Own support: prosthetic industry is being reformed in Russia
The Ministry of Labor proposed to tighten the requirements for organizations that manufacture orthoses and prosthetics. The amendments are currently awaiting consideration by the government. Innovations are being introduced against the background of growing demand for the services of such organizations and, consequently, the emergence of new players on the market. Experts recognize the need for additional control in this area, but they are ambivalent about some of the innovations. "Izvestia" talked with experts about what is happening in this industry now and what the proposed changes mean for it.
Amendments to the law
The draft amendments to the federal law "On Social Protection of the Disabled" were presented to the public in March this year. The document concerns the work of organizations providing services for the manufacture of orthoses and prosthetics according to individual parameters.
Among the key innovations: the mandatory presence of specialists with medical education in the organization's staff, the inclusion of the organization in the register of rehabilitation organizations of this profile, and medical licensing.
"There are about 350 prosthetic and orthopedic organizations operating in the Russian market that manufacture prosthetic and orthopedic products, as well as about 240 organizations that provide hearing replacement services," the authors of the document specify.
The document also stipulates the availability of facilities that meet sanitary standards and are accessible to people with disabilities, the necessary equipment and the introduction of a quality management system to ensure that services are provided in accordance with the national standards of the Russian Federation.
The document has now passed public hearings and an anti-corruption examination and is awaiting consideration by the government.
If the bill is passed, some of the provisions may enter into force from September 2028, and some from September 2029. At the same time, from the moment the law comes into force until September 1, 2030, it is proposed to introduce a transitional period for rehabilitation organizations.
Changes in the market
The new rules have been developed against the background of significant changes in the prosthetics market, "Izvestia" interlocutors point out.
""The situation has changed after 2022: the number of industry participants has increased significantly, prosthetics services have become more accessible, but at the same time there is a gap between the number of players and the quality of their work," Andrey Generalov, Director of Development at Ortho—Innovations, told Izvestia."
According to his estimates, there may be about 500 similar enterprises operating on the market now.
These include organizations that manufacture prosthetics remotely without seeing the patient, do not take into account his lifestyle and activity level, do not prepare a stump and do not teach how to use the product. As a result of such unfair competition, both patients and organizations that invest in trained specialists and the necessary technical support suffer, Andrei Generalov believes.
Natalia Zakharova, head of the Scientific and Educational Center "Moscow Prosthetic and Orthopedic Enterprise", Candidate of Technical Sciences, agrees with this assessment.
— The fact that there are unscrupulous participants in the market is not a secret for the professional community. It is enough to look at open publications, reviews and blogs of people with amputations: they regularly raise issues of the quality of the receiving sleeves, inconsistencies in equipment, problems with warranty service and the actual inability to fully use the issued prosthesis," the source said.
The vector of further market development largely depends on how effective the quality control system will be in the foreseeable future, she emphasizes.
Required filter
At the same time, the innovations proposed by the Ministry of Labor caused a mixed reaction among industry experts and NGOs. On the one hand, the interlocutors of the publication agree that the growing market requires additional control, on the other hand, they fear how these measures will affect the availability of such services.
Natalia Zakharova considers the requirements of the Ministry of Labor to be justified from a technical and organizational point of view. In her opinion, they are largely based on practices developed during the Soviet Union. At that time, prosthetic and orthopedic care was traditionally built as a comprehensive model, including not only a production workshop, but also a medical unit, and when performing complex and atypical prosthetics, a specialized hospital.
"This model is determined by the very specifics of prosthetics: high—quality prosthetic manufacturing cannot be considered separately from a medical assessment of the condition of the stump, preparation for prosthetics, control of the fit of the receiving sleeve, dynamic fitting (especially in case of concomitant diseases), training in the use of the prosthesis and subsequent rehabilitation of the patient," explained the interlocutor of the publication.
In addition, according to her, the proposed amendments are confirmed by international practice — in particular, a strict certification and registry system operates in Germany, the United Kingdom, the United States and the Netherlands.
Andrey Generalov calls the tightening of rules a necessary filter that will allow unscrupulous players to be removed from the market.
