Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

"The customer pays not only for the taste, but also for the quality"

Anna Voitenko, founder of the ANNACHOCOLAD brand, talks about what is happening on the chocolate market
0
Photo: Global Look Press/Oliver Berg
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The crisis in the cocoa market has been going on for several years: the harvest in West Africa is suffering from weather anomalies and tree diseases, raw material prices first soared, then rolled back a little, but did not return to their previous level. Anna Voitenko, founder of the ANNACHOCOLAD brand, told Izvestia about how this affects manufacturers of craft chocolate, what major players are doing and why Russian consumers are choosing bitter chocolate more often.

— Since 2024, there has been strong volatility in the cocoa market: first, a collapse in production and a rise in prices, then a fall in the spring of 2026, and now a new round of growth due to the threat of crop failure associated with El Nino. How have these spikes in raw material prices affected the business of large and small producers?

— If we recall the year 2023, then the preliminary forecast of El Nino usually begins in May, and manufacturers and suppliers begin to prepare for this. But yields in West Africa, weather conditions, diseases of cocoa trees, and a shortage of raw materials on the global market also affect. It started in June, then intensified and lasted until June 2024, and then moved into a neutral phase.

Let's look at the pricing policy for cocoa butter.: the cost for a box of 25 kg was 48 thousand rubles, at the time of the crop failure the price increased to 250 thousand rubles, that is, by 421%. Then the price dropped slightly to 160 thousand rubles, a 36% decrease from the peak. If we compare the original 48 thousand and the current 160 thousand, the difference is 233%.

It follows that there was a 421% jump from the original price, while the new price was 521% of the original. Then the price dropped by 36%, but did not return to its original level.

Large manufacturers most often operate with long-term contracts and large stocks of raw materials, so a sharp increase in prices does not immediately affect their products. Plus, they have inherent risks. A small producer uses private orders and has a smaller supply of raw materials, which means that the price has a dramatic effect on the product. For example, I now have a cost of 1 kg of chocolate of 48.3 thousand rubles — they began to buy less, but the quality remained at the same level.

— According to forecasts of climatologists, cocoa yields in West Africa are expected to decrease in 2026. Cocoa bean prices have already jumped at the end of June. How do you assess this situation? How can chocolate manufacturers prepare for such a development?

— Despite the fact that a good harvest was expected in 2026, the crisis did not end for a number of reasons: trees recover from 6 to 12 months due to El Nino, plantation conditions, diseases and climatic conditions. Due to the high price of raw materials, manufacturers spent money and made large stocks.

A small manufacturer has to plan their purchases strictly, and for this reason, a sharp price reduction is impossible. I will say about myself: because of the rising prices, I began to make a little less chocolate, because it is important for me to preserve its quality.

— They say that a possible rise in the price of raw materials will affect the cost of chocolate with a delay of six to nine months. Manufacturers can reduce the weight of the tiles and use cocoa butter substitutes more often. To what extent are such measures justified for the premium segment in which you work? What does a chocolatier do when cocoa beans become scarce?

— Most often, 85, 75 or 50 grams are made from hundred—gram tiles - they reduce weight and preserve quality. As for replacing cocoa butter, I think this approach is wrong, because the buyer pays not only for the taste, but also for the quality of the raw materials.

What I did was tell my customer how it was. People have asked me if there will be a price increase, as they read the news, which has already been prepared in advance.

— Major market players such as Lindt are experiencing the biggest quarterly loss in 17 years — consumers in Europe are no longer willing to pay for premium chocolate. The situation is similar for Hershey and Mondelez. Do you see similar trends in Russia?

— Companies that started their journey in the 19th century have gone through many difficulties and are resistant to change. They have extensive experience in managing risks and smoothing out sharp price fluctuations. I agree that the most important thing for the end user is a stable price. But in this case, I think we're talking about the stock's worst quarter in 17 years, not that the company became unprofitable.

Due to rising prices, everyone faced pressure on sales. In the premium segment, it is important to maintain the customer's trust, so I explain the reasons.

— How much does the crisis in the cocoa market affect small craft industries? Do they have any advantages over the market giants? How has the behavior of your customers changed against the background of all these events?

— People began to buy significantly less, but those who value quality remain. With higher prices for raw materials for craft producers, the price increase increases strongly at the final cost. It is important for me to maintain the customer's trust, rather than buying cheap raw materials. Basically, all my customers reacted with understanding.

— Chocolate prices in Russia, according to Rusprodsoyuz, have even decreased slightly since the beginning of 2026. What is the reason for this and how long, in your opinion, will this situation last? Should we expect a new price increase by the end of the year, and if so, how serious?

— Rusprodsoyuz reported a 1.56% decrease in retail prices by May 2026. In my opinion, the price has decreased due to a decrease in the global cost of cocoa beans. But the situation had changed by August. The cocoa market remains very volatile: after the decline, prices began to rise again amid concerns about the future harvest. Therefore, an increase in the prices of chocolates and sweets by the end of the year is quite possible.

— According to Rosstat, sales of chocolate bars in Russia in the first quarter of 2026 fell by 13%. At the same time, according to the Cooper delivery service, the number of orders for dark and bitter chocolate increased by 31%. How do you explain this paradox? What does this say about consumer trends?

— I think that people have become more attentive to the price and have become less likely to buy — this does not mean that a person has given up sweets. This is an interesting trend for small craft manufacturers. I can't compete with the mass market in terms of price, especially when raw materials have gone up in price. Therefore, my task is not to offer the cheapest product, but chocolate, in which the buyer understands the value of high—quality raw materials, taste and handmade.

— What do you think are the main selection criteria currently in the first place for the Russian consumer when buying chocolate?

— There is an interesting confirmation of this trend: an internal study by VkusVilla showed that for about half of the respondents, the percentage of cocoa was important, and artisan bitter chocolate 74% was among the fastest-growing positions. Therefore, I would put taste, quality and composition in the first place, and next to them the price. The customer has become more demanding, and now it is important for him not just to buy a product, but to ensure that the price matches the quality.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast