Fired in one day: when is it legal and how to protect your rights
Being fired "one day" does not always mean breaking the law. The Labor Code of the Russian Federation provides for a number of situations when an employment contract can actually be terminated on the day of the commission of a misdemeanor or the occurrence of a certain circumstance, however, if the procedure is not followed, the employee has the right to challenge the employer's decision. How to protect your rights is in the "Izvestia" article
When is one-day dismissal legal under the Labor Code of the Russian Federation
Russian legislation does not contain the concept of one-day dismissal. At the same time, the Labor Code of the Russian Federation (TC) defines a list of grounds on which the contract is terminated on the day a certain event or misconduct is recorded.
Experts note that such prompt termination of an employment contract is possible in three legal dimensions, which include the commission of gross violations, the occurrence of circumstances beyond the control of the parties, or mutual consent.
"The first category is dismissal on the initiative of the employer for a single gross violation of labor discipline in accordance with art. 81 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. The employer has the right to issue an order to terminate the contract immediately upon documentary confirmation of the fact of absenteeism," Sean Betrozov, a lawyer at the Moscow Chamber of Lawyers and a member of the Russian Bar Association, told "Izvestia".
By absenteeism, the legislation means that an employee is absent from the workplace for no valid reason for more than four consecutive hours during the working day. Gross violations also include appearing at work in a state of alcoholic or toxic intoxication, and disclosing commercial or state secrets.
In addition, we may be talking about theft, embezzlement or intentional destruction of property. However, in such a situation, as the lawyer emphasized, the fact of the violation must be established by a court verdict that has entered into force.
"The second group of grounds is regulated by Article 83 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation and is related to circumstances that do not depend on the will of the employee and management," said Sean Betrozov.
In particular, an employment contract may be terminated on the day of the occurrence of the relevant circumstances when an employee is conscripted into military service. However, there is an important exception.
"The exception is mobilization, in which the contract is suspended by law," the lawyer explained.
Such grounds include the entry into force of a court verdict imposing a custodial sentence if continued work becomes impossible. Another reason is the recognition of an employee as completely unable to work in accordance with a medical report.
Dismissal without pay: when an employee can leave on the day of filing an application
The third option is not related to a unilateral decision by the employer, but to an agreement between the parties. 78 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation allows an employee and an employer to independently determine the date of termination of an employment relationship.
"The third option is termination of the employment relationship by agreement of the parties in accordance with Article 78 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation," Betrozov said.
In this case, the parties sign the relevant document and fix the specific date of dismissal. It can also be the day of reaching an agreement, if the employee and the employer voluntarily came to such an agreement. In addition, dismissal on the day of application submission is possible on the initiative of the employee himself in cases stipulated by law.
"Also, dismissal on the day of filing an application is possible on the initiative of the employee himself on the basis of Article 80 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, if continuing work is impossible for objective reasons," the lawyer said.
These reasons include enrollment in an educational organization, retirement, or a violation of the labor rights of a particular employee by the employer as established by the labor inspectorate or the court. In all other cases, the law prescribes mandatory advance notification.
When day-to-day dismissal is recognized as illegal
The very fact of dismissal on the day of notification does not indicate a violation of the law. The specific grounds for termination of the contract and the employer's compliance with the established procedure are important.
"Dismissal on the day of notification is guaranteed to be recognized by the court as illegal if the employer has no valid grounds or if the management has grossly violated the regulated procedure for disciplinary liability," said lawyer Betrozov.
The law establishes an absolute ban on the dismissal of an employee on the initiative of the employer during his temporary disability or vacation in accordance with art. 81 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. According to experts, if the dismissal order is dated to the period when the employee was officially on sick leave, this may be the basis for reinstatement. It may also be illegal to be dismissed for reasons that are not provided for by law.
"It is also illegal to dismiss an employee for far-fetched reasons that are not included in the law, for example, because of the personal hostility of the head," Betrozov stressed.
Even if the misconduct did take place, the employer must comply with the procedure for bringing disciplinary responsibility. Article 193 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation provides for the mandatory receipt of a written explanation from the employee.
"Even if there is a real misconduct, dismissal on the same day violates the requirements of art. 193 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. The employer must request a written explanation from the employee. The law provides an employee with two working days to prepare it," the lawyer explained.
Therefore, issuing a dismissal order before the expiration of the two-day period or before receiving an official explanation may result in the dismissal being declared illegal.
What to do if you were fired in one day: a step-by-step algorithm for an employee
After receiving the order, it is important for the employee to fix his position as quickly as possible and obtain documents that may later be required in court.
"Upon presentation of the dismissal order, do not refuse to sign, but write down next to your last name that you do not agree with the order, consider the dismissal illegal, and did not ask for an explanatory note. Specify the exact date and time of the review," recommends Sean Betrozov.
Next, you need to request documents related to the dismissal. 62 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, submit a written application for the issuance on the day of dismissal of a certified copy of the termination order, copies of acts of violations, income certificates and extracts from the workbook. The employer is obliged to provide them free of charge.
If the conflict is related to the accusation of absenteeism, it is necessary to separately record the circumstances of non-admission to work.
"If they try to accuse you of absenteeism and block your pass, make a video at the turnstile. Write down the contacts of colleagues who are ready to confirm your presence on the spot," Betrozov advised.
If access to the workplace is blocked, the lawyer recommends officially notifying the employer of the incident. However, receiving the payment and documents does not deprive the employee of the right to challenge the dismissal.
"It is the responsibility of the parties to receive funds and documents on the day of dismissal. This does not mean that the employee agrees with the legality of termination of the contract. These funds will be useful for the period of conducting a legal dispute," the lawyer noted.
How much time do I have to go to court if I'm fired?
If the employee does not agree with the dismissal, the key way to restore the violated right is to go to court. Contacting the labor inspectorate or the prosecutor's office may be important to verify the actions of the employer, but in itself does not replace a lawsuit for reinstatement.
"These agencies conduct inspections and issue fines, but they are not authorized to resolve individual labor disputes about reinstatement. The only body for returning a person to the workplace is the court," Betrozov stressed.
The circulation period is of particular importance. According to Article 392 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, an employee is given only one month to apply to the court for dismissal disputes. This period is calculated from the date of handing over to the employee a copy of the dismissal order or from the date of issuing the workbook or providing information about the work activity.
What happens if you skip the one-month deadline for going to court after you're fired?
Missing the deadline set by law can seriously affect the prospects of the case. At the same time, contacting regulatory authorities should not be considered as a substitute for timely appeal to the court.
"Missing a month's deadline without valid reasons entails a refusal to satisfy claims without considering the case on its merits if the employer declares in court that the deadline has been missed," said Sean Betrozov.
It is possible to restore the term, but only if there are valid circumstances. These include a serious illness of the plaintiff himself, confirmed by medical documents, or circumstances of force majeure.
"Contacting the labor inspectorate or the prosecutor's office is not recognized as a valid reason for missing the one—month deadline for filing a claim," Betrozov stressed.
Therefore, if you intend to challenge the dismissal, you should not wait for the results of an audit by government agencies. A claim to the court must be prepared taking into account the procedural time limit established by the Labor Code of the Russian Federation.
How to file a claim and what evidence to attach
A claim for reinstatement is filed according to the rules of the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation. It should describe the employment relationship, the circumstances of the dismissal, and the violations that the employee believes the employer has committed.
"The document details the circumstances of the employment, the nature of the conflict and the violations of the law," the lawyer said.
In the pleading part of the claim, you can claim reinstatement to your previous position, recovery of average earnings for the entire period of forced absenteeism and compensation for moral damage. The application must be accompanied by documents that confirm the employee's position.
"A copy of the employment contract, a copy of the dismissal order, salary certificates, as well as all available evidence are attached to the statement of claim," Betrozov said.
Work correspondence, screenshots of office chats, audio recordings of conversations with management, and information about witnesses can be used as evidence. Their admissibility and evidentiary value in a particular dispute is assessed by the court.
Do I need to pay a state fee in case of a claim for unlawful dismissal
Disputes about reinstatement are considered by the district courts as the first instance. The employee is given the opportunity to choose the place of treatment provided for by law.
"The plaintiff has the right to submit documents at the company's registration address, at the location of the branch, or at his own place of residence," explained Sean Betrozov.
A separate advantage for the employee is related to court costs. 393 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, when applying to court for claims from an employment relationship, employees are fully exempt from paying state duties and court costs.
What to do if you are offered to write a letter of resignation on your own
The employer may suggest that the employee write a letter of resignation on their own. For an organization, this option is often easier than conducting a staff reduction procedure in compliance with all the guarantees provided by law.
"The requirement of the management to draw up a letter of resignation on their own is a common way to optimize staff. In this way, organizations avoid paying severance payments when they are reduced," said Sean Betrozov.
However, the employee is not required to agree to such an offer. If the application is signed under duress, you can try to challenge it, but evidence of such pressure will have to be presented to the employee.
"A statement written under psychological pressure can be challenged, but the burden of proving the fact of coercion in court lies entirely on the employee himself," Betrozov explained.
If a conflict arises, it is advisable to translate all essential circumstances from oral to documentary form. This applies both to the requirements of the supervisor and to the employee's own performance of work duties.
"Any threats to be fired under the article for far-fetched misconduct should be responded to with a willingness to transfer the dispute to the legal field. Termination of the contract at the initiative of the employer imposes on the company the obligation to flawlessly comply with a variety of personnel procedures," the lawyer said.
According to him, it is important to preserve materials that confirm the performance of work and interaction with management. Lawyers advise you to turn on the dictaphone on your mobile phone during any oral conversations in the office of the head or HR department. You should also save reports, work correspondence, and official documents. Alternatively, use official communication channels or valuable inventory letters.
Is it possible to negotiate a termination with compensation
In the event that a person understands that he does not want to continue working for the company, but at the same time does not want to leave without financial guarantees, the parties may consider an agreement on termination of the employment contract.
"If a compromise is inevitable and you do not plan to continue working in this company, it is advisable to transfer the negotiations to the plane of Article 78 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, which regulates dismissal by agreement of the parties," explained Sean Betrozov.
It is necessary to record in writing the condition for the payment of monetary compensation for the termination of the contract. According to lawyers, in practice, the amount of such a payment can range from two to five average salaries of an employee. However, the specific amount of compensation is determined by agreement of the parties and is not an automatically legally guaranteed amount.
"Such an agreement is beneficial to both sides, as the employee is protected by a financial safety cushion, and the employer is insured against legal challenge," Betrozov said.
Is it possible to withdraw a letter of resignation and at what time
If the application has already been signed at his own request, the employee may still change his mind in certain circumstances. The main thing is to do this in a timely manner and in a way that will allow you to prove the fact of the withdrawal of the application.
"In a situation where the application has already been signed on its own accord under the influence of emotions, the employee reserves the legal right to withdraw it. This can be done at any time up to and including the day of dismissal," the lawyer said.
The withdrawal of the application should be made in writing and sent to the employer by a valuable letter with an inventory of the attachment and a delivery notification, or registered in the company's office with a mark on its copy.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»