Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The European Union is experiencing difficulties with the production of fighter jets. And here's why

Guardian: Europe's plans to build fighter jets are in disrepair
0
Photo: Global Look Press/x99
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Attempts by the European Union to create its own modern fighter within the framework of the FCAS program have not been successful. Now the bloc is pinning its hopes on the success of the joint program of Great Britain, Italy and Japan to create a stealth aircraft, but the idea of autonomous fighter production for the European Union remains unrealistic. Why cooperation in military aviation does not work within the EU and how Brussels' policy affects it is in the Izvestia article.

Problems of cooperation

• Despite all the efforts of the European Union to consolidate the defense industry, the countries of the bloc have their own views on military aviation, which are very difficult to reconcile. A good example was the collapse of the ambitious Future Combat Air System (FCAS) project, designed by the joint efforts of France, Germany, Spain and Belgium to create a sixth-generation stealth fighter, attack drones, and a unified data exchange system called the Combat Cloud, a digital environment that would combine aircraft, satellites and drones into a single a network with ground systems. But already in June, Germany and France announced the termination of the project due to internal disagreements: Paris needed light fighters for aircraft carriers capable of carrying nuclear warheads, while Berlin insisted on conventional weapons, since it does not have nuclear weapons.

• Europe can produce fighter jets, but not in large quantities. And therein lies the problem: upgrading the Rafale fighter line to the new F5 standard by 2035 is stumbling over the volume of outstanding orders. By the end of 2025, Dassault's order portfolio included 45 fighters for France and 175 for export customers — it may take up to 10 years for the manufacturer to fulfill its obligations to customers. The slowdown in production is due to a shortage of components and an increase in the cost of raw materials.

• Due to the fact that each EU country primarily pursues its own interests, and they do not always coincide in matters of armaments, it is difficult for European manufacturers to scale production and pay for the release of new military equipment. Europe has missed the stage of independent development of fifth-generation fighters, and now none of the models produced by European defense concerns can reach the fighter jets produced by the United States, China and Russia. As a result, even the countries that participate in the production of European military aircraft refuse to purchase them. Due to the weak characteristics of the Eurofighter (a joint development of Great Britain, Germany, Italy and Spain) London has refused to purchase these fighters and is decommissioning them, replacing them with American F-35A.

Financing problems

• On September 3, the auditors of the European Court of Auditors published a report on EU defense spending, which shows that over the period 2020-2025, the bloc's spending on weapons increased by 80%. But due to inefficient planning at the Brussels level, years of underinvestment in the industry, acute dependence on non-European suppliers and logistical problems, it will be very difficult for the EU to achieve strategic autonomy and combat capability. The cost of production is also affected by the rising cost of energy resources and problems with their delivery, which arose due to the conflict between the United States and Iran and restrictions on navigation through the Strait of Hormuz. The situation is further complicated by the fact that the costs of the bloc's defense and support for Ukraine are financed by loans and an increase in government debt.

• Ukraine's support was also supposed to help the EU defense industry: of the €90 billion loan allocated to Kiev, two-thirds of the funds were supposed to be spent on the purchase of European weapons. But Brussels failed European manufacturers by allowing Ukraine to spend money on the purchase of American Patriot systems from September 8. This is an unpleasant signal for EU defense enterprises, which have already announced the expansion of production, but now risk being left without the promised orders. Germany immediately responded to this statement, reminding that the German defense industry "should benefit" from Ukraine's support.

U.S. influence

• The needs of EU countries for fighter jets are limited, and in order for production to be profitable, it is necessary to be able to sell products to other countries. But even here there are obstacles for European manufacturers: the Eurofighter fighter and the Swedish JAS-39 Gripen are critically dependent on American components and therefore fall under the American international arms trade Regulations (International Traffic in Arms Regulations or ITAR). This allows the United States to control the Gripen fighter program and restrict the sale of aircraft to other countries. Meanwhile, the disruption of deliveries is hitting the reputation and revenues of aircraft manufacturers.

• European fighters depend not only on American components, but also on software, which is also subject to US restrictions. The EU drew attention to this vulnerability of the defense sector after the outbreak of tariff wars between the United States and the European Union. Now the bloc is striving to achieve maximum independence from the United States in technology and materials, but the timing of achieving this goal is still vague.

China's Influence

• Modern fighters cannot be built without the use of rare earth elements, which China is leading in mining and processing: in particular, the production of one F-35 stealth fighter requires about 417 kg of rare earth metals. To join the race for the fifth-generation fighter, European companies are also forced to purchase rare earth elements and components from Beijing. After China tightened export controls on the United States, the requirements for European applications also became stricter: the Chinese side requests confidential data, which the EU defense enterprises regarded as a form of industrial espionage. Beijing has already threatened to cut off supplies of rare earths if they are used for military purposes.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast