Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

A wave of discussion about the scandal of the Samost clothing brand swept through social networks. Employers did not want to give the employee time off due to the death of a close relative, threatening to dismiss her. The girl posted correspondence with the owners on social networks, bringing the conflict to the public field. An employee of the Tatmedia SMM department had done the same shortly before. The public outcry caused by these scandals has shown a working, albeit radical, way to resolve disagreements with management — the publication of messages and chats. But how legitimate it is to do this and whether this indicates the ineffective work of justice in labor disputes was investigated by Izvestia.

High-profile conflicts with employers in social networks

At the end of August 2026, a conflict between the owners of the St. Petersburg brand "Samost" (Old Baby Vintage) and their employee Tamara became widely publicized on social networks. According to the girl, she asked for time off due to the death of her grandfather, but the owners refused her, calling her an "infantile buzzer" and threatening to fire her for absenteeism. In the correspondence, the former leaders also claimed that the deceased grandfather would allegedly have been unhappy with the behavior of his granddaughter.

The girl posted her correspondence with the management on social networks, where she met a wave of support. After that, users began to cancel the Old Baby Vintage and write angry comments on the account of the brand and its owner Anna. In turn, the businesswoman and her husband stated that they had received threats and insults, and the store had to be closed.

телефон в руках
Photo: IZVESTIA/Polina Violet

This is far from the only such case. In May 2026, netizens discussed the scandal between Tatmedia's owner, Tata Budilova, and her former SMM specialist, who accused the employer of toxic management, overworking, and slave-like working conditions. And in February, Burger King Kazakhstan fired two managers who forced the dismissal of an employee with autism. The reason for the trial was a post by the young man's mother on social media.

Why are conflicts resolved on social media instead of through the Labor Dispute Commission and the court?

Against the background of the growing number of such cases, the following question arises: if employees use social networks instead of institutional tools, does this not indicate the inefficiency of the legal system? According to Alexander Asmirko, a lawyer at Chervets.Partners, the reason is not the flaws in the current legislation, but the difference in the speed and functions of the tools.

суд
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

"The term for consideration of a dispute in court starts from a month, in the Labor Dispute Commission (CCC) the term for consideration is 10 calendar days from the date the employee submits the application. The process is quite lengthy, formalized, requires an evidence base, and the execution of the decision is a separate procedure. The publication has an immediate effect. Reputational pressure acts faster than a court decision, although it does not create a legally significant result, for example, in the form of a binding order or court decision. These are complementary strategies rather than mutually exclusive," the lawyer explained in a conversation with Izvestia.

In the event of a conflict situation, the expert recommended that violations be recorded in writing and that the CCC or the court be contacted in parallel, using the publication as an element of the evidence base. At the same time, Asmirko drew attention to the fact that public outcry may cause inspections by regulatory authorities, since they are required to monitor the rights of citizens online.

суд
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

"It cannot be said that justice has become bad for employees. Moreover, it is quite obvious that over the past few years the position of the courts in relation to employees has improved significantly: the courts are trying to protect them. Even according to statistics, courts are more likely to side with employees than employers. I think the cases of conflict resolution through social media posts are related to the development of the Internet and more accessible ways to make the situation public," added Dmitry Kofanov, a labor lawyer.

Is it possible to make correspondence with an employer publicly available?

In this matter, it is necessary to refer to Article 23 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, which guarantees the secrecy of correspondence, and to Article 138 of the Criminal Code ("Violation of the secrecy of correspondence, telephone conversations, postal, telegraphic or other communications"), which establishes responsibility for its violation.

However, it is important to remember that the object of encroachment within the meaning of this rule is the intervention of a third party who is not a participant in communication. The party of correspondence that manages its own messages is not a violator, which means that there is no structure to Article 138 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Another issue is the application of Article 152.2 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, which protects the privacy of a citizen, including information about correspondence.

кодекс
Photo: IZVESTIA/Dmitry Korotaev

"Dissemination of such information without consent is generally prohibited, except in cases where it is carried out in the public interest. Refusal to grant leave due to the death of a close relative is a direct violation of Part 2 of Article 128 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation ("Leave without pay" — Ed.), which is imperative, and disclosure of such a violation may well be qualified as dissemination of information in the public interest. Nevertheless, it is impossible to completely exclude the risk of a civil lawsuit from the employer: the final assessment depends on whether the publication was limited to the fact of a labor violation or contained excessive personal information," Mikhail Romanov, a lawyer at Chervets.Partners, told Izvestia.

Is it possible to disclose the names of employers in correspondence published on social networks?

If the publication of correspondence in the public domain can be regarded as protecting public interests, then the disclosure of names is considered an unlawful act. Nicknames, first names, surnames and other data that identify a specific individual, by virtue of clause 1 of Article 3 of Federal Law No. 152-FZ of 27.07.2006 ("On Personal Data"), refers to personal data, the dissemination of which is generally prohibited without the consent of the subject.

клавиатура
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

"The disclosure of identifying information about the employer's officials goes beyond the minimum required amount of information sufficient to report a violation of labor rights," Romanov said.

Can an employer hold an employee accountable if an employee has made public a conflict with management?

In this case, it is necessary to refer again to the Civil Code, and specifically to Article 152 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation ("Protection of honor, dignity and business reputation"). According to it, a citizen has the right to demand a refutation of information discrediting his honor, dignity or business reputation, if the person who disseminated them does not prove their compliance with reality.

At the same time, lawyers note that the burden of proving unreliability lies with the plaintiff, and the reliability of the information is an independent basis for rejecting the claim. If the publication is based on genuine correspondence reflecting a violation of Part 2 of Article 128 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, there are no grounds for satisfying the claim under Article 152 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.

трудовая книжка
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

"Disciplinary liability under Article 192 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation ("Disciplinary penalties" — Ed.) is also unlikely: the list of grounds for its application is closed and related to non-fulfillment of work obligations. Public dissemination of information about a labor dispute, unless the trade secret regime is explicitly established by a local act — and information about vacation due to the death of a relative is not such, according to the definition of art. 3 of Federal Law No. 98-FZ of July 29, 2004 — cannot be recognized as a disciplinary offense. Dismissal for such a motive is highly likely to be recognized by the court as illegal," Romanov explained.

What should I do if I receive threats and insults from my employer?

The media war between "The Self" and Tamara Semkovich escalated into mutual accusations. The screenshots posted by Tamara show how the employer calls the girl an "infantile buzzer" and wishes her to "burn in hell." The owners of the brand "Samost", in turn, stated that after Tamara's publications they received insults and threats. In particular, some users allegedly stated that they were mining the store.

телефон в руках
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

According to lawyer Mikhail Romanov, threats from users of social networks are independent offenses, and the perpetrators are responsible for them. Therefore, it will not be possible to hold the employee who published the correspondence accountable for "organizing harassment." However, an employee may be punished if he has disclosed the employer's personal data.

"In the case of a claim for compensation for moral damage under Articles 151 and 1101 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, it is the disclosure of names that has led to a wave of threats that will become the most weighty argument of the plaintiff," the expert explained.

наручники
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

Lawyer Assirko pointed out that if insults or threats are received from an employer, including from officials subordinate to this employer, in response to a publication, this is an independent offense that involves the following types of responsibility:

  • administrative responsibility under Article 5.61 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation ("Insult");
  • 119 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation ("Threat of murder or infliction of serious harm to health");
  • compensation for moral damage under Articles 151, 1101 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation in a civil procedure.

Alternative ways to resolve the conflict without publicity

If, in case of disagreements with the management, an employee does not want to resort to publicity on social networks, as Tamara Semkovich did, lawyer Assirko suggested other solutions.

"At the first stage, it is necessary to prepare a written application addressed to the employer in any form. The application must refer to Part 2 of Article 128 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, which obliges the employer to grant leave without pay for up to five calendar days in the event of the death of a close relative. The application should be submitted under the delivery mark or sent by e-mail or via a corporate messenger. This will allow us to record the fact of the appeal and form an evidence base," the lawyer recommends.

заявление
Photo: IZVESTIA/Sergey Lantyukhov

If the employer refuses to satisfy the application or leaves it without consideration, it is necessary to consider the following methods of protection::

  • Contacting the State Labor Inspectorate (GIT): a relatively quick out-of-court procedure. Based on the complaint, it can conduct an inspection and issue an order to eliminate violations.;
  • contacting the prosecutor's office: if contacting the GIT does not give any results. Prosecutorial response measures are often more effective than those imposed by the GIT;
  • filing a lawsuit in court: a claim for the protection of labor rights, compensation for moral damage; in labor disputes, the employee is exempt from state duty (art. 393 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation), which reduces costs;
  • contacting a trade union (if there is one in the organization): the trade union may represent the interests of the employee;
  • to send the employer a proposal to establish a labor dispute commission;
  • Mediation/negotiation: Pre—trial settlement through an intermediary is a less confrontational option if the parties are interested in maintaining the employment relationship.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast