- Статьи
- World
- Game of Thrones in Brussels: Callas and von der Leyen did not share the EU's foreign policy
Game of Thrones in Brussels: Callas and von der Leyen did not share the EU's foreign policy
France and Germany are preparing a reform of the European External Relations Service (EEAS). This means that the Kai Kallas department, numbering 5,000 people, can be absorbed by the European Commission (EC). There has been open hostility between the head of the European Diplomacy and the EC President Ursula von der Leyen for a long time. Details can be found in the Izvestia article.
Inefficient management
France and Germany plan to discuss the future of the European External Relations Service, headed by Kaya Kallas, at the level of EU leaders by the end of 2026, the Euractiv portal reports, citing a document at its disposal.
Paris and Berlin, according to the publication, propose to integrate the EEAS, consisting of 5,000 people, into the European Commission. In their opinion, such changes are needed to implement a "more expeditious, stronger and coordinated" EU foreign policy.
The document says that it was initiated by Germany, and then France joined, making certain improvements. At the same time, according to Euractiv, the positions of the two countries differed significantly. For example, in a later version of the joint document, Callas was recommended to be made "executive vice-chairman" of the EC — the proposal was made by Paris. Berlin, which is seeking to strengthen von der Leyen's chairmanship, did not plan for this.
The Financial Times, citing senior sources, reported in early September that plans were being worked out in Brussels to transfer part of the functions of the ECHR to the European Commission. It was assumed that Kaya Kallas and the foreign ministers of the EU countries would discuss ways to increase the effectiveness of this structure.
"It is obvious that the institute does not meet the requirements of the modern world. The problem is structural in nature, and the structure needs to be changed," the source argued, describing the state of the ERU as ineffective.
Abolish the structure
The first rumors about the possible dismantling of the ERU appeared at the beginning of this summer. As Western media reported, many in the European Union are unhappy with the work of Kai Kallas. In particular, she is considered too fixated on Russia and "makes a lot of mistakes." Some also do not like the position of the head of the European diplomacy in relation to Israel and the lack of competence in matters related to Middle East policy.
In addition, there has long been an open confrontation between Callas and von der Leyen over the levers of EU foreign policy management. As some diplomats joke, the confrontation between the bloc's institutions looks more and more like a "Game of Thrones" every time.
In practice, it is the president of the European Commission who has become the main mouthpiece of the EU on the world stage, while the head of the European diplomacy often does not broadcast the consolidated position of Brussels, but personal attitudes, causing growing irritation in the capitals.
That was the case last year, when Callas tried to push through a €40 billion military aid plan for Kiev, but faced stiff resistance from France, Italy and Spain, resulting in an eight-fold reduction in appropriations.
The peak of the hardware battle was the story of Callas' attempt to employ Martin Zelmayr, the former chief of Staff of the European Commission under Jean-Claude Juncker, in the structure of the European Union. Then von der Leyen, in order to thwart her rival, came up with the post of special envoy for religious freedom for him.
However, many are dissatisfied with the work of the President of the European Commission.: they complain about her "insatiability."
The situation is aggravated by the fact that both officials do not compromise, only increasing the degree of confrontation. Meanwhile, the EU's foreign policy requires consensus, which is quite difficult to achieve.
Currently, the issue of redistribution of powers in favor of national Governments is being discussed. In practice, the European Union is moving towards this scenario. But then it would become a legal confirmation of the absence of a unified foreign policy course.
Three possible scenarios
France offers three scenarios for the restructuring of the European diplomatic department. According to the first of them, it is planned to modernize the EEAS itself with the expansion of its mandate in the areas of trade and development. The second, more radical scenario returns the decision-making center to the European Council, where national leaders meet, making the EU's foreign policy more dependent on the capitals. The third way is to continue the reforms that began under von der Leyen in 2024: transferring key powers directly to the President of the European Commission, whose voice has recently become dominant in the international arena.
In other words, the redistribution of responsibilities will look like this: the EC is responsible for trade, humanitarian assistance, the conclusion of agreements, and also represents the EU in international organizations, while the EEAS, under the leadership of Kai Kallas, will implement foreign policy and defense strategies, which will be previously agreed upon at the level of the European Council.
Von der Leyen and Callas will find it difficult to reach a compromise due to the fact that both officials are henchmen of certain lobbying groups and structures and "suffer from careerism," said Natalia Yeremina, professor at St. Petersburg State University, in an interview with Izvestia.
— Kaya Kallas only works internationally. Ursula von der Leyen is also responsible for this area, so their powers often overlap. In theory, Callas should coordinate her actions, since she interacts with the head of the European Commission, but conflicts arise between lobbying structures and the foreign policy interests they represent," the specialist explained.
Meanwhile, Kamran Hasanov, a senior lecturer at RUDN University, Doctor of Political Science at the University of Salzburg, recalled that the European Union, created in accordance with the Lisbon Treaty of 2007, not only did not simplify and consolidate the EU's foreign policy, but also complicated it.
— Germany and France are unhappy with the inefficiency of the European Union, and the EU countries are annoyed by the complexity of coordination and duplication of functions between the External Relations Service, the European Commission and the national Ministries of Foreign Affairs. Critics want to increase the manageability of foreign policy and act as a "united front" against the backdrop of international crises, the expert explained.
He added that Kaya Kallas is doing a lot to lose support, besides, she is not good at building alliances in the council.
— But so far, the prospect of reform is not yet clear, since a consensus of the participating countries is needed to make changes, and Poland, the Scandinavian countries and the Baltic states may block the reform. The Lisbon Treaty on the creation and functioning of the EU may also stand up for Callas," the analyst concluded.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»