Companies are introducing AI into the recruitment process. What you need to know
- Новости
- Internet and technology
- Companies are introducing AI into the recruitment process. What you need to know
The proliferation of artificial intelligence tools in the field of hiring has made it easier for applicants to send out resumes, but it has made it more difficult for them to access jobs. Although 49% of recruiters claim that the use of AI has improved the quality of job candidates, the lack of transparency of such technologies reduces applicants' confidence in the hiring process and the companies that use them in recruitment. How personnel services abroad and in Russia are implementing new tools and what are the prospects for using AI in personnel selection — in the Izvestia material.
The use of AI in hiring
• In the United States, AI agents not only formulate employee responsibilities and post vacancies, but also conduct interviews with candidates: according to the American developer of the Greenhouse recruitment platform, 63% of applicants in the United States had their first interview with AI, and 38% refused to work precisely because of the use of artificial intelligence in hiring employees.. The results of using AI are mixed: the fast food chain Chipotle claims that, thanks to the introduction of new technology, it has accelerated the search for employees and resume processing by 75%, while the Greenhouse study showed that 46% of Americans began to trust the hiring process less.
• AI tools are also used by job seekers themselves, who send out resumes using pre-programmed chatbots. Because of this, employers have to spend more time reviewing applications. The situation where users send resumes using AI without even reading the text of the job has become so common that methods are already being developed to combat such spam mailings: in particular, the startup Intrinsic uses a special hint in its ads that allows you to identify the participation of large language models in resume compilation.
• Scammers are also actively using AI tools by posting fake job ads. During the interview process with the victims who responded to false vacancies, the attackers steal personal data and funds. This type of fraud has become more widespread with the development of AI and remote work.
Disadvantages of using AI in recruiting
• The growing use of AI tools in recruiting has led applicants to lose confidence in companies and accuse them of lacking "humanity." AI-based tools can quickly analyze resumes and sort out the most promising candidates, but the quality of this analysis often raises questions. First of all, because AI algorithms rely on previously made decisions by the company, and if they were wrong, the AI assistant reproduces this experience.
• The activity of an AI assistant implies that it makes recommendations based on the most popular strategies, which increases the risk of discrimination against applicants. In the United States, in June, a court rejected an appeal by a software vendor, Workday, against which a class-action discrimination lawsuit was filed in 2023. The plaintiffs accuse the company of having developed an AI tool that screened out candidates for vacancies due to disability, gaps in seniority, as well as gender and race. The reason for such AI decisions may be data-driven learning reflecting pre-existing prejudices.
• Employers may not know what AI is based on when making decisions about applicants. At the same time, data quality is crucial, since such technology cannot find inconsistencies in the text and can "hallucinate" by mistakenly attributing non-existent achievements or skills to the candidate. Risks are also posed by the expansion of the AI model market at the expense of companies that do not adhere to a responsible approach to the field of artificial intelligence, which is why their AI tools can make numerous errors and distortions.
• According to the American Association of Psychological Sciences (APS), AI is unable to recognize human emotions, and therefore artificial intelligence tools cannot form an idea of categories such as leadership, motivation, stress tolerance, sociability and emotional intelligence, which are important skills for teamwork. Because of this, an artificial assistant may mistakenly reject a candidate, considering him insufficiently confident. Since AI is based on the company's history, automated subjectivity can form in its algorithms — bias, due to which AI filters out candidates who are different from the previous heads of the company's divisions.
How AI is used in hiring in Russia
• While 80% of employers in the United States use AI for hiring, including the largest 500 companies according to Forbes, in Russia this practice is not yet so widely developed. Only 5-12% of companies use artificial intelligence tools on a regular basis, and 42% do not use AI in recruiting at all. Most often, an AI assistant is involved at the stage of the initial selection of candidates: it evaluates the compliance of the resume with the vacancy and forms questions for the first interview with the applicant. According to Sber, the AI agent GigaRecruter was able to speed up the processing of job responses eight times.
• The peculiarity of the Russian AI market in the field of hiring is that companies are afraid of leakage of personal data, and therefore they are carefully implementing artificial intelligence tools. Large companies most often resort to AI-based tools, including because they have their own developments that allow them to use autonomous AI agents and avoid leakage of information about applicants. Another obvious reason is that large companies have a larger number of vacancies and are interested in optimizing the hiring process.
Prospects for the development of AI recruiting
• With the introduction of new tools, the format of recruiters' work may change, but it will not decrease. To avoid algorithmic bias, landlords will have to study the data that the AI relied on to make a decision about hiring or rejecting. In addition, systematic work with AI involves training HR departments to work with artificial intelligence and regularly clarifying recruitment parameters.
• Hiring employees using AI may turn out to be even more expensive than traditional manual recruitment, because the requirements for qualifications and skills of working with AI for personnel departments are increasing. Companies will also have to account for the costs of AI agent services and data security, which includes hosting an autonomous agent on their own servers or in cloud storage.
• When hiring employees, there will always be tasks that cannot be entrusted to an artificial assistant. Only a person can assess the motivation and personal qualities of an applicant at the interview stage, determine his ability to work in a team or the makings of a leader. Therefore, the use of an AI assistant at the resume selection stage will be most effective, but only a human can make the final hiring decision.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»