Why Morocco is increasing pressure on Spain after the crisis in Ceuta. Analysis
After the migration crisis in Ceuta, a Spanish city on the African continent surrounded by the territory of Morocco, a dispute over its territorial affiliation resumed between the two countries. Madrid has reason to believe that the mass migration of refugees across the border at the end of July was not accidental, but was intended to put pressure on it. Rabat denied involvement in the crisis, but recalled its claims to the enclave. Why the situation around Ceuta has escalated is in the Izvestia article.
What happened in Ceuta
- Two months have passed since the migration crisis in Ceuta, Spain, but its echoes still affect relations between Spain and Morocco, becoming a potential factor for tension. On the night of July 30-31, Ceuta, which is home to almost 85,000 people, experienced an invasion of illegal migrants from neighboring Morocco and other African countries. In just a few hours, up to 80,000 people entered the city on the southern shore of the Strait of Gibraltar. They swam through barriers, bypassed them along breakwaters, stormed border crossings and overcame a six-meter fence installed on the border. The law enforcement forces were unable to contain the flow of people and were forced to let them pass. About 140 people died trying to get to Ceuta.
- Soon, the overwhelming majority of the refugees returned to Morocco. On August 1, the Spanish authorities announced that almost 70,000 people had voluntarily left Ceuta. They faced difficult conditions, as there was not enough housing and food for everyone in the city, and there were no prospects — it was impossible to get to the Spanish mainland without documents, and the authorities were not going to legalize the status of new arrivals. Individual migrants were forcibly deported, and those who did not return voluntarily were threatened with a five-year ban on entry to Spain.
- The Spanish authorities reported that by October there were up to 5,000 migrants in Ceuta, although the mayor of the city, Juan Jesus Vivas, claimed that there could be 2.5 times as many. There are mostly unaccompanied minors in Spain who cannot be deported by law, and residents of sub-Saharan Africa who continue to hope for legalization. Temporary accommodation facilities have been set up for them, but there are not enough places in them, which is why migrants continue to live on beaches and in spontaneous settlements.
- Although the acute phase of the crisis passed almost immediately, the enclave has not returned to its usual life and is experiencing the consequences of the influx of migrants. On September 2, demonstrations were held in Ceuta and major Spanish cities against the government of Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez. He is accused of an excessively soft migration policy and an inability to restore order. Later, a new series of protests took place in the enclave itself, where local residents demanded that the border be strengthened and refugees not be accommodated near residential areas. Madrid responded by stating that the immediate expulsion of the remaining migrants is impossible without appropriate procedures, and allocated a €309 million aid package.
What is the role of Morocco
- Morocco's role in the crisis remains uncertain. Rabat denies involvement in organizing an unprecedented influx of its citizens into Spain and points to the absence of any evidence of this. Nevertheless, there is evidence that the Moroccan authorities did not prevent the breakthrough. So, the day before the crisis, the Spanish special services recorded on social networks the preparation of a mass transition and sent a warning to their Moroccan colleagues. This did not lead to the deployment of any additional forces on the border from the kingdom. The first reinforcements arrived after thousands of people had already arrived in Ceuta.
- The Spanish police and intelligence have indicated in their investigations that what happened cannot be considered an exclusively spontaneous event. They conclude that the Moroccan authorities have adopted excessively passive tactics since the first hours of the crisis. At the same time, Madrid avoided specific accusations against the African country and did not establish the involvement of any officials. In the future, the Moroccan authorities nevertheless took concrete actions to protect the border, when on August 15 and September 23 there was again a threat of a mass influx to Ceuta.
- Nevertheless, Spain does not absolve Morocco of all responsibility for the July influx. They tend to note some signs that the crisis was man-made. This is indicated by the fact that in 2021, with the aggravation of relations between Madrid and Rabat, there was already a similar incident. At that time, up to 9,000 Moroccans tried to enter Ceuta and Melilla, another African territory of Spain. Shortly before the current crisis, Sanchez traveled to Algeria, which is Morocco's regional rival, and this could be a reason to put pressure on Madrid. Given that up to 90% of the refugees immediately left Ceuta and did not intend to continue their journey to Europe, their influx is perceived precisely as a way to influence the Spanish authorities, demonstrating to them the possible consequences of the termination of border cooperation.
Why Morocco claims Ceuta
- Despite the attempts of the two countries to resolve the situation and prevent an escalation, a diplomatic confrontation nevertheless occurred. Moroccan Justice Minister Abdellatif Ouahbi raised the issue of the territorial affiliation of Ceuta and Melilla and recalled the kingdom's claims to it. He claimed the "historical and geographical" right to these enclaves and called for the creation of a bilateral dialogue mechanism to determine their future.
- Spain responded by saying that Ceuta and Melilla are an integral part of the country, and called any other approach to these territories unacceptable. Madrid refused to discuss the affiliation of the enclaves and summoned a Moroccan representative at the Foreign Ministry to protest. As a symbolic confirmation of Spain's position, its King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia will visit Ceuta and Melilla on October 13 and 14. This will be the monarch's first visit to African lands in the 12 years of his reign.
- The territory of Ceuta until the end of the late Middle Ages was under the control of various Muslim dynasties that ruled in the territory of modern Morocco. In 1415, Portugal conquered Ceuta. It is believed that this was the first case of the colonial expansion of a European power outside the continent. In 1580, Portugal united with Spain in a union, but it collapsed 60 years later. Portuguese cities on the African coast came under the control of the Spanish Crown. From 1694 to 1727 Ceuta survived the siege of the Moroccan Sultan Moulay Ismail ibn Sherif and remained a possession of Spain.
- In 1912, the territory of modern Morocco came under the protectorate of France and Spain. Paris got most of it, and Madrid got strips of land to the north and south. At the same time, the coastal cities of Ceuta, Melilla and Ifni, which were already under Spanish rule by that time, had the status of an integral part of the kingdom and were not considered colonies. In 1956, Morocco gained independence, and Spain transferred its protectorate to it, but retained three enclaves. In 1969, Madrid finally abandoned Ifni as part of its decolonization policy and transferred it to Morocco, leaving only Ceuta and Melilla in Africa.
- Madrid insists that Ceuta is inhabited by Spaniards and has been under its cultural influence for several centuries. In addition, Spain refers to numerous treaties with the sultans, who recognized its sovereignty over Ceuta back in the 19th century. Morocco justifies its claims to Ceuta by the fact that this territory historically belonged to Muslim rulers and is located on the African coast outside Europe, while Spain occupied part of the kingdom. The migration crisis has given rise to a renewed territorial dispute under the pretext that the Spanish authorities cannot fully control their own territory and ensure its security.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»