People feel
All this may entail risks for small organizations operating according to high standards, the "All Together" foundation, which provides assistance to people in need of prosthetics, fears. They note that they work with a limited pool of prosthetic organizations, which were carefully selected based on the quality of their work and the feedback of their wards.
— Among these enterprises, there are small ones in which there is a prosthetist who may not be a doctor by training, but he is a very good prosthetist who has received a very high-class education as a prosthetist. People come back to him and come back, because he makes prosthetics superbly, they wear beautifully, people feel it, people come to him, — said Vlada Ivanova, head of the department of the wards of the Charity foundation "All Together".
Also, among the enterprises with which the foundation works, there are those where a prosthetist and an orthopedist work, or the prosthetist himself has a medical degree and performs the functions of an orthopedist. None of these configurations is a critical factor for quality patient care, she is sure.
— I would like to emphasize that the presence of a medical specialist at a prosthetic company does not affect the result at all. The quality is influenced by the prosthetist himself: what kind of experience he has, how well and where he is trained, and so on," the interlocutor of the publication emphasizes.
Nikolai Dedov, the head physician of "Protonik" prosthetic company, agrees that the number of unscrupulous players is growing in the market. But he emphasizes that the proposed innovations do not take into account the specifics of the industry. In particular, the difference between primary and repeated prosthetics, which accounts for a large percentage of referrals.
—If in the case of primary prosthetics it is really important to teach a person how to use a prosthesis, rehabilitate, and get back on their feet, then in the case of repeated prosthetics, speed, quality, and accessibility are important so that a person can do this somewhere close to their place of residence," he explains.
The medical care system already has a large number of specialists who manage a patient in need of a prosthesis: these are, in particular, polyclinic neurologists, orthopedists and rehabilitologists, and the prostheses and orthoses themselves are made according to the recommendations of the attending physician and doctors of medical and social expertise, the source reminds the publication. All this makes the introduction of additional medical specialists into the staff of prosthetic enterprises an unnecessary expense, which can have a heavy impact on the budget of a small enterprise, he is sure.
— If you put doctors in prosthetic workshops that still have to afford to support them, what will doctors do five days a week in prosthetic production? Besides, we already don't have enough competent neurologists and rehabilitologists, will they have to be removed from the outpatient clinic for this? — says the expert.
In small towns, it can be trite to find highly specialized specialists for such tasks: not every orthopedic doctor is familiar with the specifics of prosthetics and orthotics. Together with the costs of mandatory licensing (which will entail an increase in regular household costs), all this will eventually affect patients, Nikolai Dedov does not exclude.
"If we are talking about some private, small enterprises in small towns, then, of course, as we said, it will increase the price tag, because you will have to pay for the work of these specialists," the doctor notes.
In this case, the interlocutor of the publication is sure that large companies will benefit, which will find it easier to adapt to the new rules.
In direct contact with the body
If the new requirements are adopted, it is important to clearly separate the functions of a medical organization and a prosthetic company, Andrey Generalov emphasizes.
"Measures regarding licensing requirements and the volume of medical services provided to prosthetic enterprises should be taken with the understanding that prosthetic enterprises are not able to be full—fledged medical centers and can provide limited medical care," the source says.
The issue of classifying the prosthesis itself remains difficult. Vlada Ivanova and Nikolai Dedov draw attention to the fact that a prosthesis cannot be considered a medical device in full. At the same time, it cannot be considered a household product that is easy to assemble from suitable components, adds Natalia Zakharova.
— This is an individual technical system that works in direct contact with the human body and affects the load, movement, condition of soft tissues and safety of a user with a disability, — explains the interlocutor of the publication.
In this sense, the availability of such services is important, but it should not replace the requirements for the qualifications of specialists, medical support, manufacturing technology and responsibility for the result, summarizes Natalia Zakharova.
The main thing is that the requirements should be "reasonable and achievable" and work to increase the quality of services for patients, admits Andrey Generalov. However, in order to avoid decisions that will lead to undesirable consequences, it is important that lawmakers listen to market participants when developing a new system, he notes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»