Trump and silence: why negotiations between Belarus and the United States stopped
The dialogue between Belarus and the United States, which developed rapidly last year, has turned into a crisis. There have been no direct contacts for almost six months, and Trump's special envoy John Cole, who was a frequent visitor to Minsk, stopped coming to the Belarusian capital. Experts say that the sides have hit the ceiling and there is simply nothing to talk about in the current conditions. Izvestia investigated the situation.
The mission is on pause
Last year, the dialogue between Belarus and the United States acquired a certain rhythm. Once a quarter, representatives of Donald Trump came to Minsk, where they met with Alexander Lukashenko. The outcome of the negotiations has traditionally been the lifting of any American sanctions and the retaliatory release by the Belarusian authorities of prisoners convicted of participating in protests.
The last such visit took place in March, when Trump's special envoy John Cole made an Eastern European voyage. The result then was the easing of restrictions against the financial system — several banks and the Belarusian Ministry of Finance were withdrawn from sanctions. In response, Minsk released the largest batch of prisoners during the negotiations — 250 people at once.
It was expected that the parties would not only continue this work, but also intensify contacts. For example, at the same time, in March, there was a lot of talk about a possible personal meeting between Lukashenko and Trump. The Belarusian leader stressed that he considers such negotiations extremely important, so he agrees to visit his American counterpart.
However, as a result, it was not possible to maintain even the momentum that had been achieved. John Cole did not come to Minsk after his March visit: without explaining the reasons, he abandoned plans to visit Belarus in May or June. At the same time, the diplomat demonstrates optimism on social networks. In one of his tweets, Cole promised to secure the release of new batches of prisoners. In another, he wrote that his mission would continue.
Unofficially, however, there are signals of a crisis in the negotiation process. In May, Trump extended the sanctions against the Belarusian leadership, which were imposed back in 2006. At the same time, the Reuters news agency, citing its sources in the American administration, reported that contacts with Minsk and the release of prisoners had been postponed indefinitely.
From gestures to sanctions
Relations between the two countries have experienced several ups and downs during the years of Alexander Lukashenko's rule. The last sharp deterioration occurred after the presidential elections in Belarus in 2020.
As a result, numerous sanctions were imposed against Minsk, which were further tightened. In 2021, the situation worsened after a plane flying from Athens to Vilnius was forcibly grounded in Minsk. In 2022, the Russian ally suffered because of the beginning of its war.
A new stage began after Donald Trump came to power in the United States. He emphasized that in international relations he adheres not to ideological attitudes, but to a pragmatic approach. In addition, he called the reconciliation of Russia and Ukraine, as well as the containment of China, his task, and for these tasks a dialogue with Minsk was needed.
As a result, contacts intensified last year. At first, one or another representative of the American administration came to Minsk, and Alexander Lukashenko released one of the prisoners after each round of negotiations. For the Belarusian authorities, all this meant breaking out of isolation in the western direction, breaking the diplomatic blockade, and therefore they did not require more.
Last summer, the parties moved on. Donald Trump has appointed his special envoy to Belarus, John Cole. He also personally called Lukashenko and called him a "highly respected president," although Western leaders have not indicated the position of the Belarusian leader in the last five years. Finally, there was talk of a possible face-to-face meeting between the two politicians and a "big deal" between the countries.
Against this background, the dialogue has intensified even more. In Minsk, not individual prisoners began to be released, but groups of dozens or even hundreds of people. For example, in September, Lukashenko pardoned 52 people, 123 in December, and 250 in March. Many well-known figures from the events of 2020 were among them.
In turn, the Americans have moved from symbolic steps to lifting sanctions. In September, Washington relaxed restrictions on Belavia Airlines, which was allowed to receive and send money to counterparties from the United States. In December, sanctions were lifted on Belarusian potash fertilizers, which are the main export product of the republic. In March, the pressure on the financial system was eased.
With an eye on Moscow
There are several reasons for the current pause. On the one hand, the dialogue between Russia and the United States has slowed down, with which the contacts between Minsk and Washington were somehow synchronized. The visits of Trump's special envoys to Moscow have come to naught, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio last spoke in July at the ASEAN summit in Manila, but the meeting lasted only half an hour, no significant results were reported.
In such circumstances, it is logical to slow down the American-Belarusian dialogue. Washington has made no secret of the fact that they value Lukashenko, among other things, for his close communication with Vladimir Putin. Now it turns out that the need for such a communication channel has disappeared. In addition, Minsk is an important ally of Moscow, and an attempt to play an independent game against this background would raise questions in the Kremlin.
The second point is that the American—Belarusian dialogue has actually reached a certain ceiling. Washington lifted the main sanctions, while showing the limit of its capabilities. For example, restrictions against potassium were lifted, but it still did not go west. The fact is that the EU maintains sanctions, while Lithuania and Poland continue to keep their ports closed to Belarusian products.
Finally, the third reason is that the United States is simply not up to Belarus right now. Washington is focused on the Middle East conflict, all other regions have receded into the background. At the same time, it must be said that the parties are not breaking ties and are showing optimism. At the end of July, Belarus' permanent representative to the UN, Valentin Rybakov, announced regular contacts with John Cole, and the American special envoy promised to continue his mission in Minsk.
What the experts say
Belarusian political scientist Alexei Dzermant explains the slowdown in the dialogue with domestic American problems.
— Trump is embroiled in the Middle East conflict, and he has midterm congressional elections coming up. Accordingly, he is busy with internal issues. Our republic does not insist on negotiations, and it does not invite dialogue. Of course, we are interested in further contacts and the lifting of sanctions, but still this is not a priority issue for us," he notes.
The expert adds that the resumption of negotiations will depend on the situation inside the United States.
— If Trump loses political weight after the midterm elections, then the question will arise about how productive contacts with his administration are. Therefore, we will monitor the development of events," he emphasizes.
Vladimir Shapovalov, Deputy Director of the Institute of History and Politics at Moscow State University, explains the pause by the stalling of Russian-American contacts.
— Two negotiation tracks — Minsk – Washington and Moscow – Washington — are connected to each other. Russian-American contacts have stopped, and Lukashenko's ties with Trump's representatives have also been on hold. At the same time, I note that Belarus and the United States have achieved a lot. Relations have been unblocked, and the Americans have lifted the main sanctions. Yes, there is no current agenda right now, but it may well appear in the foreseeable future," he says.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»