Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The expert assessed the risks of France's nuclear initiative for Russia

Political scientist Pankratov: France's nuclear initiative will increase risks for Russia
0
Photo: TASS/EPA/POOL/YOAN VALAT
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Profiler and political scientist Ruslan Pankratov appreciated the statements of French President Emmanuel Macron on the expansion of the French nuclear umbrella to a number of European countries. In his opinion, they should not be perceived as the immediate creation of a new automatic nuclear threat to Russia, but they create strategic uncertainty on the northeastern flank of NATO.

"Paris' statements and decisions do not create a new automatic nuclear threat for Russia, but a more dangerous thing — uncertainty on the northeastern flank of NATO. Emmanuel Macron's initiative is not a ready—made solution. However, the political significance of such a step is much more serious than its still limited military-technical form," the expert said in an interview with aif.ru Thursday, September 17th.

According to him, France retains sole control over its nuclear arsenal and the decision on its use. At the same time, the Finnish Ministry of Defense clarified that Paris does not offer the allies an alternative nuclear umbrella.

According to the expert, instead of clear guarantees, European countries are offered consultations, joint exercises and strategic signals, and in the future — the temporary deployment of elements of the French strategic air forces. This creates deliberate ambiguity.

Pankratov believes that the participation of European countries in such an initiative strengthens the nuclear component of regional policy. If it is followed by regular exercises, visits of strategic carriers or the temporary deployment of aircraft capable of carrying nuclear weapons, the military risks in the north-western direction for Russia, according to his assessment, will increase.

The expert also warned that France risks linking its own nuclear deterrence to any incident on Russia's borders with Finland or Estonia. In the event of a crisis, it will be more difficult for Paris to explain to the allies why the stated guarantees do not imply the real use of French nuclear potential.

On September 15, Nicolas Dupont-Aignan, leader of the right-wing "Stand Up, France" party, criticized President Macron's desire to extend the French nuclear umbrella to Finland and Estonia. The politician said that Macron had "gone crazy" because such an initiative, in his opinion, would make Paris vulnerable even to a minor incident on the border of these countries with Russia. He noted that nuclear deterrence is designed to protect France's vital interests, so the country should not be drawn into other people's conflicts. According to him, Paris must maintain exclusive control over its nuclear arsenal and independently make decisions about its use. kp.ru .

Prior to that, on September 14, Finnish President Alexander Stubb announced that the country had joined the French nuclear deterrence initiative, but had no plans to deploy nuclear weapons on its territory. He explained that the initiative does not overlap with nuclear deterrence within the framework of the North Atlantic Alliance. 360.ru . He stressed that "Finland has no intention of deploying nuclear weapons on its territory in peacetime," according to NSN. At the same time, Finnish Foreign Minister Elina Valtonen announced Helsinki's interest in expanding the "nuclear umbrella" to the whole of Europe, writes RT.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast