Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Gold remains expensive despite rising U.S. government bond yields. What does this mean for an investor

Gold breaks historical trends despite the Fed's tough policy
0
Photo: RIA Novosti/Ilya Naimushin
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Brief content

  • Gold holds high positions despite the Fed's harsh policy and rising real yields on US government bonds. Previously, high rates forced investors to get rid of precious metals that do not bring coupons and dividends in favor of profitable treasuries, but today this mechanism has ceased to determine the dynamics of trading.

  • The main driver of the structural shift was not so much investor sentiment and declining confidence in the dollar, as increased demand from global central banks: they are buying up metal at a record pace (China and Poland are especially actively increasing stocks). After the freezing of Russian assets in 2022, regulators in other countries realized the risks of dependence on the dollar system. Now gold is being purchased not so much to protect against inflation, but as an instrument that has no issuer and is completely protected from infrastructural blockages.

  • In the new reality, American government bonds and gold in official reserves have ceased to be competitors — now they perform different tasks in institutional portfolios. Treasuries provide liquidity and fixed dollar returns to capital, while gold guarantees the independence of reserves from the jurisdiction of other states.

  • The demand for precious metals will continue to grow, but this trend may affect other assets. Against the background of the capital flow into the gold—government bonds tandem, traditional conservative instruments will be at risk: low-yield real estate, dividend stocks and long corporate bonds of low credit quality. At the same time, forecasts for gold itself remain positive — Goldman Sachs expects the price to rise to $5.4 thousand per ounce by the end of 2027.

Gold breaks trends: the precious metal remains at historically high levels, ignoring the tight policy of the Fed and high yields on US government bonds. The usual dependence, in which rising interest rates in the United States played against the demand for bullion, no longer works. It's not so much that confidence in the dollar is declining, but rather that the demand for the metal from central banks has been too high in recent years. They are buying gold as the main insurance against geopolitical risks and blocking reserves. Why the usual interconnections in the economy are becoming weaker, how gold and American debts cease to be competitors, and what forecasts for the value of precious metals are in the Izvestia article.

Gold went up despite the rate hike in the United States

In September, an atypical pattern appeared on the gold market. On September 16, the US Federal Reserve raised the rate by 25 bps to a range of 3.75—4%, amid still elevated inflation. Usually, such a tightening of monetary policy creates pressure on gold: the higher the interest rates, the more attractive the instruments that bring fixed income become.

This is especially noticeable in the US government debt market. In September, the yield on ten—year Treasuries rose to about 5%, while thirty-year Treasuries rose above 5.3%. Moreover, not only nominal, but also real profitability increased: the yield on ten-year inflation-protected US bonds (TIPS) reached 2.93% by September 30 against 2.68% on September 16.

This is a fundamentally important indicator for gold. The metal itself pays neither coupons nor dividends. Therefore, an investor has to choose between holding gold with zero cash flow or buying a virtually risk-free U.S. government bond and locking in high yields.

Historically, the growth of real, rather than just nominal, rates has been one of the main opponents of gold.

But there are atypical dynamics in the market right now. Despite the sharp rise in real yields on U.S. bonds, gold remains close to historically high levels. Even after individual corrections, sellers are still unable to develop a steady decline.

By itself, this does not mean that the usual relationship between betting and gold has ceased to exist. A few weeks is not enough time for such a conclusion. But the current situation could be a turning point.

Why did gold usually get cheaper when interest rates in the United States rose

For an investor, the profitability of gold is formed due to an increase in the price of the metal, but by itself it does not create a cash flow: it does not pay a coupon, like a bond, and does not pay dividends, like a stock. Therefore, owning gold always has an opportunity cost: the investor refuses the income that he could have received in another asset.

When interest rates are low, this sacrifice is small. If government bonds bring in about zero, gold's lack of profitability does not look like a serious disadvantage. Then the demand for precious metals goes up, and with it its value.

And when bond yields rise, the opposite situation develops: gold becomes less profitable, investors choose in favor of bonds, and the precious metal loses in price.

A good historical example is the early 1980s. To combat inflation, American monetary policy tightened sharply, real interest rates became significantly positive, and gold entered a prolonged decline after its peak in 1980. The World Gold Council notes that in the last decade, rates in the United States have been one of the notable factors in the movement of gold.

Of course, all this time the price of precious metals has been influenced by other factors: the dollar exchange rate, inflation expectations, geopolitical risks, investment flows, purchases by central banks and the general demand for protective assets. However, despite them, the interdependence with real American rates persisted.

