The expert called the risks of total control of employees through automation
Automation should help companies identify problems in their work processes, rather than becoming a system of constant employee monitoring. Alexander Klimeshov, director of the Center for Industry Expertise at LANSOFT IT holding, told Izvestia on October 27 about why the number of clicks, messages and time in programs does not always reflect productivity.
According to the expert, automation can be aimed directly at the workflow or at monitoring the actions of an employee. In the first case, the system helps to find delays, queues, errors and unnecessary operations. In the second case, it tracks a person's digital activity, but such indicators cannot always be directly linked to the result of the work.
A significant part of his professional activity is related to information analysis, finding solutions, communicating with colleagues and preparing for negotiations. It is difficult to assess such processes using the number of actions in the program or the time spent at the computer.
Why Digital Activity Doesn't Equal Productivity
This is especially evident in intellectual work. According to Klimeshov, a good developer can spend no more than a third of his working time writing code directly. The rest is spent on analysis, problem discussion, and finding solutions.
"At the same time, high activity in the information system may be associated not with high performance, but with the complexity of the interface, excessive reporting, or the need to correct the result several times," the expert explained.
Therefore, the mere fact that a certain indicator is available does not make it suitable for evaluating an employee's performance.
How metrics can change employee behavior
The indicators chosen by the company can influence how employees perform their tasks. If the main criterion is the number of closed tasks or the speed of their completion, employees begin to focus on these parameters. As a result, formal indicators may improve without a comparable increase in business results. In some cases, the desire to meet the established standard can even affect the quality of work.
Klimeshov considers the use of automated systems for process analysis to be a more useful direction. For example, if a document has been under approval for too long, the system can help identify the stage at which the delay occurs and determine its cause. This allows you to identify an unnecessary link in the route, lack of resources, uneven distribution of tasks or other organizational constraints instead of reducing the problem to the actions of a particular employee.
When control is really necessary
At the same time, a complete rejection of control, according to the expert, is not a solution. It may be required to ensure information security, compliance with mandatory requirements, deadlines, and work standards.
"It is more important to determine how well the tools used correspond to a specific task. If it is enough for a manager to know the status of the job and compliance with the deadline, collecting significantly more information about the employee's actions will not necessarily increase the effectiveness of management," Klimeshov said.
A separate risk arises when the indicators collected by the system are automatically used to evaluate employees. The algorithm sees the data available to it, but it may not take into account the complexity of the task, dependence on other departments, technical failures, and other circumstances. Therefore, the automatic rating, according to the expert, can serve as an additional source of information for the head, but should not completely replace the managerial decision.
What does effective automation look like?
According to the expert, the maturity of automation is not determined by the amount of data that a company is able to collect about each employee. It is much more important how well the system shows the status of the workflow itself.
"The maturity of automation is not reflected in how closely a company is able to monitor each person. It manifests itself in the ability to make the process transparent: to show the expected result, the current state of work and emerging limitations, that is, the information necessary for making managerial decisions," Klimeshov said.
A good system, the expert believes, allows the manager to see the progress of the work and thus reduces the need for constant monitoring. If automation only increases the amount of employee supervision, it can create the illusion of manageability instead of a real increase in efficiency.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»