Beauty and the Beast: Why you can't remake the "bad Guy"
The "love will save the bully" scenario leads women to a therapist's office, not to a happy marriage. The craving for "bad guys" hides not only youthful rebellion, but also low self-esteem, codependency, and an attempt to "play out" childhood traumas. How to distinguish a rude but positive man from a man with deviant behavior, and why a narcissist and a psychopath cannot be reformed — in the material of Izvestia.
Victim, rescuer, aggressor
In psychology, craving for "bad guys" is considered as one of the stages of personality development, says Anna Guseva, a psychologist and senior lecturer at the Department of Psychology at Synergy University.
— This may be related to the search for thrills, an attempt to heal childhood traumas, or the habit of a familiar type of relationship (for example, if there was an emotionally unavailable father in the family). Such relationships are often based on the model of the Karpman triangle: victim – rescuer – aggressor, where a woman assumes the role of a rescuer, hoping that she will be able to change a man for the better, although this is impossible, says the specialist.
At the same time, Daria Serebryakova, a clinical psychologist and deputy head of the rehabilitation program at Dr. Isaev's Clinic, believes that the topic of "bad guys" should be considered in two aspects — psychological and social.
— There are a lot of men whom we call "bad guys" — addicts, bullies, people with criminal records, without permanent jobs. Their behavior and lifestyle are often based on mental instability, which makes a person unable to live and work normally, marginalized, and aggressive. The male psyche is vulnerable in principle," the editorial interlocutor notes.
The "bad guys" are active in making contact, they have more time to communicate with potential lovers, and this, according to the expert, increases their chances of a relationship. The main secret of such men is that they maintain long-term contact with women: they can constantly write, imitate violent activity.
— A classic example is the prisoners who do not skimp on words and compliments and the phenomenon of "waiting". The psyche is so arranged that a girl begins to feel that an assertive and sociable man is invested in a relationship. But in fact, he's just pulling the wool over his eyes. It is unlikely that a person will spend years on dating sites, constantly writing to someone if he has a settled life and constant employment. An unstable person who runs from relationship to relationship, engages in "murky" activities, and so on is more susceptible to this," explains Serebryakova.
From the point of view of a clinical psychologist, there are no more "bad guys" than good ones, but those who actively initiate various contacts benefit. Such men are more emotional, and the human psyche inevitably interprets vivid emotions as a predisposition to communication.
— It turns out a paradoxical situation. Some wonderful guy can also be quite "testosterone-fueled", active and sexy, but he is constantly busy: he has a job, hobbies, obligations, and his own tasks. In his free time, on a date, he sometimes does not have the resources to express his emotions vividly. And the girl subconsciously reads this as non—involvement in communication, lack of romance," the specialist points out the problem.
At the same time, it is important to distinguish a rude but reliable man from a man with deviant behavior, Anna Guseva emphasizes. Rudeness, according to her, is characterized by a harsh style of speech, but does not imply humiliation.
— A woman feels safe next to such a man, even if he is unhappy with something. And deviant behavior is a stable model of norm violation, control through humiliation, violation of promises, lack of boundaries, gaslighting, alternation of heat and cold. In a relationship with such a man, a woman is constantly in a cocked state of anxiety," explains the psychologist.
Women sometimes mistake external pseudo-activity (some kind of aggressiveness, rudeness) for the behavior of an alpha male who is able to protect his lady, Serebryakova points out. But in her opinion, it is very easy to check how much a man fits this image.
— We need to look at how he behaves with real offenders, with reputable people, with his peers and superiors, and not just with a waiter or taxi driver, allowing himself to talk down to them. When meeting a man, observe him in different situations, pay attention to the circle of his acquaintances, the clinical psychologist recommends.
Bad or good
Girls who choose bad guys are often united by low self-esteem, a chaotic childhood environment, incomplete separation from their parents, or just a search for adrenaline, Anna Guseva notes. And healthy relationships are usually built on respect, security, and the ability to be with another person. And if a woman finds herself thinking that she is attracted to "bad guys", and the "young lady is a bully" social model repeats itself over and over again, then this is a reason to ask the question: "What exactly am I looking for in this relationship?". Such a question is the first step towards freedom and a change in the plan of life.
— Most often, women in such cases say: "I'm attracted to the bad ones because they are bright, attractive, easy to be with, interesting to be with." But in practice, we are talking about feelings, as they say, on the edge, about some kind of drive, about emotional swings. And if a woman chooses an unreliable, unstable partner from time to time, then it is necessary to work with this, otherwise the situation will go in circles, the specialist warns.
Bad guys are often liked by women who grew up in a chaotic environment where love needs to be earned, according to the Izvestia interlocutor.
— They have low self-esteem, they have not separated from their parents, they are not ready for a serious relationship when it is necessary to build a mature couple. These women are actually in their teens — to find a "bad guy", go for a walk with him and go back to the absence of a relationship, she believes.
The psychologist focuses in more detail on women who are prone to the so-called playful style of love (ludus), which is characterized by lightness, flirting without serious intentions, and the ability to switch between different sympathies. Usually such ladies are attracted to bad men for the sake of entertainment.
— It's not about love, but about adrenaline and unpredictability. A calm, predictable partner seems to these girls to be something wrong, because it does not give vivid emotions and sensations. Sometimes a woman realizes that a serious relationship is important after all and marries a reliable and caring man, sometimes starting a parallel relationship with a "bad guy" on the side, says Guseva.
Even well-off girls who lived and were raised in a safe family and had a good parental example in front of their eyes are not immune from meeting a dangerous man. They are let down by elementary naivety. According to Daria Serebryakova, such women simply do not have the skills to recognize a crook, a liar, or a dangerous person playing a double game. However, sometimes inexperienced, but ready for risk and uncertainty, girls are let down by a lack of acute impressions.
— If life was too stable and predictable, and the girl lived in constant discipline and regime, then this may lead to the fact that her "shadow side" wants to find another "shadow side" to play some dangerous games, — the clinical psychologist does not exclude.
The "bad guys" themselves like women who are ready to save: it is convenient with such partners — there is no need to grow and change, they will always come to the rescue, the expert emphasizes. But if such a man really wants to change and is reaching up, he will choose not a lifeguard, but a woman who is not satisfied with his bad habits and lifestyle. Changes in this case are possible, but not always guaranteed.
Why can't you be a lifeguard
Over time, most girls go through a phase of infatuation with "bad guys." They begin to understand that love is freedom, security, relaxation, respect, and a willingness to grow and achieve something together. And then women look around for "good guys" — positive men who are determined to have a serious relationship.
"There are a large number of stable families and many examples where a woman has experienced an emotional storm with a dependent, unstable, aggressive man, and then found a calm partner,— comments Daria Serebryakova.
Sometimes it takes years and decades to communicate with bright, textured, but hopeless adventurers from the point of view of family life. When a woman decides to create a stable relationship, she suddenly realizes that all the promising guys have already been "sorted out by puppies," and only the dependent, mentally weak, unstable and infantile remain in free swimming.
— Sometimes a woman chooses a man with the understanding that he is somehow "flawed": addicted, alcoholic, unstable. And she has the illusion that he will not find anyone else and therefore will worship her, especially if she helps him. This raises both a woman's self—esteem and her sense of self-worth," explains the clinical psychologist.
In this case, according to the expert, the motivation is "bad, but your own". A woman secretly hopes that a man with some kind of "defect" will be grateful that she condescended to him.
— As a rule, this is an illusion. Such a character quickly begins to devalue a more successful woman. He gets bored with her. Yes, he needs her, and it's difficult for him to "detach himself from her," but at the same time he will be looking for someone else, even a virtual one, in order to level his self-esteem and appear more successful, Serebryakova continues.
If a woman still has to choose the best from the worst, then she needs to be prepared for the fact that she will have to "nurture" both her partner and herself to a certain level somewhere, the editorial interlocutor emphasizes. But this should not be done through rescue and codependency.
— First of all, from the very beginning, you need to build boundaries with a man, while showing that you value good healthy relationships, stability, and affection. This means that you need to be attentive to a man, understand his difficult experience, support him, but not solve his problems. You should also not be impulsive, rush into intimacy, or overly attached. And if he shows negative behaviors, then you need to set a distance," the expert recommends.
In her opinion, there are many examples when a "problematic" man meets a woman who understands him, with whom he feels comfortable, and turns out to be ready to change his whole life for the sake of this relationship, for example, to stop drinking.
— But, of course, this does not happen in conditions of "rescue", but in conditions when a woman "goes into the distance", makes it clear: "I am not satisfied with the way it is, and it will not be like that, and relationships are possible if you change your destructive patterns of behavior," he says. Serebryakova.
At the same time, Anna Guseva believes that one should not place high hopes on the fact that a bad guy will turn into a good one if he does not realize the problems himself and does not start working on himself with the help of a specialist.
— Dark personality traits (narcissism, psychopathy) cannot be cured by love — deep personal work is required. The role of a rescuer in this case is harmful: you cannot take responsibility for other people's changes. It is important to set boundaries and end a relationship if you are not satisfied with it — this is a reference point for the growth of both participants," the psychologist concludes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»