The people of Iceland refused to discuss joining the EU. And here's why
Iceland rejected the idea of joining the European Union: 52.8% of the votes in the August 30 referendum were cast against the country's accession to the EU. The Icelandic authorities have promised that this decision will be final during the term of the current cabinet. Why the Icelanders refused to join the EU and how this will affect the plans of the European Union — in the Izvestia article.
The economic benefits are questionable
• The European Union is interested in Iceland's membership more than Iceland needs the EU. Iceland has the highest GDP in Europe: since the country left the union with Denmark in 1944 and gained independence, it has gone from one of the poorest countries in Europe to a welfare state and one of the richest countries in the world. For the European Union, Iceland's inclusion was beneficial because it would have become a donor country in the bloc. The last time the donor countries joined the EU was in 1994, when Sweden, Austria and Finland signed an agreement on accession.
The intention to join the EU in Reykjavik was formed after the financial crisis of 2008 and the subsequent political instability. The accession process has not been completed, but the country is a member of the European Economic Area and the Schengen area, which gives it access to the EU internal market and free movement of citizens to the countries of continental Europe. In 2025, the European Union accounted for 66.5% of all Icelandic exports. That is, the possible economic benefits of joining the EU for Iceland are insignificant, but the country's contributions to the EU will increase significantly.
• Supporters of EU membership argued that joining the eurozone would help contain inflation within Iceland. The Icelandic krona is very volatile and unstable to economic shocks, which poses a serious risk in an open economy. Currently, the central bank of Iceland's rate is 8%, while in the European Union it is 2.25%, which means that joining the EU could improve the mortgage lending situation. But as part of the bloc, Reykjavik would lose the opportunity to pursue its own monetary policy based on the situation inside the country, and would depend on the decisions of the European Central Bank.
Risk to fisheries and agriculture
• It was the issue of fishing in 2013 that led to the suspension of Iceland's European integration, which at that time had opened 27 negotiating sections out of 35 for EU membership. Fishing is of key importance for Iceland: fish supplies account for 40% of the country's total exports. Currently, Iceland manages its own waters and sets fishing quotas, and if it joined the EU, it would have to follow the quotas set by Brussels and open equal access to fishing waters for companies from other European countries.
Agriculture is another sensitive topic for Iceland. Due to the fact that the island's territory is not favorable for agriculture, and the cost of labor is one of the highest in Europe, agricultural production costs significantly more than in EU countries. If Iceland joined the European Union, local farmers simply would not be able to compete with products supplied from the continent, and this could lead to a large-scale crisis in the industry.
• The results of the referendum show that the issues of agriculture and fisheries remain the most sensitive even now: the majority of votes for EU membership were cast in Reykjavik (57.5% in the north and 54.5% in the south), while Eurosceptic sentiments prevail in rural areas: European integration was opposed in the north-western constituency. 62.9% of the participants in the referendum, 61.2% in the northeast, 60% in the south, and 53% in the southeast.
Risk of loss of sovereignty
For Iceland, which gained independence relatively recently, sovereignty is a sensitive issue. Currently, a country can independently manage its territory and resources, but after joining the EU, these decisions would be made at the EU level. At the same time, Iceland is a small island state that will not be able to form an effective representation in the European Parliament and influence important political decisions of the European Union.
Inconclusive defensive advantages
Iceland is the only NATO country that does not have its own army. It was assumed that joining the EU would give the state additional defense advantages, especially given the US interest in joining Greenland, which was perceived in Reykjavik as a potential threat, since the United States attaches strategic importance to the Arctic zone. But the results of the referendum showed that Icelanders still do not consider the country's security to be a serious threat, and the economy plays a more important role for them than defense issues. In addition, NATO is perceived as a more serious structure that is specifically aimed at defense, while the military capabilities of the European Union are still difficult to assess.
Euroscepticism in Northern Europe
• The referendum in Iceland was closely watched by Norway, another rich Nordic country that the EU is seeking to include in its membership. The reasons why Norway is not ready to join the bloc — the Norwegians voted twice against membership in 1972 and 1994 — are the same as in the case of Iceland.: fear of loss of sovereignty and control over natural resources, and first of all, fish quotas. At the same time, participation in the European Economic Area already gives the Nordic countries a number of advantages that they do not have to pay for with sovereignty.
• For the European Union, which expected to begin a new process of expansion at the expense of the countries of the Arctic region, which is of strategic importance to the bloc, this is an unpleasant signal. After Iceland's decision to reject EU membership, it loses the opportunity to increase pressure on Norway, which is also part of the union's sphere of interests. The example of Iceland shows that EU membership is economically impractical for the Nordic countries, and in a period of global instability, maintaining sovereignty even for a small island state turns out to be a more profitable strategy.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»