The Supreme Court sided with Trump on the issue of voting by mail. What the media is writing
- Новости
- World
- The Supreme Court sided with Trump on the issue of voting by mail. What the media is writing
The US Supreme Court has overturned the decision of a lower judge who tried to block President Donald Trump's decree on voting by mail. The head of the White House wanted to impose restrictions on the work of the postal service for sending ballots to voters. The decree has not yet entered into force, and the congressional elections, which it may affect, are just over two months away. How the media reacts to the controversy surrounding the vote is in the Izvestia digest.
Associated Press: Supreme Court sides with Trump over mail-in voting
The U.S. Supreme Court has opened the way for possible enforcement of Trump's executive order restricting mail-in voting, although it remains unclear whether these measures can be taken before the midterm elections. This decision leaves room for additional lawsuits that could further slow down the execution of the decree. The conservative majority of the Supreme Court did not decide on the legality of Trump's decree, instead ruling that the states that filed the lawsuit had no legal right to challenge it.
Associated Press
"Although the emergency ruling is not yet final, it has the potential to cause chaos in the voting process across the country, as Trump often questions the integrity of elections, and the country's highest court may once again become the arbiter in political disputes. "The court's decision on this application does not mean that any measures taken by the government to comply with the ruling will necessarily be lawful. In this regard, time will tell," the majority of judges wrote in an unsigned ruling.
Trump's executive order, signed in March, obliges his administration to compile lists of eligible voters and instructs the US Postal Service to deliver voting ballots only to persons included in these lists. The new requirements, announced on August 21, prohibit the postal service from sending ballots by mail from any state that does not comply with Trump's decree. Representatives of the Democratic Party in 23 states and the District of Columbia filed a lawsuit to block the decree. They argued that the Constitution gives the states and Congress the power to hold elections.
CNN: what does Trump's victory in the Supreme Court mean for voting by mail?
At the center of the dispute is an executive order signed by Trump that gives the U.S. Postal Service an unprecedented role in deciding whether to mail ballots. This step followed years of baseless statements by the president about illegal voting by mail. However, the Supreme Court's ruling, issued despite the disagreement of three liberal judges, does not resolve the issue of the legality of Trump's proposal. The president's plan for the U.S. Postal Service remains blocked nationwide. In the future, the court will almost certainly submit Trump's executive order again for consideration, possibly within a few days.
CNN
At the moment, voters planning to vote by mail in the midterm elections do not need to change their plans. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court's decision provided the president with a procedural victory on an issue that has been central to his rhetoric for many years. And this is likely to introduce uncertainty for both voters and state election officials, who are hastily preparing for these important midterm elections.
The court's decision did not concern the legality of Trump's decree, but the timing of the filing of a lawsuit by 23 states where Democrats are in power, who challenged this decree. The conservative judges concluded that the lawsuit was filed too early because the Trump administration had not yet taken any steps to actually implement its plans. As stated in court, the decision does not mean that the president will eventually be able to implement the provision of the executive order concerning the US postal service.
Politico: The Supreme Court lifted one of the restrictions on Trump's plan to vote by mail
The Supreme Court lifted the block on Trump's executive order aimed at restricting mail-in voting, but did not clarify whether it would allow him to make significant changes to these procedures before the midterm elections. The judges voted by six votes to three, guided by ideological considerations, to lift the injunction imposed by the judge on Trump's order in June. The lower court's decision concluded that the president's plan to use the postal service to restrict the delivery of ballots probably goes beyond his authority and could disenfranchise legitimate voters.
Politico
More than 20 states that traditionally vote for Democrats have filed lawsuits to block Trump's executive order, saying it threatens to disrupt their plans for midterm elections in November and encroaches on their election-organizing powers. The conservative majority of the Supreme Court stated that these states have no grounds for a lawsuit, partly because it is unclear exactly how the administration will implement this decree, although [on August 21] the administration published the final rule of the postal service, which discusses more detailed details.
A controversial executive order signed by Trump in March directs the Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration to compile lists of U.S. citizens in each state and calls on state officials to send lists of voters who vote by mail and in absentia to the postal service, which will use these lists to block the delivery of ballots by mail to persons not included in the lists. The order also instructs the postal service to completely block the delivery of ballots for postal voting or absentee voting in states that refuse to share lists with the federal government.
Axios: Trump's decrees raise concerns about abuse of authority
Voting rights groups have argued that Trump's push to restrict mail-in voting could allow the federal government to control voting data and elections conducted at the state level. There are still questions about what will happen to voting by mail in the current election cycle. The Supreme Court has removed one obstacle to Trump's attempt to restrict mail-in voting, but a separate nationwide injunction has so far prevented this rule from taking effect.
Axios
The decision issued [on August 24] "is definitely not the end of this story," said Jonathan Diaz, director of voting rights and partnerships at the Campaign Legal Center. "It's not the Supreme Court saying, 'Yes, this order is legal and constitutional, and you can definitely comply with it by November.' It was just a technical decision regarding the timing of the district court's ruling."
Diaz added that states will still be able to sue the administration after the rule is published in the federal register, scheduled for August 26. According to Diaz, the Trump rule will disproportionately hit Americans who rely on voting by mail, including the elderly, voters with disabilities, rural residents, college students, and people who work multiple shifts. Voters facing sudden illness, travel, or hospitalization may also be at risk.
The Washington Post: The Supreme Court has eased the way for Trump to impose large-scale restrictions
There are just over two months left before the decisive elections, and the decision of the supreme court, which overturned the ruling of a lower judge who blocked the president's order, will not be the final word on whether its execution will be allowed. The case is returning to the lower courts, and a key part of the decree is still blocked due to a decision in a separate court case, which must also be reviewed in order for the decree to enter into force before November.
The Washington Post
If this decree is eventually passed, it is likely to introduce new uncertainty into the already tense elections, which will determine which party controls the House of Representatives and the Senate. Some representatives of the election commissions stated that the introduction of new important procedures in such a close period to the elections would not be an easy task. States are facing approaching deadlines for the start of mailing absentee ballots, and some of them will have to replace envelopes, train staff, and make other changes to comply with the order.
In their decision, the majority of the Supreme Court dismissed these concerns, but acknowledged that their ruling was not the final decision on the legality of Trump's executive order. Representatives of the states that filed lawsuits against the executive order promised to continue the trial. Thus, Arizona Attorney General Chris Mayes stressed that the decision was procedural in nature, and the states will continue to try to block the executive order itself.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»