Until a few years ago, the World Gold Council estimated real rates above about 2.5% as the level at which pressure on gold has historically become particularly significant. Now the yield of ten-year TIPS is already about 3%. However, the precious metal does not show a corresponding decrease. This means that other factors are now having a more significant impact on gold prices than before.

The first factor: is the market waiting for the dollar to depreciate?

The first explanation for what is happening is that investors may fear that high yields on U.S. bonds will not be able to compensate for the future loss of purchasing power of the dollar. The US national debt is rising, inflation remains above the Fed's target, and high borrowing costs are increasing budget debt service costs. In such a situation, gold can be considered as insurance against the gradual depreciation of money.

On the other hand, the bond market itself does not yet show expectations of uncontrolled inflation.

One of the most useful indicators here is breakeven inflation. It shows the difference between the yields of ordinary Treasury bonds and inflation-protected TIPS, and thus allows you to estimate approximately what average inflation the market expects on the appropriate horizon. On October 1, the ten-year breakeven was only 2.36%.

Probably, by buying gold, even despite the real yields that treasuries offer, investors insure themselves against those risks that cannot be expressed only by the depreciation of money. It offers the investor another property: the absence of an issuer and a counter obligation.

The second factor is that people are buying gold not only for the sake of profitability

There is another explanation for gold's resilience despite the increasingly lucrative U.S. government bonds. These assets cannot be compared only in terms of profitability.

Gold does not have an issuer that must repay the debt in 10 years, which means there is no second party (bond seller) whose financial situation needs to be assessed.

1

The bond is bought primarily for the sake of future cash flow and capital preservation within the dollar financial system. Gold can be purchased as a reserve of value that exists outside the balance sheet of a particular state, bank or company.

That is why the demand from central banks is particularly interesting. According to the World Gold Council, in 2025, regulators from different countries purchased a total of 863 tons of gold. This is less than the record volumes of the previous three years, but still significantly higher than the average level of 2010-2021 (then it was about 473 tons per year). Purchases continued in the first half of 2026.

Moreover, the central banks themselves explain quite directly what they value in the metal. In the World Gold Council survey, gold's ability to preserve value in a crisis, portfolio diversification, lack of default risk, and its historical role as a store of value were the most frequently mentioned among reserve managers. In other words, central banks, when choosing assets for reserves, pose a broader pool of issues than profitability.

For the central bank, Gold and Treasury solve different tasks. Treasuries provide liquidity and profitability. Gold reduces the dependence of part of reserves on the obligations of other states and financial institutions.

Thus, rising U.S. bond yields do attract capital — they just don't eliminate the need for gold. Treasury and gold are starting to perform different tasks and can therefore be in demand at the same time.

In this case, the old inverse relationship between real bets and gold has not necessarily disappeared. Rather, a fairly large source of demand has appeared nearby, which has become less sensitive to the level of interest rates. That is, now it is much more important for forecasts on precious metal quotes to understand who exactly continues to buy it today and why.

How much gold did the central banks buy

The increased demand for gold began to form a long time ago, but the real turning point occurred in 2022.

After the outbreak of the military conflict in Ukraine, the United States, the EU and their allies froze a significant part of the international reserves of the Bank of Russia. This set a new precedent for managers of government reserves in different countries: it turned out that an asset needs to be assessed not only in terms of profitability, liquidity and currency risk, but also in terms of whose jurisdiction it is located in and who controls its storage and settlement infrastructure.

In the same year, 2022, net purchases reached 1.1 thousand tons, a 55—year high against about 450 tons a year earlier. In 2023 and 2024, purchases again exceeded 1 thousand tons, and in 2025 they amounted to 863 tons.

China is especially interesting here. At the end of 2022, the People's Bank of China announced an increase in gold reserves for the first time in three years. Then, during November and December, he added 62 tons. By the middle of 2026, official reserves reached about 2,346 tons, and purchases continued even with a significantly increased metal price.

Poland is even more clearly a country that is a member of NATO and an ally of the United States. In 2025, the National Bank of Poland became the largest officially disclosed buyer of gold in the world, adding 102 tons. By the end of the year, its gold reserves reached 550 tons and accounted for about 28% of international reserves. Then purchases continued: by the end of the first quarter of 2026, stocks reached 582 tons. The target level of the central bank itself is 700 tons.

Russia, in turn, began to actively reduce the dependence of reserves on the dollar and accumulate gold long before 2022. Therefore, after the freezing of part of the Russian reserves, there was no sharp increase in physical gold reserves. Moreover, in the first half of 2026, Russia was a net seller of approximately 44 tons.

However, so far there is no talk of countries completely abandoning the dollar in their reserves. The share of "Americans" is still quite high, although it is gradually decreasing — according to the IMF, at the end of 2020 it was about 59%, and by the end of 2025 it was about 56.8%. Therefore, it is more accurate to call what is happening not a rejection of the dollar, but a diversification of dependence on it.

Which assets may be the "losers"

It is too early to talk about the final reversal of the former dependence between gold and US bonds. It's only been about two weeks since the Fed's September meeting. This is not enough to declare a structural shift, which may yet turn out to be a short-term market reaction.

But if you look beyond a few trading weeks, the role of gold is really changing. Previously, its attractiveness was largely explained by protection from inflation, falling interest rates and financial crises. Now another function is added to this — protection from jurisdictional risk.

That is why, in today's realities, gold and American Treasuries do not necessarily have to displace each other from the portfolio. They have different functions. Treasuries provide investors with profitability, dollar liquidity, and one of the deepest markets in the world. Gold does not create a cash flow, but it reduces the dependence of part of the capital on a specific issuer and financial infrastructure.

In this design, they become more like companions than competitors.

In this paradigm, it increases the requirements for other assets, from which funds from institutional investors and central banks can flow.

The main threat to other assets comes not from the growth in demand for gold itself, but from high risk-free returns. The more an investor can earn on U.S. government bonds with minimal credit risk, the greater the premium they will demand for owning less liquid, more volatile, or credit-risky instruments.

First of all, this applies to long-term corporate bonds issued by issuers of low credit quality. Such securities simultaneously carry interest and credit risk. The high yield of Treasuries increases the base rate relative to which corporate bonds are valued, and expensive borrowing worsens refinancing conditions for companies with a heavy debt burden. As a result, an investor may demand a higher yield, which means a lower bond price, for two reasons at once.

Another vulnerable segment is low—income real estate. While government bonds were yielding little, investors were willing to put up with low rental yields for the sake of a relatively stable cash flow and a potential increase in the value of the facility. But when the risk-free rate gets high, this compromise looks less attractive.

The situation is more complicated with dividend stocks. By itself, a high dividend does not make the company a loser from rising rates. Businesses with stable free cash flow, low debt burden, and the ability to increase profits and payouts can remain attractive. The so—called bond proxies are more vulnerable - companies with low growth rates, high debt loads and relatively fixed dividends, which investors bought primarily as a substitute for bonds. With an increase in the risk-free rate, their dividend yield should become higher to compensate for the risk of owning shares, and this may require a reduction in their market valuation.

Low-yield deposits or other monetary instruments, whose rates do not keep up with market rates, may also be under pressure. However, cash balances themselves cannot be automatically considered a "losing" asset: liquidity performs an independent function and gives the investor the opportunity to quickly respond to market changes. The problem arises only when capital remains in a low-yield instrument for a long time in the presence of a more profitable option that is comparable in risk.

What will happen to US rates and the gold price: forecast

After the September Fed meeting, the median forecast of FOMC members assumes a rate of 4.1% for the end of 2026 and the same 4.1% for the end of 2027. Only then does the regulator predict a gradual decline to 3.9% in 2028 and 3.6% in 2029.

The high rate means that American government bonds may remain an unusually profitable defensive asset in the coming years.

Now ten—year Treasuries yield about 5.2% per annum, and thirty-year Treasuries yield about 5.5%. Inflation-protected ten-year TIPS offer about 2.9% real return.

As for the forecast for gold quotes, there is a wide range of expectations. After the September rate hike, Goldman Sachs lowered its estimate of the precious metal's fair value for the end of 2026 to about $4,650 per ounce, but maintained its target of about $5,400 for the end of 2027. The main structural argument for the price increase is central bank purchases, which remain well above the levels typical for the period up to 2022.

The World Gold Council, in turn, gives more cautious estimates.: In his scenario analysis, while maintaining the current macroeconomic background, gold in the second half of 2026 may remain approximately in the range of ± 5% of the base level, about $4.1 thousand per ounce. In a more favorable scenario for gold, the WGC models an increase of 5-20%, and in an unfavorable scenario, a decrease of 5-15%. A more pronounced increase is possible with a weakening economy, lower rates, or a new increase in global risks; strong growth in the economy, rates, and the dollar, on the contrary, can lead to lower prices.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast