedrich Merz, fell to 17.5–18%, that is, to a historic low. The Social Democrats and the Greens have 14% each, while the Left—wing Party has 10%. The Sarah Wagenknecht Union and the Free Democratic Party do not even overcome the five percent barrier. The results of the land elections have become a particularly alarming signal for the ruling coalition. In Saxony-Anhalt, the AFD received 43.8% of the vote, an absolute record for this party. In Mecklenburg–Vorpommern — 38.3%. Moreover, in Thuringia, the AfD candidate won the post of president of the Landtag for the first time.
The issue of justice
As Maxim Reva notes, the increase in the AfG rating is the accumulated effect of several factors. "The migration crisis and the government's inability to control it, economic stagnation and rising living costs, growing inequality in access to social benefits, and a sense of injustice — 'we pay, and they receive.' Benefit statistics have become a symbol of this injustice — concrete, measurable proof that the system is not working as it should. Since the systemic parties have confessed their inability to solve these problems, the German layman is increasingly pinning his hopes on an "Alternative for Germany," the political scientist notes.
Back in November 2025, Chancellor Friedrich Merz called the employment rate among Ukrainians who settled in Germany (34%) unacceptably low and announced an adjustment to the system. As part of this adjustment, benefits for newly arriving Ukrainians were reduced to the level of ordinary asylum seekers — about €441 (after indexing in 2026 - €455) per month instead of the previous €563. In addition, starting in July 2026, a new "basic support" system (Grundsicherungsgeld) began operating in Germany instead of the previous system of benefits (Bürgergeld). The new system turned out to be much stricter, shifting the focus from support to coercion to work.
The key change is the priority of rapid employment. Previously, long-term qualification courses and retraining were allowed within the framework of the Bürgergeld, but now the Grundsicherungsgeld requires first to check the possibility of immediate integration of a person into the labor market. The use of educational measures is considered only if it is considered impossible. Fines have become uniform and more severe: now, for any violation (refusal to work, absenteeism), the allowance is immediately cut by 30% for three months. Missing appointments at job centers three times in a row without a valid reason is a complete loss of benefits, including housing costs. If a person deliberately refuses a specific job offer, they may lose the entire benefit the first time (while still paying for housing).
However, many consider these measures insufficient. Now, even within the ruling coalition, the number of supporters of further restrictions is growing. Johannes Winkel, deputy chairman of the CDU/CSU faction in the Bundestag, has publicly stated the "problem of justice": those who have never paid into the German social system should receive less. However, it is still unclear how far the government is willing to go. The radical proposals of the AFD go far beyond what the ruling coalition is ready to accept. But the pressure of public opinion may force the CDU/CSU to make more serious concessions.
Maxim Reva says that Germany is facing an existential question: How can we maintain a welfare state in the face of mass immigration and economic stagnation? "These statistics have become a mirror in which German society has seen the injustice that it is no longer ready to tolerate. 46% of benefits for foreigners, compared with 15% of their share in the population, is an imbalance that undermines the legitimacy of the entire system. The Merz government is trying to maneuver: on the one hand, somewhat tightening the rules for newly arrived migrants, on the other hand, preserving the basic principles of the previous system. But the pace of change may not be sufficient. Meanwhile, the AfD is gaining strength in the wake of this discontent. Her growing rating is a signal that a significant part of German society considers the current state of affairs unfair and requires radical changes. The question of who is entitled to social protection and under what conditions has become a central issue of domestic German politics. The political stability of Germany for years to come depends on the answer to it. So far, one thing is clear: the German model of the welfare state is experiencing the most serious crisis of trust in its entire history," the expert concludes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»